4 ms·
I cultured immortalised and primary cells during my PhD, and i came away with one firm decision about my postdoc: i would work on a model organism where i didn'
by twic 8y ago
I cultured immortalised and primary cells during my PhD, and i came away with one firm decision about my postdoc: i would work on a model organism where i didn't need to do this cringe-inducingly unphysiological practice!
There were groups at the university working on zebrafish and Xenopus tropicalis (a little frog), both of which are pretty sweet experimental systems.
Zebrafish are really easy to raise, and are transparent, so you can do live microscopy on them without having to do surgery or take explants. Someone i knew worked on a project where you zap them with lasers to cause wounds, and then watch immune cells respond to the damage.
Trops are more work to raise, and the embryo is not transparent, but they are the only vertebrate for which we have powerful classical genetic tools - it's naturally diploid (two copies of each chromosome, like humans, but unlike many other animals you might consider using), but if you produce embryos using sperm which has been zapped with UV light to destroy its DNA, they're haploid, and then if you block the first cell division with a cold shock, they're diploid, but with two identical copies of each chromosome [1], so sort of functionally haploid in a way which lets you investigate the effect of mutations really easily.
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4273174/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4273174/
- rleigh 8y agoAbsolutely agreed. My primary area of research was vascularisation, and I read a lot of zebrafish-based work and saw some awesome microscopy work at conferences. I would have loved to have worked with tools like this. It made my own efforts (3D collagen scaffolds with co-cultured HUVECS and smooth muscle) look utterly unrealistic and deeply flawed from the outset (which, in retrospect, they were).
- pvaldes 8y agouh? Zebrafish aren't transparent. They are white and stripped in metallic blue. Am I missing something here?
- dekhn 8y agothe embryos are. so it's great for studying early development.
- jonlucc 8y agoAs the other comment mentions, the embryos are, but also, you can get amelanistic zebrafish. This might be an interesting addition. You can't usually just buy zebrafish from Petco and use them for research. There are standards in animal facilities that determine whether your fish must be "specific pathogen free" or various other levels, and so you have to generally buy them from one of a few sources if you can't bum some from a beneficent lab. When we went to purchase embryos to set up a zebrafish colony (at something like $400 for 2 females and 1 male), the facility in Europe had suffered a fire that required them to stop production for 4-6 months.
- pvaldes 8y agoAs an aquarist I find this hilarious. For $399 you could hire an expert in fish pathology to check that the fishes are free from diseases and spend the other dollar into buying the real fishes, and put it in a quarantine tank then. > the facility in Europe had suffered a fire that required them to stop production for 4-6 months. This sounds very strange, unless you want to artificially create a scarcity in the supply of an animal that anybody can breed by thousands in their living room. You don't need almost any space to breed this fishes, and aquariums can be moved right?. 6 months seem too much. I wonder why nobody has tried with another of the 100000 species of fish with transparent embryos and bypass this money-grabbing structure.
- jonlucc 8y agoSure, you can hire the fish pathology expert (or send samples out to a lab), but our facility requires us to have "clean" fish coming in, so we can't do the exercise of breeding, treating, and certifying fish in our own facility. The same is true of mice and rats. We have many pathologists on staff who could certify such a thing, but it would require setting up a "dirty" facility completely separate from the "clean" ones (complete with a separate animal care staff to change cages and such). Overall, the price is justifiable to avoid the trouble. You wouldn't even need a different specie to bypass the money-grabbing, you only need a new facility, your own certified processes, and some clout in the industry (read citations). Hell, you could start with the fish from the expensive vendor and sell the offspring (I think, unless there's a licensing agreement involved).
- saati 8y ago> two copies of each chromosome, like humans, but unlike many other animals you might consider using Could you elaborate on this a bit? I tried to look it up but only found that some insect males are haploid.
- twic 8y agoThe thing i was thinking of is a rival frog, _Xenopus laevis_. That has been a classic model organism for research since the 1930s, and so ideally you would use that. But it's tetraploid - four copies of each chromosome. So are other related species of frog which are similarly useful. But not _X. tropicalis_ - that is basically "the Xenopus you can do genetics with!". Zebrafish are diploid (i think), but their genome underwent a duplication during evolution, so they have two copies of each gene on each chromosome (more or less), which makes them hard to do genetics on in the same way as being tetraploid does.