5 ms·
I would expect the HN crowd especially to see the economy as a technical system. A fluid pipe line, perhaps. There are no ethics. Expect companies to do everyt
by solarkraft 8y ago
I would expect the HN crowd especially to see the economy as a technical system.
A fluid pipe line, perhaps. There are no ethics. Expect companies to do everything there allowed to. Disallow things you don't want them to do.
It's this easy.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIf people had absolutely no agency and the companies incapable of influencing the regulations maybe. It is far more complex including game theory and recognizing prisoner's dilemma in action.
- happytoexplain 8y agoThe system you've described is massive, complex, subtle, and slow moving at the scale of the United States. Why do you think it's easy? Additionally, you seem to be implying that its being easy would somehow invalidate any criticism of any action taken within the bounds of legality. Can you elaborate?
- fixermark 8y agoBeyond the United States---these "tax evasion schemes" exist at the boundaries of international law. That's why they continue to survive despite lack of popularity among citizens---no nation wants to blink and close the loopholes, risking the multinational companies will pull up stakes and take their jobs and tax base to the "competition" (in this case, other nations).
- happytoexplain 8y agoAgreed. I wish we could somehow all work together to fix these things. And as a bonus, if corporations actually paid taxes in a more straightforward way, there would be less confusion and deception in political arguments about corporate tax rates.
- simplify 8y agoThis is called the Freidman Doctrine [1], and didn't exist until 1970. Before this stupid idea got popular, companies were actually concerned with how their actions impacted society. They weren't the souless profit-seeking machines you see today. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine
- refurb 8y agoReally? Seems like the past is ripe with abuses by corporations - pollution, child labor, tax avoidance. I think you need to take your rose colored glasses off.
- simplify 8y agoI think you need to stop making personal jabs. I never said the past was perfect – that's a strawman. But it's self-evident that companies on average used to think contrary to what Freidman was proposing. That's why he was arguing for it in the first place!
- tivert 8y ago> Really? Seems like the past is ripe with abuses by corporations - pollution, child labor, tax avoidance. And before the Friedman Doctrine, they could be more easily condemned for their lack of social responsibility without the constant refrains that the only duty a corporation is to make money for its shareholders.
- gammateam 8y agoHow much a private company pays for infrastructure and protection has nothing to do with the Friendman Doctrine. It has to do with the consistency of due process from the group demanding payment. The only meme you presented was the idea that groups recognized as governments are a more respectable group to pay and secondly that their arbitrary levies are to be respected at any arbitrary amount. And that combination of ideas working together is pretty new, there is simply no reality to support the view of the world someone else convinced of when you were young. You can donate directly to the Treasury if you want to imagine more roads and schools are going to be built.
- thinkingemote 8y agoHackers have always been concerned about ethics.