4 ms·
> Brains fail at times. Computers should not make mistakes. I don't think this is a reasonable position to take. We are going to have to accept that if we want
by modeless 8y ago
> Brains fail at times. Computers should not make mistakes.
I don't think this is a reasonable position to take. We are going to have to accept that if we want computers to do the things brains can do, they will also make mistakes like brains do sometimes. It's not reasonable to insist that the error rate is exactly zero. Besides, if you consider the computer as a complete system including the hardware and human-computer interface, it's clear that no complete system can ever be error-free, even if the CPU executes its instructions faultlessly.
As long as it's as good or better than a human, it's good enough to be useful. Even with "fallible" AI techniques, we should be able to make systems that are much more reliable than humans.
- laythea 8y ago"...if we want computers to do the things brains can do..." That's my point though. I don't want computers to do what my brain does, mainly because I have no idea what my brain does, nor does anyone. Sure, some people think we do, but we don't. It also seems silly to try to engineer something that we know may fail (by design), on the probability that it may haphazardly produce better results (even if this is most of the time). That may be useful for things like search results, where the outcome is not critically important. Please excuse the example, but I would be happier passing away in an aircraft accident knowing it was because although the system was designed not to fail, we did our best in terms of understanding the systems in place. That would be my definition of "sh&t happens". If I passed away because the aircraft "AI" took an untested path of execution (there are too many to verify, unlike most regular "dumb" software), I would be less happy. Maybe there is a balance, Eg verifiable software for the important stuff, AI fluffery for the less so. But in that case, we should not get carried away (eg. self driving cars). Remember, planes could fly themselves completely for a long time, and we still have 2 pilots for a reason. Computers are a human's tool, not replacement.
- modeless 8y ago> I don't want computers to do what my brain does OK, that's a valid position to take, and I'm sure some people agree, but I and many other people do want computers to do what our brains do. And it is pretty likely to happen. > I would be happier passing away in an aircraft accident knowing it was [not AI] If I was in an aircraft accident caused by human pilot error while pilot AIs with 1/100 the error rate of humans were blocked from deployment because they don't meet your "zero errors" requirement, I would not be happy.
- laythea 8y ago"...I and many other people do want computers to do what our brains do" (emphasis, mine). I hear you, but my point is "what do our brains do?" In the case of driving, if the answer is "drive a car", then that is a bit like "brexit means brexit" :) The definition of the thing is the outcome of the thing. Instead, if you try to can decompose the question into a more useful form, one that can drive a specification of software, then progress can be made. However, all that has done, in that case, is a description of the outcome, not the process. (And incomplete, due to the complexity). It is at this point where my problem with all this AI stuff starts :) The lack of understanding of the process, rather than the outcome is why I call it voodoo, and anyone talking different is trying to impress, in my opinion.
- Jarwain 8y agoGenerally our brain is composed of a bunch of different subsystems and networks that accomplish varying tasks or objectives, and communicate the results with each other. There's a lot of data sharing going on, as well as reinforcement of known successes thanks to one subsystem known as the reward center. While we don't understand how our brain works to the bits and bytes, our knowledge and understanding of how our brain functions is Growing. A fuller understanding of how our neurotransmitters work on a chemical/biological level, and an effective way to model it, will likely result in interesting advances in the field of AI I chat with my neuroscience friend a lot, and the overlap I see between how he describes how the brain works, and general computer science concepts is surprising.
- nradov 8y agoHow many passengers died in the USA last year on Part 121 flights due to aircraft accidents caused by human pilot error? When do we expect to develop pilot AIs with 1/100 the error rate of humans? How will those pilot AIs cope with unexpected environment conditions or mechanical failures which aren't programmed in advance?
- modeless 8y agoObviously this is a hypothetical example and I cannot predict the future. If you want to talk seriously then take self-driving cars, where humans kill over a million people per year and we are very likely to have AIs that would kill less than that, but still a nonzero amount, within 20 years. In my view it would be unethical to stop the deployment of such AIs on the grounds that we don't "understand" them well enough or can't predict their behavior in every hypothetical circumstance, because we can still test them well enough to know with statistical certainty that they will save many, many lives.