10 ms·
Mozilla: Ad on Firefox’s new tab page was just another experiment
- ekianjo 8y agoAnd Mozilla is wondering why they keep losing usage share...
- gulbanana 8y agohow do these people convince themselves that the problem with ads is privacy and tracking? i use an ad blocker so that i _won’t see ads_.
- david-gpu 8y agoI would happily pay a flat $50/month for an ad-free experience where content producers got paid for each of their pages I visit.
- alyandon 8y agoWe really need some form of frictionless micropayment system that goes directly to the publishers. I would gladly pay for ad-free web content (for example, NYT and WSJ) if they made it possible for me to pay them via a consumption based model instead of trying to force me into an expensive yearly subscription.
- Proven 8y agoThat's what Brave enables (although they also "pre-collect" payments for those publishers who may not be aware of their "service" - quite scammy, so I uninstalled their browser from desktops and use it only on my phone)
- ronsor 8y agoI already pay the ISP for internet service.
- SyneRyder 8y agoGoogle already offers something like this with Google Contributor. You load a fixed amount onto your ad-free pass, select which publishers you want to browse ad-free who have opted-in, and it will deduct a small amount (typically 1 - 4c) for each webpage you view ad-free. The catch is, publishers don't seem to be signing up, presumably because they're making far more than 4c / pageview by showing ads to you. The publishers I added seem to have all abandoned the program long ago. I've been a member for over a year and have still only spent 6c. https://contributor.google.com/ https://contributor.google.com/
- scarejunba 8y agoI, too, would pay $1000 for unlimited use of any supercar I want.
- david-gpu 8y agoSnarkiness does not help. Right now publishers make zero from me because I have a couple layers of ad blockers. If I'm willing to pay X for some number of ad-free articles, which does not have to be unlimited, then publishers would be making X dollars more.
- scarejunba 8y agoYup. That's why I don't pay for HBO, so I totally get it. If they want to make it $2, at least they'd get something from me. Until then, there's always Putlocker. Their loss, really.
- david-gpu 8y agoHBO is not funded by ads. We are talking about removing ads with a micropayment of equivalent magnitude. The energy spent feeling smart would be better directed at your reading comprehension.
- darkpuma 8y agoIf you're near a city that can sustain such a business, you can in fact rent fancy cars you'd never otherwise be able to afford.
- Proven 8y agoDisgusting
- keepingscore 8y agoBased on their logic ads in newspapers aren't ads because customer information isn't shared with the advertiser until they connect with the ad and visit their store.
- clairity 8y agothat's not quite right. newspaper ads are paid placement, while these are not. being paid for placement is an essential feature of advertising. so to differentiate from that, mozilla uses the term "offer" here.
- zzzcpan 8y agoPaid placement is just one model of advertisement. Other well known ones are paid per impression, per click, per action. This is obviously the last one. I guess Mozilla is confident enough not many people understand what CPA ads are to claim they are not ads.
- clairity 8y agothat's a fair point, but it still doesn't help the newspaper analogy i was responding to. i don't like ads either, but i'm ok with mozilla experimenting to find more privacy-respecting revenue streams and lessen their reliance on google.
- codinger 8y agoThat's the same DoubleSpeak telemarketers used to say when you asked if they were a telemarketer. "No No, we're just informing you of this new offer in the middle of your dinner with your family."
- MiddleEndian 8y agoIt's an experiment in hurting the good will of their brand. I still use Firefox but it's painful sometimes. Not as painful as Chrome, but Mozilla seems determined to come up with unexpected new ways to fuck up Firefox for some reason.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoIt's simple: $$$$$. Every one of these actions is a short-term cash grab. The real amazing part is how privacy advocates let these transgressions, or what Mozilla calls "experiments", slide.
- agwa 8y agoIs there anything to suggest that this violated people's privacy? If not, I see no reason why privacy advocates should have a problem with it.
- claudius 8y agoPhoning home by default, necessary to display such "snippets" of course violates people’s privacy. That this is done not to pointlessly wish a happy new year but with commercial motives makes it even worse.
- agwa 8y agoIt's already phoning home to retrieve vital security updates, without which your privacy would be at much greater risk than Mozilla learning that a certain IP address uses Firefox.
- tedunangst 8y agoPeople use privacy to also mean "you violated the sanctity of my mind by beaming propaganda onto my retinas".
- zaarn 8y ago
- dang 8y agoA related thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18800360 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18800360
- maxhetfeld 8y agoIt's just a prank.
- gwern 8y agoI hope they randomized it so they can measure the effect of ads on users quitting Firefox or reducing usage.
- jchw 8y agoWow. They keep using that word 'experiment' to mean 'I can run whatever code I want on an end user's computer' which is not right. It's an ad. You're pushing ads. It's not the worst thing in the world if you just call it what it is, but using the 'experiments' mechanism to push ads is scummy and to me a violation of trust. I've been running Firefox inside of Firejail, a sandbox, lately, primarily as a light form of exploit mitigation, and I think maybe you should too, just in case Mozilla decides to experiment with attacking your computer as well. I think today I'm going to experiment with QuteBrowser and some other more fringe browsers that are available for Linux.
- clairity 8y agothe difference may not matter to you but it's not an ad because it's not a paid placement. no personal info is shared up front either. obviously you'd share info once you click on it. i don't like ads either, but this seems better than the standard track-you-out-the-wazoo ad.
- jchw 8y agoWhich definition of ad requires it to be a paid placement? As far as I understand it the word advertisement is a pretty broad term. You could advertise for someone for free, perhaps because you have an existing relationship, or perhaps you could advertise for something other than monetary payment. It's an advertisement. Worse, it's an advertisement, for a commercial service, in a place that I didn't want it to be. The last place I wanted something like that to be, really.
- clairity 8y agowe can debate the semantics but i don't think it's a stretch to consider monetary exchange as a feature of advertising (perhaps a more narrow version of your general exchange of value definition). with that said, another commenter noted that this could be paid per action after the fact (CPA), so it could very well be called an ad by any definition. i agree that we shouldn't place ads everywhere, especially in "safe" places. but i'm also concerned with the viability and longevity of firefox.
- sodosopa 8y ago"It's not an ad" is such a fucking bullshit line. Why does anyone believe Mozilla is different than the others?
- dependenttypes 8y agoIf you want to avoid running random experimental mozilla code on your machine without any kind of confirmation needed by you remember to go to about:preferences#privacy in the "Firefox Data Collection and Use" and turn "Allow Firefox to install and run studies" to off. I would also set the about:config options "network.allow-experiments" and "app.normandy.enabled" to false.
- stockkid 8y agoI am disappointed.
- clairity 8y agothe hubbub over this seems overblown. sure, there is advertising value to booking.com, but if no data is shared with them until you click on the offer, this seems like a decent privacy-respecting effort to find another revenue stream for mozilla that's not google. if you already use booking.com, it's 20 bucks free. moreover you can turn off snippets in the about:preferences > Home tab. at least it's not chrome, which constantly and intrusively monitors you for advertising value.
- yowlingcat 8y agoPlease don't resort to whataboutism to defend a move that would obviously alienate a very core part of Firefox's userbase. Being better than Chrome is a very low bar. This hubbub seems overblown to you, but not to others, and from your comments on this thread, you don't seem to understand why. Firefox has traditionally been the _only_ major browser that champions the traditional freedoms that many folks (myself included) associate with the web. For me personally, that involves looking at the commercial internet as a subset of the internet as a whole, which is a successful decentralized system which has reached escape velocity. The legacy of Firefox is the legacy of that system. You seem to presume that the corporation and its profitability is necessary for Firefox to be successful, and so a "decent privacy-respecting effort to find another revenue stream" rooted in advertisements is reasonable. I don't agree on principle, and I don't agree in practice, because these things take away the sole differentiator that prevents Firefox from becoming Chrome with less market share. This is probably the central thing that might make sense for you to think about: what is the market differentiator for Firefox? Why would anyone bother to use it versus Chrome? Being less obnoxious in doing sketchy things but still doing them is not a good reason. Not doing sketchy things is a good reason.
- clairity 8y agoi deny your whataboutism and counter with slippery slope! but seriously, i don’t think it’s a big deal because 1) no personal data is shared up front 2) it's an experiment 3) you can turn it off/block it 4) some people might appreciate the discount 5) there’s a wide non-slippery gulf between complete ad blocking and complete tracking 6) mozilla might find a decent compromise between those extremes, which is sorely missing 7) i trust mozilla to course-correct if necessary, as they have in the past. i don’t want ads everywhere either, and i applaud your principles, but please apply them to helping mozilla find non-ad and non-google revenue streams (assuming you’re not anti-revenue as well). please work through and put forth a rationale, not an emotional appeal, and refrain from condecscension. n.b. - i've used firefox since it was called phoenix (v0.3).
- ddtaylor 8y agoWhile I'm not thrilled Mozilla ran an experiment placing ads in the browser, I am confident that anything they release will be easy to disable via about:config or some other configuration. However, looking closer at this situation there is a bit of a troubling fact that `experiments.enabled` - the configuration directive used here - doesn't appear in about:config but certainly is being used: https://dxr.mozilla.org/mozilla-esr45/source/browser/experiments/ExperimentsService.js#20 https://dxr.mozilla.org/mozilla-esr45/source/browser/experim... Looks like someone filed a bug: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1517147 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1517147
- naner 8y agoMozilla's in a weird spot. I understand they need to be profitable but springing these types of "experiments" on users is eroding trust and is damaging long-term. There's got to be a better way to manage these changes so that it doesn't feel like adware is being surreptitiously injected into your web browser. The Wikipedia method of getting in your face begging for money seems unpleasant as well but at least that doesn't leave you questioning their motives and judgement.
- apiraino 8y agoto those complaining about Mozilla trying to monetize: did you (ever) make a donation to the foundation? Now it is a good time to show your support to the project.
- csande17 8y agoIf you disagree with what Mozilla just did, now is a terrible time to show your support for them; given their data-driven philosophy, they'll conclude that running ads on the New Tab page led to an X% increase in donations and do it again in the future.
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y ago“This snippet was an experiment to provide more value to Firefox users through offers provided by a partner,” a Mozilla spokesperson told VentureBeat. “It was not a paid placement or advertisement. We are continually looking for more ways to say thanks for using Firefox. Yuck, what a slimey piece of PR babble. I guess all those IE toolbars weren’t spyware after all - they were trying to provide value to their users! I guess all those unwanted flyers tucked in my mailbox aren’t ads either, they just want to provide me value...
- justapassenger 8y agoWith things like that, I find moral superiority of Mozilla to be questionable.
- nvo 8y agoMozilla's death will be one of the saddest dead-horse-beatings to be ever seen. Personally I've switched to Chrome after so many years of using Firefox and I'm not looking back. I'll be stabbed in the back, but I won't say I didn't expect it! Also the knife in my back will be placed by competent people, keeping my bleeding to a minimum ^_^
- codinger 8y agoI've switched because chrome manages my accounts seamlessly across my Android phone and Desktop. It's an unfair advantage Google has. I don't know how Mozilla can compete in the long run.
- nvo 8y agoFrom your answer, I assume you own an Android phone. Mozilla could compete because Firefox has Sync, but Firefox on Android is some seriously laggy shit with built-in ads, so it's going to be hard for them to win.
- rrrguy 8y agoWhile I agree ff on Android has big lag problems, where are the built in ads?
- hnaccy 8y agoEither Mozilla has been infiltrated by malicious actors or the modern crop of web-focused developers are so numb to current status quo of mass ads and tracking that they are unable to see alternatives or understand why people would be upset. I find it a bit bizarre.
- darkpuma 8y ago> "malicious actors" Maybe, but my best guess is they've been 'infiltrated' by people with absolutely no ideological commitment to what Mozilla has traditionally stood for and instead view it as "just another job". Probably people with a stronger marketing background than anything else. I think it's the best explanation for shit like this or the "mr robot tie in." These sort of advertisements aren't the sort of ideas a software developer with a commitment to free software and privacy would think up. These are the sort of ideas that come from people with a marketing background. I doubt these were bottom-up ideas, the order almost certainly came from the top down. I hate to say it but Mozilla's upper and middle management probably need to be gutted if this kind of crap is ever going to stop, and I doubt that will happen.