7 ms·
I find it odd that being a big in a large market that isn't growing (like the mobile phone market) is seen as a problem. Why does the company need to grow if it
by nicoburns 8y ago
I find it odd that being a big in a large market that isn't growing (like the mobile phone market) is seen as a problem. Why does the company need to grow if it's profitable as it is?
I think what apple will find is that the market won't stand for their high-priced iPhones forever. If they have any sense, they'll notice this and put their prices down again.
- dak1 8y agoReducing prices almost certainly means reducing profit. Which means now they're in a market that is delivering shrinking revenues and profits.
- ProAm 8y agoBecause when you do not largely innovate, it doesn't matter if you are in a large market or not it signals grave danger. Apple knew this years ago when they started their large services push (i.e. collecting rent). Apple has a good challenge in front of them for the next 5 years, they have enough cash in the bank to ride it out and try some moonshots, but there will be some big changes/chances in the next 5 years, and I'd be willing to bet that Cook will leave as CEO by 2024.
- cobookman 8y agoInvesters could also ask for all that cash to be issued to them. See altababa / Yahoo for example
- ProAm 8y agoThat won't happen. Apple is still wildly successful, just not as successful as in the past. Yahoo was a dumpster fire for years, and thus people wanted the cash before Yahoo burned it.
- cobookman 8y ago> Apple has a good challenge in front of them for the next 5 years, they have enough cash in the bank to ride it out and try some moonshots, but there will be some big changes/chances in the next 5 years, and I'd be willing to bet that Cook will leave as CEO by 2024. I don't believe apple's shareholders would let them burn a singificant amount of their cash reserves for R&D over next 5 years...unless investors truley believe said R&D has solid ROI.
- wklauss 8y agoIt has been issued steadily for the last couple of years in the shape of buybacks and dividends. Will probably keep happening going forward.
- wklauss 8y agoI think this is a common misconception based on both the way innovation is perceived and the role it played in years past vs. the current state of the technology market. 1. Apple does innovate. Every year. But doesn't tend to follow fads or new technologies for the sake of newness and those tend to be confused with innovation all the time. 2. As markets saturate and the smartphone becomes an everyday object, the behavior starts to resemble the fashion and accessories industry where brand image, and customer loyalty plays a larger role in purchase decisions. If Louis Vuitton sales 10% less bags YoY in China, nobody thinks it's because they have not innovated enough in handbag technology. Apple is ok. At least as of now. They are still selling 84 billion $ worth of products on a given quarter.
- AznHisoka 8y agoIt's only a problem if you're a public company and have shareholders. If you're private, it's not really a serious problem if you have a large enough buffer to support current operations. I think Bloomberg is in the latter category. Revenues from selling their terminal have declined every year for awhile, but since they're private, they're not panicking as much.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThere are public companies that operate this way as well, like utilities. There is no reason a tech company couldn’t as well, but the stock price would need to drop to reflect minimal growth. No more 20x multiples.
- nemild 8y agoBecause for shareholders, the stock price only appreciates if the company grows. In many ways, it mirrors the issues for Hacker News entrepreneurs. To get VC capital, you have to dangle promises high returns on your equity — even if a consistent cashflow business is a great outcome for an entrepreneur (these businesses are pejoratively called "lifestyle businesses").
- zip1234 8y agoWhich is why dividends exist. Mature companies may grow less, but they produce profit, which can be distributed to shareholders in the form of dividends.
- avs733 8y agoBut that would require me to own the stock for months or years rather than milliseconds
- oarabbus_ 8y agoDividends are not some magic; they are taken out of the share price. There's not really a difference between reinvested dividends vs. no dividends at all. And non-reinvested dividends are less optimal as you'll pay taxes on them, so you actually have less net worth from collecting and not reinvesting dividends vs. either reinvesting them, or investing in a company which doesn't yield a dividend. It's a fallacy that many people fall for though. See Berkshire Hathaway for the prime example.
- nradov 8y agoSome public companies choose to return cash to shareholders through share buybacks rather than dividends because it's more tax efficient.
- ataturk 8y agoI don't know who is doing your taxes, but dividends, whether reinvested or not, are taxable in taxable accounts. Might want to look into that.
- thomasthomas 8y agoit's not "seen as a problem," the company just gets valued differently if growth is expected to slow
- ForHackernews 8y ago> Why does the company need to grow if it's profitable as it is? This is how capitalism works. Everything has to be growing all the time, or it's seen as failing. Requiring infinite growth on a finite planet is a problem, but so far all the alternatives are considered fringe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steady-state_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steady-state_economy
- abtinf 8y ago> Why does the company need to grow if it's profitable as it is? The word "profitable" covers wide range of possible outcomes.
- PeterisP 8y agoIt's current valuation is based on an assumption that the revenues will continue to grow significantly. If it turns out that in reality the revenues will be stable/stagnant, then the owners of Apple are in for a rude shock (since it'd mean that Apple is worth much, much less), would not consider this situation as acceptable, and would be ready to install new management and approve radical changes to try and continue growth (of both revenues and share value) by any means possible.
- coob 8y ago> It's current valuation is based on an assumption that the revenues will continue to grow significantly. Is it? It has a P/E of ~10, the same as IBM ('big and steady')
- tivert 8y ago> [the shareholders] would not consider this situation as acceptable, and would be ready to install new management and approve radical changes to try and continue growth (of both revenues and share value) by any means possible. IMHO, that's not "creative destruction," it's more "we had to destroy the village in order to save it." "By any means possible" will inevitably turn into short-term, customer-hostile actions that will erode the value provided by the company to society. Narrow focus on financial metrics by shareholders sometimes seems to be more of a destroyer of real value than a creator of it.
- alain94040 8y agoI agree, that has always bugged me as well. Growth is not the end goal, it's the desired temporary state for a company to make profits. Here's a serious question: what should the valuation be for a company that is not growing, but generating $X amount of profit year after year, with no risk, forever (and assuming the profit keeps up with inflation). Logically, companies are valued on their expected future profits. Since you want those to be as big as possible, growth in general is good. But at some point, in rare cases, a company may get so big that it has reached the point where it's just extremely profitable. Wasn't that supposed to be the end-goal?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stupidcar 8y agoI think what complicates it is that the shares themselves are a tradable commodity. The price of a commodity isn't just a function of the underlying value of the asset, but also expected change in price, the overall health of the economy, the attitude of other investors, etc. Many short to medium term investors may not care directly about profits at all, because they hope to make their money from growth in the price of the share as a commodity.
- nicoburns 8y ago> Many short to medium term investors may not care directly about profits at all, because they hope to make their money from growth in the price of the share as a commodity. Indeed, which breaks down the entire market rationale of capitalism right. It seems that we ought to put minimum hold times on shares. There shouldn't be any medium and certainly no short-term shareholders.
- module0000 8y agoThere are minimum hold times, otherwise 2 things happen: short term capital gains(high taxes), and the SEC flags you as PDC(high liquid capital requirements, compared to non-PDC).
- jahewson 8y agoA publicly traded company needs to either grow or pay an attractive dividend. Otherwise investors will put their money into companies which can provide those things.
- gmiller123456 8y agoAs several people have pointed out, the stock market investors care. But putting that aside, a company can be profitable with a stock price of $0 (though not likely). So at first glance it would seem that just staying profitable is enough to get by, and technically it is. But the problem is staying profitable. If a company has been growing rapidly, then the growth slows, then the growth stops, that's a big indicator that they'll start shrinking. Of course there is a non-zero probability that they will stay profitable for quite some time, but the odds are against them.
- oarabbus_ 8y ago>I find it odd that being a big in a large market that isn't growing (like the mobile phone market) is seen as a problem. Why does the company need to grow if it's profitable as it is? It's anything but odd. That's the basis of how the stock market works. If Stock XYZ is big in a large, not-growing market, and trades at $50 per share... why would the stock price ever appreciate?
- mikestew 8y agowhy would the stock price ever appreciate? Reinvested dividend money; see a sibling comment somewhere in here that addresses this. If the company doesn't pay a dividend, that money has to go somewhere, so it gets accounted for in the stock price (a vast oversimplification, yes).
- oarabbus_ 8y agoThat was likely my own comment; and it was comparing a company that didn't pay dividends to the exact same company which does pay dividends. In this scenario with equivalent cash flows, expenditures, and expectations of future growth the non-dividend company will have a higher share price. Share price _increases_ however only occur when the market expects the company to _grow_ revenues (profits), not sustain them. In other words, your comment isn't accurate, that would not cause the share price to increase. Only actual growth, expectation of growth, or market manipulation will cause share prices to increase.
- nicoburns 8y ago> why would the stock price ever appreciate? Why should the stock price ever appreciate?
- oarabbus_ 8y agoBecause profits are expected to grow or actually grow. Is this facetious?