4 ms·
It’s a very clear indication that adding a tax on internal combustion cars of say 100% can be a very effective way to achieve almost any fraction or sold cars b
by alkonaut 8y ago
It’s a very clear indication that adding a tax on internal combustion cars of say 100% can be a very effective way to achieve almost any fraction or sold cars being EVs. I’m not saying that’s a bad idea either, the question is how realistic a huge car tax is elsewhere in the world. That they had it in the past is a nice coincidence for them. Means they now get a “free” subsidy without making gas cars more expensive. Meanwhile in e.g Sweden polluting cars get a new added tax which is used to subsidize EV’s. It’s not nearly as high as in Norway however.
- koolba 8y agoI’d much rather have society agree on a tax on the thing we don’t like then try to arbitrarily pick the one we do (ie EV rebate). The alternative to buying a ICE car isn’t necessarily buying an EV car, it could be a bike, taking trains, taking ride services, or any combo of things.
- Scoundreller 8y agoWhich is why I prefer carbon/gas taxes. If you’re a very light driver (eg: a short commute to work and back. Some people make 2 trips a week: church and grocery store), your carbon footprint from buying a Tesla is probably higher than comparable ICE cars.
- zdragnar 8y agoRaising taxes on things like cars is a tax on poor and middle class people, whereas a subsidy for EV makes them more accessible to poor and middle class people (lower price = more purchases = larger second-hand market). > The alternative to buying a ICE car isn’t necessarily buying an EV car, it could be a bike, taking trains, taking ride services, or any combo of things. That's blatantly false for anyone not living in a metropolitan area. Ride-share / car rental places simply don't exist in many places out in the countryside, and a bike is only a partial substitute. Punishing people for bad behavior (buying ICE cars) only puts more people deeper into debt, and lowers the overall number of cars purchased by raising the market floor. Encouraging good behavior (making transit more available, subsidizing EV) encourages more people to consider alternatives to ICE such as EV who otherwise wouldn't be able to afford it or wouldn't otherwise have access.
- jakobegger 8y ago> Punishing people for bad behavior (buying ICE cars) only puts more people deeper into debt Or they might just buy fewer, smaller cars, use more public transport, and get jobs close to where they live, and not move to a place without public transport in the first place.
- zdragnar 8y ago> not move to a place without public transport in the first place. I'm sorry, but that is absurdly bigoted and naive. Pretty much everything you use and own- from cotton, wood, glass, metal ore, food- comes from someplace that isn't a high-density urban city. Most of those things are produced by people with middle or working class jobs, and public transit isn't an option to get there, nor are they buying extraneous cars to just have lying around. Not only that, but those people have needs too, and so many jobs are located near where they live- everything from grocery stores to car mechanics to regional hospitals. If they go EV, they're going to get a smaller car, and it's going to cost substantially more than the equivalent ICE. Double the cost of ICE cars, and you're really doing is punishing them for not being wealthy.
- baroffoos 8y agoIf the expenses of the people producing these products goes up then they will all raise their prices to match what it costs to make. The price of wood and glass isn't set in stone.
- xte 8y agoSo they became more vulnerable, dependent on big (mostly private, despite the "public" word in the name) transport network and forced to live in a city. I suggest you a small game: we all depend on society but there are various level of dependency; for instance in a country house you may: - have fuel stocks enough for a month or two or even three so while you still depend on fuel supply you may not depend too much on constant supply like you do not suffer casual strikes, emergencies etc; - have food stocks (big freezers in garage) that let you live comfortably for a month and you may integrate them and re-supply from various sources, including a little bit from nature (hunting, fishing, vegetable garden+proper preservation); - have enough water stock (rainwater recovery / sources) to not suffer both aqueduct outages or contamination; - have enough tools and prime matter to being able to repair a bit your home in case of need for long time; On contrary in dense cities you haven't space to stock food, water, fuel, ... you can't even heat yourself in the winter burning wood in a stove. So you depend completely on city infrastructure, without option in case of even short outages. City infrastructure in turn depend on few countrywide networks that's are similar but LESS important than the countryside. Today's, and not from today's, people inhabited to have anything at their fingertips do not think at those vulnerabilities not much different than many today's programmers that treat web services like a thing that always run and it's always available... We have only to wait to see the results.
- xxs 8y agoNorway winters and bikes are not very compatible. Ride sharing is a hard ask even in Oslo (you may even need to get boat there)