5 ms·
Others visit their site. Some sites are very popular. It never stays on the internet, and its not all about what I'm seeing. Imagine a billboard that says "Joe
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
Others visit their site. Some sites are very popular. It never stays on the internet, and its not all about what I'm seeing. Imagine a billboard that says "Joe is a deviant criminal". It's ok, I should just not drive that way again?
And Universities have a special obligation, lets not forget that.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Imagine a billboard that says "Joe is a deviant criminal". The solution isn’t to ban billboards.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoTrue, but way to miss the point. Its to forbid posting crap like that (on existing sites). And the ban part is all about the special position of a University vs students. Not about the internet, not about the public in general. Anyway that's how the OP started...
- williamscales 8y agoI think it is you who is missing the point. What is different between "forbidding posting crap like that" and "banning billboards"?
- EpicEng 8y agoSo who gets to decide what information is ok for adults to consume? What happens when this newly elected dictator decides that e.g. Jordan Peterson is a hate monger who must be censored? Is that ok? How do we prevent abuse when the subject matter is so often subjective? This is exactly why we have the first ammendment. This sort of power should not exist as those who would wield it are not infallible and cannot be trusted.
- npmaile 8y agoIf Joe happens to be a deviant criminal and doesn't like to be reminded of the fact, then he should avert his gaze when driving by. If Joe is not a deviant criminal, then he can sue the person who put up the billboard for damages incurred.
- anigbrowl 8y agoAnd then there will be a tide of amicus briefs making the same generic arguments about free speech and slippery slopes and parades of horribles, and it's a question of whether Joe wants to spend lots of money and time on litigating the issue, which may cost substantially more than the original libel, thus creating a market for lies which is effectively what we have now.
- nradov 8y agoUniversities shouldn't have special obligations any more than any other employer or government agency. Another way to look at it is that regular people shouldn't have less protection against online harassment just because they don't happen to be university students. Rules and protections should apply equally to everyone. Should public libraries be obligated to block online content that harasses some of their patrons?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoUniversities have parental responsibilities to legal children.
- nradov 8y agoVery few university students are children. There are a lot more children in public libraries.
- EpicEng 8y ago>Imagine a billboard that says "Joe is a deviant criminal" Well now Joe has a libel claim. If Joe is actually a deviant criminal then, well... he pissed off the wrong person. What's the issue?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoWell, on that subject, of course the internet is the issue. Once something is 'in the wild' on the internet it is very, very hard to quash it. The old legal mechanisms are slow, certainly not the speed of the internet anyway. A 'viral' video on social media isn't something you stop with a libel suit.
- EpicEng 8y agoYou can't unprint a libelous article in a newspaper either. You can sue them and they can print an apology, but you cannot erase history. The internet poses new hurdles because information is so easily accessible, but we have to be very careful about imposing rules which restrict an adult's ability to consume information.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI don't' think it is that new given anonymous bill postings before forensics were sufficient to identify a publisher. If everyone already knows that someone posted a bunch of pamphlets that stated that the governor is an embezzling child molester. Enforcement has always been limited by practicality. Before forensics advanced sufficiently just a dead body in the street with no witnesses was a perfect murder.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoWhat about "I've heard Joe is a a deviant criminal"? The rumor does not have to be true for the statement (that the rumor was heard) to be true. What about "Joe has, at the time this sign was made, never denied beating his wife on Decemeber 31st." The claim could be very true in that Joe never has denied that specific claim because there was no reason to deny a claim that hadn't been made yet. What about putting up the sordid details of a teenagers love life on a bulletin board outside her high school? Assume you verified the statements as factual. Is there perhaps an issue even when it is the truth?