3 ms·
Okay. But why just Amazon? What about hundred Joe's Car Shops and and a hundred Betty's Diners and a hundred Sue's Tech Startups? Does not the same calculus
by paulddraper 8y ago
Okay.
But why just Amazon?
What about hundred Joe's Car Shops and and a hundred Betty's Diners and a hundred Sue's Tech Startups?
Does not the same calculus apply to them?
What about an up and coming competitor to Amazon that would have provided even more jobs, had the government treated them fairly?
Should we not be equals under the law, having the same requirements, receiving the same punishments, paying according to the same tax code?
If Amazon can negotiate different tax laws, should it be able to negotiate more lax employment requirements, or lower speeding tickets, or more voting rights?
I'm as staunch a low-tax and pro-business libertarian as they come, but for everyone, not just for the government favorites.
Equality under the law.
- pergadad 8y agoGood government incentives should support something that wouldn't otherwise happen. They balance out market inefficiencies. The lack of risk capital for startups or affordable loans for SMEs is an inefficiency. The reduction of costs for highly profitable mega-corps is not a market inefficiency.
- paulddraper 8y agoAnd even worse than a bad incentive is a selective one. It'd be one thing if New York passed a law that any company that does ABC can get XYZ. They didn't. They said one company, and one company only, can get XYZ.
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoIt's not just Amazon. Tax incentives are very common and lots of companies get them. It's very, very uncommon for a tax break to apply only to one specific company.
- pergadad 8y agoYet that's tm what the op article was about: that the big ones get special deals.
- paulddraper 8y agoAlright. Then (1) write that rule down and (2) call those writings "the tax code". Then everyone knows the rules and the outcomes. This onsies twosies business of choosing who pays one on a case-by-case basis is ripe for bribery and inequity.