7 ms·
Dr He chose a bad time to skirt scientific ethics, regardless if there was any direct harm to the people, as China recently announced measures to punish scienti
by dmix 8y ago
Dr He chose a bad time to skirt scientific ethics, regardless if there was any direct harm to the people, as China recently announced measures to punish scientific misconduct [1].
They will likely make an example of him since he's such a public figure now. Whether they can really change the culture there is to be seen, but one thing China knows how to do is add layers of administration to select areas.
Ever since CRISPR was announced people have always been scared of what "rouge" actors could be do, now that this technology it's so 'democratized'. It was probably bound to happen somewhere. So they'll be interested in clamping down hard on the early minor cases of ethical violations, in order to protect against other much more deliberately malicious future cases.
[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07740-z https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07740-z
- tiglionabbit 8y ago> "rouge" You mean rogue?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GordonS 8y agoIt's a play on "red"; the Dr is Chinese.
- toyg 8y ago(For grammar-challenged people who might take dry humour as serious: above comment is clearly a joke. “Rouge” is the French word for “red”, but it’s a common misspelling for the English word “rogue”. It’s pretty clear the top post in thread is a misspelling, not a pun.)
- GordonS 8y agoEh? I wasn't joking, and I've never seen "rogue" mis-spelled as "rouge". The top post even put it in double quotes, e.g. "rouge". That makes it pretty clear it's a pun, in this case playing on rogue and red - and it works all the better because of the recent 'red danger', anti-Chinese sentiment that the powers that be are currently stirring up.
- toyg 8y agoIf you’ve never seen rouge as misspelling of rogue, you haven’t read enough intertubes. Beyond that, I guess we won’t know until drmix intervenes - although now he’d say “of course!” it was voluntary ;)
- ggggtez 8y agoYou got your cause and effect backwards. The rules were only added after he did it, because he did it.
- est 8y agothe rules were they before he did it, but not enforced (as usual). he triggered it.
- gwern 8y agoNo. They were announcing crackdowns and punishments well before He Jiankui announced anything. This article, for example, is from several weeks before, and records punishments initiated well before that: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07222-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07222-2
- Arima11 8y agoRe read the article. It's not about the use of CRISPR but the lack of transparency in his operation. The couple gave a consent based on false info. They thought their babies would receive a type of 'vaccination'.
- codyb 8y agoThis is what I thought the big issue was, that the parents were grossly misinformed and uniformed about what Dr. He was doing.
- dmix 8y agoIs there any good link with sources of what the patients were actually told? The original articles about this were pretty vague and only had the initial negative response from scientists who were against the whole thing. But I’m curious about the level of consent he got and what the AIDS organization was told when they helped him find his guinea pigs. If he really did say it was just a vaccination then regardless of what scientists think, he crossed a line no medical professional should take.
- neom 8y agoHe Jiankui did a Q&A in November, many of the questions people asked concerned the informed content process he used. The Q&A starts ~20 minutes in: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLZufCrjrN0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLZufCrjrN0
- kanzure 8y agoI typed a transcript http://diyhpl.us/wiki/transcripts/human-genome-editing-summit/2018-hong-kong/jiankui-he-human-genome-editing/ http://diyhpl.us/wiki/transcripts/human-genome-editing-summi...
- tossaccount123 8y agoIf I was China I would put him in an underground lab and make him work day and night I can't find the article but there was a geneticist who said the difference between Einstein and the average human was 50-200 base pairs. Which ever country figures that out first will rule the world. Instead of getting an Einstein or Newton or Da Vinci every several hundred years, they could have an assembly line of them. China already collected the DNA of 2,200 geniuses to try and find correlations. The West's value of "human rights" and subjective ethics will be our doom. We are completely ignoring avenues of research because people don't like the implications of intelligence being genetic https://singularityhub.com/2013/03/19/chinas-bgi-to-sequence-2200-geniuses-in-search-for-smart-genes/ https://singularityhub.com/2013/03/19/chinas-bgi-to-sequence...
- habith 8y agoI'm pretty sure it's about the ethics of altering humans and a fear or a resurgence of eugenics. That aside, I'm also pretty sure someone reviewed his work and found out that his HIV-immune mutation was not done correctly, it's a bit late for me to find a link, will update later if you're interested. Edit: Nvm, someone else posted a better answer: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18798764 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18798764
- sizzle 8y agoWill an army of Einsteins be impervious to atomic warfare? I mean if they have a superior grasp of physics and build the tech to intercept an ICBM then I suppose...
- tossaccount123 8y agoWho needs nukes when you can send an autonomous drone swarm to subjugate a country? Or develop an ethnic bio weapon to wipe out your enemies with no damage to infrastructure? Nukes will be seen as primitive brute force weapons in the future