3 ms·
This explanation doesn't separate the terms "tactic" and "strategy". In fact it mixes them together, he even says a tactic is basically a substrategy. If you'r
by lordnacho 8y ago
This explanation doesn't separate the terms "tactic" and "strategy". In fact it mixes them together, he even says a tactic is basically a substrategy.
If you're using recursion, that should be clear. Just call everything a strategy, or everything a tactic.
Fact is this distinction between these terms has never been real in any sense. People vaguely use strategy to mean "big picture" and tactic to mean "particular action", but if you decompose it you'll see more little strategies inside.
This is true in many game-like situations.
- Kinrany 8y agoThe following definitions make sense to me: it's a tactical game if the outcome merely determines how many resources the player will have in the next round, and it's a strategic game if failure means there won't be a next round. More generally, the problem with defining "tactic" and "strategy" smells like a case of false assumptions: they're orthogonal, not opposite.
- the_af 8y agoI tend to see it used like this: a tactical game is about the movement of the pieces/units and about winning this match without particular consideration for the next one, or considerations of logistics or use of resources. A strategic game is concerned with the overall campaign (did I win in such a way it favors the next match? Was it even a good idea to play this match? Did I use too many resources?) Indeed it's about high level vs zoomed-in detail.
- dhimes 8y agoIn other words, tactics are about how to win the fight. Strategy is about which fights to engage in to accomplish an overall goal.
- the_af 8y agoI can agree with this definition, though I'd say there is some degree of overlap; they are not completely separate. The Russians (and then, the rest of the world) defined an intermediate level and called it "operational". I suspect one could refine it even further.
- larrydag 8y agoI believe the point of the article is one person's tactics is another person's strategy and vice versa.
- barrkel 8y agoStrategy is the singular of tactics. Strategy is a route to a goal that occurs once in the domain. A tactic may be repeated multiple times for sub-goals when the same or similar sub-goals reoccur. A tactic might win a battle but a strategy wins a war. But if you're fighting multiple wars, then the strategies for each war are tactics, because there may be reoccurring elements in each war. It's the repetition and reuse that makes things tactical, practiced, routine.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- logfromblammo 8y agoTactics is that portion of decision-making applied to repetitive patterns and recurring situations. Strategy is that portion of decision-making applied to situations that are unique or unlikely to reoccur. Procedures are tactical. Decisions are strategic. In a chess match, the opening book is tactics, the mid-game following the combinatorial explosion of potential moves is strategy, and then the end-game is back to tactics, after the board has been reduced to fewer pieces. In the real world, breaching and clearing a modern urban building is tactics. Part of the squad covers as the remainder moves. Corners are checked before moving around them. Doors are checked before opening. There is still a strategic element, in that any given building will have a unique floor plan, but with sufficiently developed tactics, the strategy portion becomes somewhat unimportant. Capturing and occupying a specific city is strategic. The tactic of breaching and clearing buildings will be used many times in that strategy, and so too will the tactic of erecting concrete T-wall barriers and creating checkpoints, but the choices of where to start, and in what order to proceed, are all strategic. It is difficult to separate the terms, because every real-life situation will have some portion that can be matched to a general pattern, and some portion that represents the variance from that pattern.
- luckydata 8y agoTactics are the means used to implement a strategy.