5 ms·
Perhaps there are no candidates who represent the residents views. Then they wouldn’t have a say.
by zepto 8y ago
Perhaps there are no candidates who represent the residents views.
Then they wouldn’t have a say.
- Alex3917 8y ago> Perhaps there are no candidates who represent the residents views. Then they can run themselves. That's sort of the concept of a Democracy.
- fzeroracer 8y agoIn order to run as a candidate you need to have a certain amount of capital. If you're in an area that's economically depressed, the only people that are going to be able to run are those attempting to extract as much profit as possible to the detriment of the locals. America is far from a democracy considering only the wealthy are able to actually run as candidates.
- Alex3917 8y ago> In order to run as a candidate you need to have a certain amount of capital. Most political races don't have many more voters than the average class president election. And a lot of those positions have a lot of power.
- briandear 8y agoYou raise the capital. That’s how campaigns work. You start with a small office. Then you raise money to go bigger. Joe Biden wasn’t wealthy at all, yet he never lost an election, starting with the New Castle Counsel. Ocasio-Cortez didn’t have a ton of money. Look at Maxine Waters. Plenty of “poor” people get elected. You just have to be smart, organized and have a message. Certainly running for Senate or President isn’t easy, but local races are winnable which springboard you to higher office of you’re any good.
- zepto 8y agoThat’s a generic argument. You ignore that we’re talking about running against candidates who are favored by billion dollar businesses, and the people on the other side are not wealthy. Where can they ‘raise’ this capital from?
- ghufran_syed 8y agoSure. But they have the right to run for office - so if none of the 100's - 1000's of people who do represent their views chose to run, isn't that a choice too? Wouldn't a simpler explanation be that the more popular choice won i.e. overall, the people of the city decided that the benefits outweighed the harm? And as more evidence of harm is accumulated, I'm sure their views on regulation will change. But I think it's unhealthy to imply that when "our side" loses, then the results are not legitimate, but when "our side" wins, only then is it "democracy in action", "will of the people" etc
- adventured 8y agoOf course that's exactly what happened. The anti views are the minority. Their complaint is actually that they're losing out to a more popular position in a Democracy. The oil industry jobs pay extraordinarily well compared to (non-existent) alternatives that were there before the oil boom. There was no economy in West Texas before the fracking output soared. There's nothing out there other than Midland and Odessa, and their populations hadn't changed much in 30 years. The choice is extraction economy or no economy. And if by some unexpected effort + resources the state decided to invest vast tax revenue to build up a non-extraction economy in the area, it will take decades anyway.
- sremani 8y agoAs usual an unpopular yet sound argument from adventured. The real losers are people downvoting because of their shallow mental models. West Texas oil is making US more secure and access to cheap energy will not only make things better in Texas, but Mexico is going build on this supply of NG. West Texas is extraction colony, for America. The rest of the world is buying because it is sweet as hell and produced in most stable region on the planet.
- zepto 8y agoNobody is implying that when ‘our side loses’ the results are not legitimate. That’s a weird thing to say. I’n not on a side on this issue. However it’s also obvious that running for office isn’t free and that often elections are decided on the basis of who can buy the most publicity. A random person standing against petrochemical interests is clearly at a massive disadvantage.