6 ms·
This is a great move. Many pets sold in a pet store come from puppy mills which are terrible places. Even if a person wants a particular breed, you can almost a
by matwood 8y ago
This is a great move. Many pets sold in a pet store come from puppy mills which are terrible places. Even if a person wants a particular breed, you can almost always find a specific rescue. Rescues also typically stop people from doing stupid things like bringing an English bulldog into a house with small children. Which in turn ends up putting another animal into a shelter or rescue.
My wife volunteers for a bulldog rescue, and we have adopted 3 French bulldogs (in addition to many cats over the years). If my wife had her way we would live on a farm and adopt every animal in need.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoWhat makes a English bulldog different in temperament from an French one or some other breed of bulldog? One licks up spilled tea and the other licks up spilled wine? Edit: I actually want to know the answer to the first question.
- matwood 8y agoEnglish bulldogs tend to be bigger and clumsy which leads to accidentally hurting small children. Keep in mind too, that even though their fighting temperament has been bred out they were originally bred to fight bulls[1][2]. A bigger dog with strong jaws can seriously injure a small child in a single act of aggression. For these same reasons I also wouldn't have a pit bull in the house with a small child. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bull-baiting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bull-baiting [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulldog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulldog
- yellowapple 8y agoMeanwhile, I grew up with a pit bull / bull mastiff mix that we rescued. Nicest dog in the world (he sure looked mean, though, on account of him being a giant pit bull). Of course, it all depends on training. I'm with you on not believing an adult rescue in a house with a small child is a good idea. One you rescued as a puppy and made sure was well-trained, though? Sure, sounds like the perfect babysitter in canine form. This is true of most (probably all) dogs, of course. Smaller dogs thankfully do less damage on average, but they also tend to be a lot more inherently aggressive ("Napoleon complex" and all that; they have to be as a survival strategy). Especially as rescues, they're the ones more likely to bite small children, since even small children are bigger than them and more likely to severely injure them.
- bluedino 8y agoThose are two very different breeds. They have been bred into caricatures of a sort, incapable of doing their original intended job. They can't even breed on their own as they need c-sections to deliver pups. The American bulldog is a better example of a dog that is still capable of it's original purpose.
- warmwaffles 8y agoWhile I agree with you, I don't agree with the fact that the state should dictate the source of products to sell for a business.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cdumler 8y agoPlease stop and think before you write. Of course you do want the state to dictate sources. I suspect you want want your food to be regulated, your buildings to be engineered, your planes to be certified. Society places all kinds of restrictions on sources. It is also finally time we start moving away from pets being "products" and towards them being living things.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoNot the person you were replying to but I want my food, my buildings, etc to have acceptable performance. What is acceptable can roughly be summed up as "safe to eat and safe to inhabit" and I don't really care how that's achieved so long as the negative impact of whatever means are used is minimized. I have no special love or hatred for regulation. Regulation is also not a binary yes or no, on or off value. Something can be regulated not at all or regulated to an infinite degree. Regulation has a lot of negative externalities it places upon society and we need to be cognizant of those trade-offs when we use it. I'm generally very supportive of regulation that mandates transparency or that information be made available so that the consumer can better make their own choices (nutrition facts, those energy usage stickers on appliances, etc, are not perfect but solidly a net win IMO) because it tends to have very little by the way of negative trade-offs. I would really prefer to see CA try some sort of softer approach that nudges consumers toward the "right" pet purchasing decisions rather than going for the ban hammer right away. Edit: why is this an unacceptable opinion?
- warmwaffles 8y agoBecause this is the internet. Obey the echo chamber or suffer the consequences.
- gnicholas 8y ago> Even if a person wants a particular breed, you can almost always find a specific rescue. Is this true at a city level? There are many popular breeds and it’s hard to imagine that there would be sufficient inventory at all/most times.* > Rescues also typically stop people from doing stupid things like bringing an English bulldog into a house with small children. How so? Maybe if you adopt from a diligent rescue organization, but if the only organization in contact with the customer is a commercial pet store, the diligent vetting will likely go out the window. Note: I’m all in favor of rescue animals, and several family members have adopted rescues from petsmart’s years-old program. I’m just not sure statewide legislation is the way to go here.
- coldtea 8y ago>Is this true at a city level? There are many popular breeds and it’s hard to imagine that there would be sufficient inventory at all/most times. In that case, one has to settle for some different breed and not one of the more exotic ones. Oh, the humanity!
- matwood 8y agoIf a buyer is set on a particular breed, then the rescue location shouldn't matter. And yes, sometimes the buyer may have to wait for an animal. Commercial pet store != rescue organization. I used a rescue organization as an example of a way to find a specific breed if the local pet store or ASPCA didn't have one. Rescue organizations are also typically diligent as I noted.
- gwern 8y ago> Is this true at a city level? There are many popular breeds and it’s hard to imagine that there would be sufficient inventory at all/most times.* It's not. Expect more shabbos goys: "Dog Fight: Dog rescuers, flush with donations, buy animals from the breeders they scorn" https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2018/investigations/dog-auction-rescue-groups-donations/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2018/investigations/...
- learc83 8y agoAt many rescues the interviews are ran by people who are temporarily caring for the dog who are looking for reasons to disqualify you. The approval process is completely arbitrary and far too invasive. The president of the ASPCA was turned down by a rescue a few years ago, and he wrote about the process.
- scolby33 8y agoLink to a similar story I about the Executive Director of Greater Good being denied [0]. Also, a Washington Post article on the subject of adoption difficulty that mentions the ASPCA President’s rejections [1]. Thanks for sending me down an interesting path! [0]: https://greatergood.org/blog/2016/01/05/why-i-was-turned-down-by-a-rescue-group/ https://greatergood.org/blog/2016/01/05/why-i-was-turned-dow... [1]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/animalia/wp/2018/02/02/millions-of-dogs-need-homes-why-is-it-sometimes-hard-to-adopt-one/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/animalia/wp/2018/02/02/m...
- matwood 8y agoI completely agree that some of the processes are broken. Sometimes it's because of selfish reasons as you noted, but others are people trying to do what's best for the animal. Rescues are by no means perfect, but we should be careful not to ignore the good they try to accomplish.
- yellowapple 8y agoI mean, should they not be looking for reasons to disqualify you? Ain't finding red flags the point of the interview process? Sure, the interviewers would do well to relax a bit and not reject applicants for selfish reasons, but ultimately their job is to put a pet in a home with the best interests of that pet in mind. If even the ASPCA president can't sail through that process, then that's at least somewhat reassuring that pets ain't going to be placed in abusive/neglectful homes.
- learc83 8y agoIf all rescue interviewers were doing was trying to avoid abuse, I'd agree with your sentiment. But from what I've read and the experiences myself and my friends and family have had, rescue interviewers are more often than not looking for perfect homes not simply trying to avoid abusive/neglectful homes. Is it better to place a dog with someone who works 8 hours a day, or to euthanize it? (there are many people who'd say euthanize, but I disagree)
- clairity 8y ago> “If my wife had her way we would live on a farm and adopt every animal in need.” me too! i grew up out in the country for a period of my youth and the thing i really miss is the animals. and good on her for volunterring! i adopted a dog last year and just started volunteering in the kitten nursery of a local rescue organization (they’re so cute!). volunteering (and then fostering) is a good way to see the range of animals and their behaviors before you make a commitment and also streamlines the adoption process.