5 ms·
This is more of a sidenote, but after having way, way more experience in healthcare system over the past few years, I thought I would share my experience. The
by jjeaff 8y ago
This is more of a sidenote, but after having way, way more experience in healthcare system over the past few years, I thought I would share my experience.
The Affordable Care act made some big changes in health insurance. Unfortunately, making it "affordable" was not one of the things.
But, if you do have money, you have the option now to have absolutely great health care.
For about $1300 a month, you can cover a family of 3 in california. That amount is less if you qualify for subsidies. And that is not a budget option. This is a premium silver PPO from a large provider. All your normal medical needs are covered with copays. $40 for doctor visits. $80 for specialists and $350 for an E.R. visit. Your max out of pocket is $7500 per person or $15k total. So $30,600 a year is your absolute worst case maximum that you would have to pay if everyone in the family had serious medical issues in one year.
Now, I agree, that's expensive. But we are on a plan like this and it is very good coverage (and it's likely not much more than companies pay for their employee plans). While sometimes navigating everything has been a beurocratic nightmare, it has never denied us coverage and almost every doctor we have come across is in network. It also pays about $600 a month (after $80 in copays) for our regular, ongoing prescriptions.
It also covered the $600 a month eyedrop Rx I needed for about a year for dry eyes.
The quality of care is top notch and we have never had to choose anything less than the absolute best when it comes to treatment.
Anyway, my point is, American quality of care is some of the best in the world. If not the best... If you have money.
- zaarn 8y agoIn 2017, the median income of households in the US was 61'000 $. Meaning half the population has to pay half their income (maximum) into this healthcare plan. And 61'000$ income isn't being dirt poor either. In some economic models this is the lower middle class in terms of income. For people who only graduate high school and no college, this is 80% of their income. If they go to some college about 70% (14'000$ left of the income). This group makes up about 30 to 40% of the US population. In my own country, I would pay 350€ a month for a 60'000€ yearly income. The equivalent of an ER visit copay for you and it covers all my medical needs for a month.
- tptacek 8y agoThe key idea in the ACA that addresses this problem is subsidies: you get tax credits and (ostensibly) CSRs to offset the cost of health insurance if you're within some multiple of the Federal poverty line. Unfortunately, this is exactly the part of the system Congressional opponents of the ACA have taken direct aim at.
- jjeaff 8y agoWith a multi-person household and $60k income, you would qualify for subsidies to reduce the premiums and out of pocket costs.
- tptacek 8y agoThe ACA reduced the rate of growth in health insurance premiums, but health insurance premiums continue to grow and have been for decades --- spiraling health care costs were a part of the Republican Party platform... in 1980. Guaranteed issue, community-rated health insurance is a necessity for a private health care system, and the ACA brought those badly-needed features here. But the big problem with US health care is simply that it costs too damn much to stay healthy, and those problems are structural more than they are a function of how we fund the system.
- kasey_junk 8y agoBut aren't those structural problems directly caused by the way we fund the system?
- tptacek 8y agoNo, I don't think that's even partially true. Medicare also overpays for care and responds to the same structural wackiness the rest of us deal with. Medicare has lower administration costs, but those costs are still higher than administration elsewhere in the world, and administration is not actually where most of our dollars go.
- kasey_junk 8y agoSo maybe I don't know what you mean by structural problems. I assumed you meant agency problems, administrative costs, medical professional pay, liability costs, over care & end of life care. All of which are directly impacted by how we fund the system.
- tptacek 8y agoTwo examples of structural problems with our health care systems: 1. We lead the world in transitioning from inpatient to outpatient care; for instance, I read a source last night that said the majority of hernia repairs in the NHS were inpatient, and the overwhelming majority of them in the US were outpatient. That's good, but an unintended consequence of it is that it's easier to route a patient to a surgical procedure if it's done outpatient, and as a consequence US patients get a lot more of these procedures, some of them (cardiac stents being a recent well-publicized example) of dubious utility. Our relative overconsumption of services doesn't lead to better outcomes, and thus represents misallocation. 2. Our health provider systems are more decentralized, delivered in smaller clinics and hospitals. Our hospitals generally, nationwide, have poor utilization. Not only do we therefore overspend on plant and salary costs (which we do, relative to Europe) but coupled with our price transparency problems we end up with the situation Atul Gawande described a year or two back, when he noted the insane difference in prices for an MRI at different imaging centers in a small region of (iirc) Texas. Our system right now isn't good and some of it (but by no means all of it) is related to how we regulate the way it's funded. But Medicare overspends on many of the same things. The structural problems will need to be corrected no matter how we design the rest of the system. Ultimately I think the problem in the US is a sort of perfect storm of badnesses. (Good sources: Kauffman's health cost explorer, the McKinsey report, the Health Care Cost Institute annual breakdowns).