3 ms·
But many people automatically assume home ownership is a good thing... and the government officially promotes it as well (see mortgage interest deduction). You
by crazygringo 8y ago
But many people automatically assume home ownership is a good thing... and the government officially promotes it as well (see mortgage interest deduction).
You're right this is why mortgages exist, but you're not explaining the demand. It's also easy to imagine an alternate universe where most homes are owned by institutional landlords, people rent, and invest what their interest payments would have gone to in index funds instead, winding up with a more reliable chunk of cash when they retire instead of a home whose value is hard to predict.
- jimmy1 8y agoOwnership beats the hell out of renting. The key is owning something you can afford. The problem is people buy homes automatically thinking they will rise in value and they will make money off of it. Buy a home to live in.
- njarboe 8y agoWithout 30 year loans and low down-payments, areas where the rent is much lower than the cost of owning a house (like the Bay Area) would have much lower housing prices. Many fewer individuals would be buying and the investment firms would not be pumping up prices on a bad investment.
- nobodyandproud 8y agoYou see this anywhere. Take NYC's outer boroughs. Same block. Buildings built at the same time. The owner-heavy condos are in far better shape than the ones that are mostly rented. There is a huge social benefit to ownership.
- crazygringo 8y agoI live in Bed-Stuy. I just don't see this pattern at all. You can own your own home and not invest in maintenance too because you don't have the money, while landlords need to attract renters. I don't see any compelling evidence there's a trend toward live-in owners maintaining higher quality.
- closeparen 8y agoPeople who buy as their financial situation improves will naturally experience lower-quality rental housing and higher-quality ownership housing. That demand pattern shapes the housing stock, so ownership units will be nicer than rental units on average. But luxury apartments can be very pleasant, and price-competitive with ownership. In San Francisco these are very popular, servicing the legions of tech workers who have $3000+/mo to rent but not $5000+/mo to own.
- crazygringo 8y agoWhy does ownership beat renting? I live in an apartment in NYC. It's great quality and easy. I have total financial stability: I know exactly what I'm paying in renting this year. And little time commitment: something breaks, the landlord comes and fixes it. It's predictable and I don't need to think/worry about it. Whereas my house-owning friends in NJ suddenly need to shell out $5K to fix something I never heard of, and another $2K on maintenance of whatever, and it takes all weekend... sounds like a nightmare to me.
- snowwrestler 8y agoYour rent includes your landlord’s costs for financing, for taxes, for repairs. Unless it’s controlled by the government, your rent will go up as those costs go up. When you take out a fixed-rate mortgage, it locks the finance cost, which is by far the largest component, for the duration of the loan. That is better financial stability than renting, and a good inflation hedge. Repairs in a house are not that unpredictable. Every part of a house has a expected lifespan, and part of buying a house is getting an inspection that tells you where along that lifespan everything is. And again: you’re paying for repairs either way.
- sgc 8y agoThat universe is hard to imagine without legislation, because landlords will have mortgages and in general rent will be more than the mortgage, so in general it will always be cheaper to own than to rent. That this is not true in all markets only indicates that speculation is driving that market, and either non-market forces are restricting supply, or the market will likely self-correct.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> You're right this is why mortgages exist, but you're not explaining the demand. It's also easy to imagine an alternate universe where most homes are owned by institutional landlords, people rent, and invest what their interest payments would have gone to in index funds Not realistically, because the institutional landlords will charge purchase cost distributed over expected life + maintenance/operations/management cost + return that could be earned investing the purchase price as the minimum rent (plus a bit more, because the m&o cost is also a lost investment opportunity.) Otherwise, the institutional landlords would be better off just investing and not being landlords. The savings to the renter is (something less than) the difference between what the renter would have been forced to pay in interest and the returns the landlord is giving up by not investing elsewhere, and that's before even considering the costs associated with risk-based deposits or rent premiums charged by the landlord. > winding up with a more reliable chunk of cash when they retire instead of a home whose value is hard to predict. Even if true, is a certain home of uncertain value better than a certain cash value with uncertain residential rents? In the former case, you at least know you have a place to live. In the latter, you know the dollar value of an asset with no certainty of what it will provide. Which is more secure?
- snowwrestler 8y agoIf home ownership is a bad thing in this alternate universe, why would institutional landlords own and rent out homes? Why wouldn't they just invest all their money in index funds instead? Are they dumber than the renters or something? I think it's fair to say that any scenario that works out well for landlords, works out at least as well for home owners. Because when you buy a home, you become a landlord! (Even if your only renter is yourself...) As for why home ownership is a good thing, from a societal level, it's pretty well established that home ownership correlates to all sorts of good stuff like wealth development, better schools, lower crime, etc. But beyond that, a lot of people just like being in charge of their own stuff. Over-extending yourself financially is a bad thing, and it's true that some people do that in pursuit of owning a home. But, other people over-extend themselves in pursuit of owning a nice car, or trying to become a rock musician, or getting rich quick with cryptocurrency, etc. Home ownership certainly does not have a lock on the category of "things people sometimes make bad financial decisions about."
- chibg10 8y ago>As for why home ownership is a good thing, from a societal level, it's pretty well established that home ownership correlates to all sorts of good stuff like wealth development, better schools, lower crime, etc. I'm going to go out on a limb with no data here, but I'm fairly certain you would find the same correlations among people with equivalent wealth of any kind to that of homeowners. Home ownership as a path to wealth building at the societal level is fundamentally in conflict with the (more important imo) goal of affordable housing. This is especially apparent in a democracy... where homeowners tend to wield an enormous (and disproportionate) amount of political power (i.e. see NIMBY). So I would disagree that home ownership is desirable at societal level. Democratic society is better off when the default path to wealth building for the masses involves investing in productive goods (i.e. goods that create economic value.. such as the computer), rather than a good which both is necessary for everyone to live a decent life (though doesn't necessarily need to be owned) and only increases in value when there's a shortage of it for others.