3 ms·
Cost would not be my biggest concern. Genes are not like points you can spend in a game to upgrade stuff. Editing them is a two edged sword. Cystic Fibrosis i
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Cost would not be my biggest concern.
Genes are not like points you can spend in a game to upgrade stuff. Editing them is a two edged sword.
Cystic Fibrosis is likely so much more common in Caucasians because having one copy of the gene protects against at least a couple of diseases that were seen a lot in Europe for a time. So being a carrier was protective and made you more likely to survive, similar to how Sickle Cell is protective against malaria.
"Survival of the fittest" doesn't mean the strongest, smartest, etc. Evolution is more about winnowing than about adapting per se. The ones that don't die in the face of unexpected new challenges are the "winners," even if it means they have a defect protecting them from something worse than what the defect does to them.
A fish out of water dies. But gills have a lot of advantages in the water.
Genes just do not work the way comments like this one (above) seem to assume. They just don't.
- chii 8y ago> Cost would not be my biggest concern. i believe the comment refers to the way genes get inherited to the next generation. If making gene editing is expensive, the poor will have yet another disadvantage that their children will be less 'capable' than their rich counterparts. If gene editing is possible - it should also be subsidized so that all of society benefits, not just select few who can afford it.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoFor now, the rich are more than welcome to keep their idiot choices to fuck with a thing we don't fully understand. I have a form of Cystic Fibrosis. That's enough horror without it being a thing my idiot parents did to me on purpose in hopes of raiding my IQ. There is some evidence that some genetic disorders impact brain function and tend to correlate to higher IQs, not lower ones. From what I gather, CF seems to be one of them. I've made my peace with the hand I was dealt at birth and I'm pretty good at looking for the silver lining. I doubt I could so easily make my peace with it if I learned my parents thought that having a high IQ was more valuable than having functional lungs and a functional digestive tract.
- noir_lord 8y ago> and a functional digestive tract. Different disease to yours but I hear that, I never realised how important that was until mine went sideways, it affects everything.
- mcnichol 8y agoYou appear to take an extreme stance. Try a different argument: If your parents knew there was a high probability that their child would inherit genes making CF an aspect of their lives, would they try to change that even at potential risk. As a parent myself there is very little I wouldn't do for my child. I can't imagine the pain CF has caused you and the sacrifices you've had to make. If I were your parent, my desire to not put you through pain would be invariably high. Isn't that one element of exploration in foundations looking for a cure? It seems transparency, the longer term impacts, the tradeoffs we will face that we just don't know. There is a cold logic that accompanies that line of thinking. I am not saying one way or another, I just feel it is worth echoing from a purely logical standpoint.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoNo, I am not taking an extreme position. Saying that trying to make designer babies comes with potential downside that is potentially horrifying is not an extreme position. It also isn't the same as arguing that people with known genetic defects should be denied the opportunity to try to have children who lack that defect. Isn't that one element of exploration in foundations looking for a cure? I've grown vastly healthier while the entire world calls me crazy and accuses me of making that up. I've done so largely via diet and lifestyle. Based on that, my view is that the obsession with Oo, Shiny! tech solutions expected to create some slam-dunk solution actually hinders real progress. It causes the world to largely overlook more prosaic solutions with more immediate pay-off but less glamor.
- EamonnMR 8y agoThe same can be said for generational wealth, education, culture, language, and even names.
- saulrh 8y agoGenes are not like points you can spend in a game to upgrade stuff. Editing them is a two edged sword. Sure... but relative to the objective function that our genes currently optimize. All bets are off once a different objective function gets involved. Given that our genes are currently optimizing something like "reproductive fitness for pre-writing tribes circa 500ky BCE", and that that environment is completely different from what we're dealing with right now - no drug-resistant pathogens or globe-spanning plagues (hell, not even any antibiotics in the first place), low or negative value on longer lifespans, massively lower rewards for cognitive capabilities especially in comparison to the rewards for physical power, no surgery or vitamin supplements or blood testing, surprising (and tragic) lean toward r-selection over K-selection, quite a lot more - I would be surprised if we were unable to find some wins that are, relative to our current objectives, major, obvious, safe, and free.
- Amezarak 8y agoThe objective function currently in effect has kept us going through an extremely wide variety of environmental and cultural conditions. Will the new one? Suppose the current civilization doesn’t last forever? We have a responsibility to people a thousand years from now, not just the people of tomorrow.
- DoreenMichele 8y agohell, not even any antibiotics in the first place No man-made antibiotics. I assure you, Mother Nature was way ahead of humankind there and, in fact, a lot of our drugs are based on things already found in nature. We have a want center. We tend to like the taste of things that benefit us. There is research on such things. If you are sick and you respect your cravings, it's possible to find yourself consuming a thing that contains a natural form of medication that addresses your issue, and doing so in sufficiently high quantities as to hit a medicinal dosage of it. This is likely a root cause of the idea that "god" made someone better: We don't know what they were sick with or what cured it, so it seems miraculous. That doesn't mean there wasn't something in specific that they did or that simply happened that fixed the issue. We are swarming with billions of microbes at all times. Some are beneficial and we can't digest our food without them. Some are harmful. Low levels of harmful microbes are a routine norm that the body deals with daily. It's only when it gets beyond a certain threshold that it becomes identifiable sickness. I would be surprised if we were unable to find some wins that are, relative to our current objectives, major, obvious, safe, and free. When antibiotics first came out, the world announced the end of disease. It's a few decades later and we are dealing with the rise of super bugs instead of living in the predicted disease-free utopia. You and I fundamentally don't see this problem space at all similarly.