5 ms·
I feel like nobody is offering the obvious evolutionary explanation: you certainly don’t gain anything by wanting to kill/eat human babies, but it’s a completel
by derefr 8y ago
I feel like nobody is offering the obvious evolutionary explanation: you certainly don’t gain anything by wanting to kill/eat human babies, but it’s a completely rational impulse to want to kill/eat baby squirrels or rabbits or deer or any other thing a human hunter-gatherer might run into. “Cute” in this case means “defenseless”, which means “a free meal.”
- bobthechef 8y agoNo, because this has nothing to do with the desire to kill or harm. It actually invokes a desire to protect. It is motivated by the overwhelming adoration, if you will, for what is cute. The intensity is not "aggression" in the sense you or others seems to be thinking of. By analogy, think of two people who have not seen each other for a while, miss each other dearly, and meet one another. The hugs and physical expressions of affection are going to be more intense. I think this is similar. It is an experience of overwhelming joy.
- jm__87 8y ago> you certainly don’t gain anything by wanting to kill/eat human babies Actually, this is exactly what gorillas do. When there is a new alpha male, he will go and systematically kill all the baby gorillas who are still nursing. Why? So he can impregnate the mothers of these gorillas who are unable to reproduce while they are nursing. While human females can get pregnant while nursing a baby, they are less fertile during the first few months of breastfeeding. Now I'm not saying this the reason why some people have this impulse. Just thought I'd share some interesting info with you. Happy new year! Edit: I am not an expert on gorillas, just something I have recalled from reading Robert Sapolskys book, "Behave". I'm sure there is some nuance to this infanticidal behavior of gorillas which I have misrepresented. Apologies in advance to the primatologists who read my comment.
- wallace_f 8y agoYou shouldn't lose complete confidence like that just because of some superficial disagreement. History is filled with examples of groups being very wrong.
- jm__87 8y agoAh, I wouldn't say I've lost complete confidence in my statement. Just wanted to add a disclaimer in case I didn't fully remember the details correctly (perhaps it isn't all gorillas, just certain species of gorillas. Perhaps the female gorillas aren't entirely infertile, just significantly less so. Etc), as I don't have the book handy to validate.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThis is true of cats too. Stray mother cats will keep moving her kittens because tomcats would seek out lactating mother cats, but will first kill the kittens before mating with her. Nature is brutal. Also in a way, the tomcat is making sure that his kittens won’t have to share resources with kittens from a different litter. P.S: that’s a great book by Sapolsky. I read it fully and just last night, I went back to it for light selective browsing. Very well written. Thanks for mentioning it.
- Semiapies 8y ago"Obvious evolutionary explanations" by laymen tend to be just-so stories.
- wallace_f 8y agoIf I'm not mistaken, just-so stories were Lamarckian explanations, while OP's seems like a Darwinian one.
- stcredzero 8y agoIt's very easy to craft evolutionary just-so stories. That's why you need to look out for it.
- wallace_f 8y agoBut this is actually not a just-so story. It's a Darwinian hypothesis. OP needs to gather evidence if they want to prove their theory. Said another way: A single Lamarckian example of evolution has yet to be proven, so they can perhaps be dismissed with a degree of confidence. OP's hypothesis is not Lamarckian.
- stcredzero 8y agoA Darwinian just-so story may well be worse than a Lamarckian one. The latter might be immediately falsifiable while the former might be "not even wrong." (Ugh. I just did a search for "Just So stories," only to discover that the anti-evolutionists have latched onto that term!)
- wallace_f 8y ago>I just did a search for "Just So stories," only to discover that the anti-evolutionists have latched onto that term! Well, that is my point. They are not evolutionary theories. Despite this being ultra downvoted, my pointing out the use of the term "just-so stories" is incorrect here seems to clearly be something you are even realizing while in the same breath disagreeing.
- gnulinux 8y agoNow you need to gather evidence to support your hypothesis.
- vbuwivbiu 8y agofalsify
- anigbrowl 8y agoWell no, because if you regularly snack on immature prey you risk a future shortage of adult prey that can feed you for longer when the seasons change. In agriculture harvesting of livestock aims to balance supply and demand as consistently as possible, while in nature population sizes tend to demonstrate chaotic/hysterical behavior as a function of species' maturity cycles.
- smallnamespace 8y agoAnimals in the wild are generally unable to plan ahead and let fruit ripen optimally since if demand is high enough, the only result will be another animal coming along to eat it first. Also, it's well known that predators prey not just on old and sick individuals but also the young. Predators don't plan ahead, they eat whatever is available and accessible.
- anigbrowl 8y agoAll true, but recall that attacking infant animals tends to be riskier, and that these pressures operate at the population rather than individual level. A population that's too good at targeting baby prey will go hungry later, all other things being equal.
- xaedes 8y agomaybe that is why, even when experienced, the least, certainly no whole population, do act on a cute aggression impulse?
- itry2develop 8y agoWhen you are a starving nomad, as we once were, you don't stop to worry about population sizes of the prey. Why do you think so many species go extinct...
- iseeyoubydesign 8y agohence immigration. JK bro, happy new year to all. We are all learning. Leave Trump in 2018 we are going to the future, come with?
- GuB-42 8y agoThe study seems to use pictures of humans: babies, adults, some of them manipulated for more/less cuteness. It doesn't really need an evolutionary explanation. What is obvious is that babies and adults somehow coevolved in order to ensure that helpless babies are probably taken care of. But that mechanism doesn't have to be perfect. If a consequence is a few overly cute babies get hurt by a few overly sensitive adults, is not a really big deal.