6 ms·
IMO Tim Cook did a good-enough analysis but deliberately omitted the rather insane prices of the XS and XS Max phones. Just look at the prices of the 256GB stor
by pdimitar 8y ago
IMO Tim Cook did a good-enough analysis but deliberately omitted the rather insane prices of the XS and XS Max phones. Just look at the prices of the 256GB storage models.
My wife's brother has a 6S Plus. My mother has 7. They work amazingly well and fast. To them X / XS / XS Max are basically "spend 1300 EUR to get a bezel-less phone and nothing else"... and in a way, they are correct. Many people don't care about FaceID or OLED screens.
Smartphone market is nearly saturated. It's time for more realistic pricing. And I am saying this is a loyal Apple user.
- interlocutor 8y ago> Smartphone market is nearly saturated. It's time for more realistic pricing. Just before Christmas I bought an iPhone 6S for $99 from AT&T. That’s a very realistic price for a very nice phone! Fine print: I had to pay $145 plus tax but $45 is credited to me for monthly charges. The phone is locked to AT&T for 3 months. After Christmas the price has gone back to $199.
- pdimitar 8y agoThat the 6S is going to be outside of software support window (1-2 years) and/or clearing stock might be factors. But I could have been clearer: I meant the newest models.
- interlocutor 8y agoAs an AAPL investor, I want Apple to raise prices for their top-of—the-line phones, otherwise the cheaper phones (like the one I purchased) will lower the average selling price. Of course people are not going to pay higher prices without getting something substantial in return. This is where Apple is lacking at the moment. The pace of innovation in both hardware and software has slowed down. There is plenty of room for improvement. EDIT Take a look at this video from Microsoft where they show how hover and squeeze gestures can dramatically improve the phone experience: https://www.theverge.com/2016/5/5/11595564/microsoft-3d-touch-kinect-gestures-windows-phones https://www.theverge.com/2016/5/5/11595564/microsoft-3d-touc... This shows there is plenty of room for innovation, Apple just isn't innovating fast enough.
- vatys 8y agoHover input on touch screens is cool tech but I’ve yet to see an implementation of it where it really added usability. More hidden UI just seems like more difficulty for average users. More hidden UI in a car seems like the absolute worst place to use such a hardware feature. Drivers should have their eyes on the road, not staring at the screen while they try to get their finger just the right distance to make some UI element pop up. Edit: the linked Microsoft demo is pretty cool, and could improve mobile devices, but is exactly what I was thinking should not be in a car control surface.
- joppy 8y agoHover is not necessarily more hidden UI, but could actually go to making bits of phone UI that currently exists more discoverable. A personal gripe of mine is that press-and-hold on a button is a terrible way of discovering something new, you’re never sure if the button is just going to perform its default action (which is something you may not want to do, and without a readily-available “undo” key is kinda dangerous). Hover could go a long way to improving this.
- jsjohnst 8y agoI have no written source to back this up, but based on a conversation I had with an Apple engineer, the first version of the iPhone way back in 2007 could’ve supported hover. Steve Jobs personally nixed the idea as he felt it wasn’t intuitive and thus we are where we are today.
- pdimitar 8y agoThere is a maximum amount of money people are ready to part with for status / stronger hardware / bigger screen / better screen / more storage / integrated experience / ecosystem / something else. And I believe Apple did hit that maximum back in November 2017. I spent 1400 EUR for my X as an early adopter so as not to wait 1-2 more months for sufficient stock in my country -- and gave the exact sum for my wife's X at the same day, so make those 2800 EUR in total -- about 13 months ago and it really tested my patience even though I am quite ready to invest solid money in good and reliable long-term tech (which mostly describes Apple's; I am also heavily eyeing the maxed out iMac Pro which sits at 14_000 EUR). I agree Apple -- and everybody else -- does little to no innovation in the smartphone sector but I don't feel that's the only factor. At certain point prices are so high that people refuse to buy and then do post-hoc rationalization. My wife's brother loves the idea of a bezel-less phone but he is not in a situation to spend the ~1000 EUR on an iPhone X or ~1500 EUR on an XS Max so he just said "screw that, it's not worth it". It seems that many others are doing the same. I don't necessarily disagree with you -- just adding that IMO there's a maximum price you should not test your loyal buyers with no matter how much can you sweeten the deal otherwise.
- mrob 8y ago>Many people don't care about FaceID or OLED screens. The OLED screen is arguably a downgrade because it uses flickering PWM brightness control.
- creddit 8y agoI’m not familiar with this. I have a X and haven’t noticed any flickering of the screen and really love it generally. Can you expand on this?
- _fzslm 8y agoThe OLED display on the X uses pulse-width modulation, which is basically where the OLED panel flickers at different frequencies to adjust its brightness. Most people (like me) don't really notice it, but for some it can cause headaches over prolonged use, and in some extreme cases really bad migraines.
- creddit 8y agoAh interesting. I definitely don’t notice it at all.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoNit pick. Pulse Width Modulation holds the frequency steady and varies the duty cycle, that is the ratio of on time to off time. See here for more info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse-width_modulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse-width_modulation
- kartickv 8y agoDoes this mean that the R, G and B values of any pixel is either 0 or 1 at any given instant? And how is it different from FRC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frame_rate_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frame_rate_control
- 8y ago
- bitxbit 8y agoYet it was considered acceptable to spend $4-500 on an email only device called Blackberry more than a decade ago.
- JeremyBanks 8y agoOnly for wealthy professionals. The smartphone market is a bit broader.
- jmtulloss 8y agoTheir revenue for those models were in line with expectations, so there was no reason for him to spend time on the issues that may be effecting that revenue.
- pdimitar 8y agoThat's a bit like the chicken and the egg problem though: did they project the iPhone sales correctly because they were aware of the high price? And couldn't they have reduced it a bit and project bigger sales numbers?
- jmtulloss 8y agoI think the point they wanted to get across was that they're seeing compelling evidence that China's economy is slowing dramatically. They mentioned the other things to establish that the revenue miss was not a mistake in modeling other factors. It's evidence for the broader point.
- alkonaut 8y agoI have a 7. I’m a typical dream-customer for Apple and my carrier in that I upgrade every 24months (Hand phone to a family member and get a new one). I don’t care about new features such as Face ID. I do look with envy at the X camera though. My next phone might be another 7 unless Apple drastically cuts prices or introduces an iPhone 9 with the X camera. There is no justification for adding 50-100% to the monthly cost of a smartphone in 2019 when it’s the first time I don’t really need a faster phone! Apple obviously realize that if they had a reasonably priced phone it would eat all their XR/XS sales, but the product strategy just looks like it risks losing customers to Huawei/Samsung.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoI think they were in the luxury position to try bumping up the prices a few generations; up until and including the X that strategy was successful, but now people are voting "no more". Or well, it's still selling, just not as much that it's causing Apple's revenue to keep going upwards. Apple is still one of the most successful companies in the world so I wouldn't call it a problem / failure just yet.
- pdimitar 8y agoYep. As I written in another sibling comment, there is a ceiling to what people would pay even if they love the idea of the device. And Apple has hit that ceiling. I know people who can easily buy 10x iPhones for their entire family and part of their relatives -- and they refuse. These are people who can spend $50k and almost wouldn't notice and even they think the modern iPhones have taken the price too far.
- Havoc 8y agoYup. Went and got a nice 2K tablet instead @250 usd. Overall much better utility improvement than swapping one iphone for another.
- Kerrick 8y ago> [...] we believe there are other factors broadly impacting our iPhone performance, including [...] US dollar strength-related price increases They did address this.
- pdimitar 8y agoIt's hard for me to believe that's the only reason. Apple has historically been VERY stubborn about reducing prices.
- donaldknuth123 8y agoAre there even mainstream apps that could take full advantage of the computing power in even say an Iphone 6? Most people are browsing the internet or using social media on their phones an Iphone 4 could do those just fine, there's very little gain for a consumer when upgrade these days.