4 ms·
Really? I'd just naively assumed that USB-C cables sold by Apple and Google would be universal. What is missing that they aren't universal? Is there some kind
by crazygringo 8y ago
Really? I'd just naively assumed that USB-C cables sold by Apple and Google would be universal.
What is missing that they aren't universal? Is there some kind of tradeoff between full power load and full data transmission capacity or something?
- justadudeama 8y agoUSB C != Thunderbolt 3 != Thunderbolt 3 < 1m, but all of them have the same port. Things like charging your phone can be done with USB C. Things like external hard drive are generally done with Thunderbolt Things like External GPU's have to be done with a Thunderbolt cable that is less than 1m All of that said, I am not 100% sure of all of that, because it is all so confusing.
- crazygringo 8y agoOK... is is just a Mac-only Thunderbolt issue then, which I guess you could kind of say is a problem with Apple and not with USB-C itself? If you ignore Thunderbolt, can you always rely on the latest USB-C cables Apple and Google sell working for everything? Or are there still issues?
- gumby 8y agoNo, this has entirely to do with thunderbolt and USB spec. Dating back to the early days of Apple, they have been hyper conformant with the spec (e.g. no drivers needed to connect to conforming devices). They still are. I answered your question about which cables above.
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoApple isn't the only vendor using Thunderbolt 3. According to Wikipedia [0], the following vendors have all shipped devices with at least one port: Acer, Asus, Clevo, HP, Dell, Dell Alienware, Lenovo, MSI, Razer, and Sony. This affects everyone. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderbolt_(interface)#Thunderbolt_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderbolt_(interface)#Thunde...
- jhasse 8y ago> Things like external hard drive are generally done with Thunderbolt Why? External USB drives are much more common.
- gumby 8y agoThunderbolt 3 is 40 Gb/s of PCIe + DP — basically exposes your bus out through a Type C connector. USB theoretically tops out, as of last year, at half tha, though in practice you won’t see anything faster than USB 3.0 (if you’re lucky) which tops out at 625 MB/s, before all the USB protocol overhead. TL;DR: USB drives are really really slow.
- jhasse 8y ago625 MB/s is "really really slow"? I don't know any HDD which can deliver more than 100 MB/s. And for SSDs there's also USB 3.1 Gen 2.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> though in practice you won’t see anything faster than USB 3.0 (if you’re lucky) which tops out at 625 MB/s 625 MB/s is 5Gb/s; the switch from bits to bytes seems to be a way to exaggerate the difference from Thunderbolt speeds quoted in GB/s; at any rate, USB 3.1 Gen 2 (equivalent to USB 3.2 Gen 2×1) 10 GB/s cables and device support isn't hard to find; I don't know that anyone had USB 3.2 hardware (controllers, or cables supporting the new 2×2, 20Gb/s, mode) yet.
- gumby 8y agoThe cable is not a dub set of wires; there's a a lot of silicon in the connectors. Though they fall back by default to the old resistor sensing used in earlier USB specs, the higher functions (which include power delivery) are negotiated. As far as I know a universal cable is not possible. My reading of the spec says that it should be but I am not a USB implementor and some of my friends who are tell me it's not possible. In any case nobody ships such a thing. The charging cables provided with devices are likely to be power-only. With the 87W charger, Apple ships ones that can carry about 100W (the maximum per USB spec -- 20V@5A) which requires thicker conductors; my understanding is that those cables don't carry data (i.e. they can safely be plugged into any third party brick without you worrying that the remote device will attack your computer). You want a power-only cable for this purpose. I am not sure of they have the same cable with the smaller adaptors. The very high speed cables only work over short distances unless you go to optical (which I'm not sure anybody has deployed). The most standard cables carry "USB 3.1" which is just another name for USB 3.0 carried over Type C connectors. The higher frequency and higher power cables are more expensive to design and build so will cost the customer more. That's one reason you have to specifically look for cables for DP, PCI-e/Thunderbolt etc.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The most standard cables carry "USB 3.1" which is just another name for USB 3.0 carried over Type C connectors. No, it's not; USB 3.1 adds the new SuperSpeed+ mode over all supported connector types (and USB 3.2 adds two additional SuperSpeed+ modes for Type-C connectors.) USB Type-C connector spec is a separate spec issued after USB 3.1, USB 3.1 isn't USB 3.0 over Type-C connectors.
- Dylan16807 8y agoThe main reason you can't make a truly universal USB cable is the same reason you can't make a universal ethernet cable. You can make a cat5e cable, you can make a cat6 cable, you can make a cat8 cable. But you can't make a cable that's guaranteed to support anything. Currently there are four common speeds/specs for the high-speed lanes: none, USB 3.0 at 5GHz, USB 3.1 at 10GHz, Thunderbolt 3 at 20GHz. Cables that can support the higher speeds without signal loss issues tend to also be increasingly short. That's another issue getting in the way of an ideal cable; it's hard to carry such high frequencies to the same distances. There's no tradeoff between speed and 100W support, but most cables do lack 100W support for whatever reason. A lot of cables (even from Apple and Google) pick the "none" option for high speed lanes. Such a cable can only run at USB 2.0 speed and is often called a "charging-only" cable. (True charging-only cables are significantly more rare. They also probably violate the spec.)