5 ms·
Question from someone ignorant on the topic: if the US ever adopted a universal health care system in the future, would disclosures of 23andMe/Ancestry DNA to i
by keiferski 8y ago
Question from someone ignorant on the topic: if the US ever adopted a universal health care system in the future, would disclosures of 23andMe/Ancestry DNA to insurance companies still have negative effect? I’m assuming that under a universal system, it wouldn’t matter how severe your conditions are, as you’d be covered anyway.
- georgyo 8y agoA hypothetical health care system could be designed in all sorts of ways. While your gut feeling is likely correct, they could implement a system has reduced benefits for people deemed to costly to support. Or prioritize treatment of critical problems and not count preexisting conditions as critical. It is much more likely that everyone would be covered in the same exact way in my opinion though.
- MereInterest 8y agoAt that point, from a medical perspective, I don't believe so. The other main issue would be privacy, which would not at all be affected. Under the third-party doctrine, there is no expectation of privacy when individuals share information with a third party. Therefore, that information can be demanded by police without a warrant. Having the information collected into a central location (the insurance companies) would make it easier for a large number of these requests to be filed, rather than needing to track down individual services for each investigation.
- jahaja 8y agoThere's a lot of other non-health related insurances and more that depends on an assumed average lifespan. Mortgage/Loans, employment etc. One could become an second class citizen in such a dystopian future.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI recently watched the film GATTACA. I was shocked by how appropriate it was for our time. In the film, discrimination by genetics is, strictly speaking, against the law, but a matter of course because of how easy it is to get a sample and sequence someone. Humans are judged based on what's in their genes, not who they are. The synthetic, designed humans are classified as "valid", while those born naturally are "invalids" or "de-gene-erates". It would be quite easy for people of all walks of life to become second-class citizens due to information in their genomes if things do not change quickly.
- Someone1234 8y ago23AndMe/Ancestry don't reveal DNA information to insurance companies. Even if you opt into providing your DNA for research purposes, it is anonymized.
- swixmix 8y agoHow can my DNA be anonymized? It's a unique identifier to me and leaks traceable information about my family.
- Someone1234 8y agoBecause it impractical to tie the information found in the DNA back to you as an individual (e.g. name, social security number, etc). It is therefore impractical for companies to use that information to target you.
- sorokod 8y agoEven if it is impractical now, is there any objective reason to believe it will remain so in the future?
- Someone1234 8y agoThe sequenced DNA exists without any identifying information linking it to an individual. If they re-sequenced you and matched the two, they've gained nothing (since they had to re-sequence anyway), if they didn't re-sequence then they have no way of associating the two. So now, tomorrow, or into the far future the two piece of information cannot be re-associated because there's nothing to map them. The information about the link is lost. It is like asking "Can a lossy MP3 be restored to the lossless version if technology improves enough?" Nope. The information is simply gone. Same is true here, the associated link is just gone.
- Real_S 8y agoThis is a common misconception, but you are incorrect. These data can be used to identify you, therefore they are not anonymous. If a name is removed from a file that contains zip-code, age and gender, that data is nevertheless sufficient to re-identify most people. Removing a name from a data-base does not necessarily anonymize that data-base. DNA can be used to uncover your last name and ethnicity, estimate your height, hair color, eye color and more, so anonymization is not as simple as removing a name.