4 ms·
If I give a company $100M in tax breaks to come to my city, and they end up paying $50M in tax (instead of $150M), the outcome was financially positive as the a
by refurb 8y ago
If I give a company $100M in tax breaks to come to my city, and they end up paying $50M in tax (instead of $150M), the outcome was financially positive as the alternative was that they don’t come and my tax revenue is $0.
- grecy 8y ago> If I give a company $100M in tax breaks to come to my city, and they end up paying $50M in tax (instead of $150M), the outcome was financially positive as the alternative was that they don’t come and my tax revenue is $0. And now you're in a race to the bottom with every other city in the USA. You're lowing the standard of living for every normal person (less tax revenue to spend on schools, roads, etc.) and you're increasing the standard of living for big companies (more profit) Rather than doing that, NO city should offer any tax breaks, and that company will come to some city and pay $150M in taxes, thus improving society overall in the USA. It's amazing how often you guys work against your own interests, degrading your own society in the name of increasing private profits.
- refurb 8y agoIt should be a “race to the bottom”, it’s what normal people call “competition”. Cities that can provide the necessary services to their citizens for less money “win”. That’s how it should be and how it works today.
- grecy 8y agoIt's competition when it's between two companies. It shouldn't be a competition when it's about providing basic services to a community of people. > Cities that can provide the necessary services to their citizens for less money “win”. I think you would find the vast majority of citizens in OECD countries would not say America is providing necessary services to it's citizens. Though your explanation certainly explains why so many government services are so terrible in America compared to OECD countries. Thanks.
- refurb 8y agoWhy are basic services so special they should use competition to drive efficiency? It’s well known that Singapore has a very high functioning govt with plenty of social services for its citizens and very low tax rates. I say good on them and if a company tells another country they are moving there then that country should take that as a hint to get their shit together. And as for OECD countries not being satisfied with the US govt services who cares? The only opinion that matters is US citizens. Should Sweden care if the US complains about their system?
- grecy 8y ago> Why are basic services so special they should use competition to drive efficiency? Because America has proven what happens when you let competition dictate - the quality of services goes to crap. Look at your public schooling, healthcare, roads and rail. They are seriously below standard. > And as for OECD countries not being satisfied with the US govt services who cares? The only opinion that matters is US citizens I once read a report that said "If Americans knew what Europeans get for their tax money Americans would riot in the streets". I don't think you can ask US citizens, because they have no idea what the rest of the world is doing. It's not in their culture to look or compare themselves to other countries. > Should Sweden care if the US complains about their system? I've lived and worked in Australia, Canada, USA. My sister lives in the UK. In my experience, it's extremely common for Australia/Canada/UK to compare itself to other countries, and point out where Australia/Canada/UK is lacking. As one example it made massive headlines across Australia when it came out that school kids in Kazakhstan had higher Maths results than Australian kids. So in answer, yes, other developed countries do care and notice and use that comparison to improve their own country.
- trophycase 8y agoYes? But you basically just externalized the business's costs for them to simply redistribute wealth to you. It's a net societal negative. As an outsider, it makes exactly 0 difference to me whether there is a data center in Wisconsin vs. Illinois, the only difference is that some corporation will be more profitable and pay less tax overall, which they are supposed to be paying to offset externalities (at least in a perfect world).
- chrisseaton 8y ago> As an outsider Right but these tax breaks are offered by representatives of people who live there and want the company to be there - not outsiders. You’re saying ‘as someone who doesn’t live in the area I see no benefit to me in spending money to improve the area’ well duh thanks for the insight. It’s no different to cities offering higher salaries to hire a good administrator - normal competition to bring in beneficial things.
- Retric 8y agoThis breaks down becase the people who benifit are different than the people who pay for it. The area is worse off, but specific people get rewarded.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIt's not inherently the case that the area is worse off than under the status quo. If you have a business that would consume $45M in government services, having them pay $50M rather than the $150M they would pay under the existing laws would still put you up by $5M compared to them going somewhere else. The issue is that designing tax changes for specific companies is ridiculous. If the local area can net $5M by charging lower taxes in this specific case, why is that not just the general rule so they can net $5M a hundred times from a hundred other companies without having to negotiate separately with each of them? And $50K a hundred thousand times from smaller companies?
- 8y ago
- Retric 8y agoCity’s are not generally profitable as they have real expenses that scale ~1:1 with population. A 10% discount might be a net gain, but a 66% discount is a sure loss. So, for a company to actually generate 150M in taxable activities it would use far more than 50M worth of city services. Resulting in a net negative return. Politicians benifit from concentrating upsides while defusing downsides. They can point at X jobs, while ignoring the long term issues.
- paulddraper 8y agoOkay. But why just Amazon? What about hundred Joe's Car Shops and and a hundred Betty's Diners and a hundred Sue's Tech Startups? Does not the same calculus apply to them? What about an up and coming competitor to Amazon that would have provided even more jobs, had the government treated them fairly? Should we not be equals under the law, having the same requirements, receiving the same punishments, paying according to the same tax code? If Amazon can negotiate different tax laws, should it be able to negotiate more lax employment requirements, or lower speeding tickets, or more voting rights? I'm as staunch a low-tax and pro-business libertarian as they come, but for everyone, not just for the government favorites. Equality under the law.
- pergadad 8y agoGood government incentives should support something that wouldn't otherwise happen. They balance out market inefficiencies. The lack of risk capital for startups or affordable loans for SMEs is an inefficiency. The reduction of costs for highly profitable mega-corps is not a market inefficiency.
- paulddraper 8y agoAnd even worse than a bad incentive is a selective one. It'd be one thing if New York passed a law that any company that does ABC can get XYZ. They didn't. They said one company, and one company only, can get XYZ.
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoIt's not just Amazon. Tax incentives are very common and lots of companies get them. It's very, very uncommon for a tax break to apply only to one specific company.
- pergadad 8y agoYet that's tm what the op article was about: that the big ones get special deals.
- paulddraper 8y ago
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> If I give a company $100M in tax breaks to come to my city, and they end up paying $50M in tax (instead of $150M), the outcome was financially positive as the alternative was that they don’t come and my tax revenue is $0. The issue is that this is true of every company. It's much more efficient (and fair) to just have a lower tax rate to begin with and allow that to attract businesses in general than to negotiate with each of them individually and screw over any that aren't big enough to get that level of attention.
- pergadad 8y agoAlso the broken window fallacy: yes the money will have had a positive effect, but was this the best effect that could be achieved with the funds? Maybe it brought a company and a few jobs but the same funds could have increased local pensions, increased teacher training or built a new wind energy installation. The question is not "was this a useful use of money", it's "was this one of the better/the best use of these funds".
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoNot if attracting the company is still net positive, i.e. they're still at least paying for the services they directly consume. Lowering the "net profit" from taxes on a company that otherwise wouldn't be in your jurisdiction doesn't cost you anything. There is nothing you could have otherwise spent the money on because there otherwise wouldn't have been any money to spend. At best you only lose a small amount by letting them leave. But if you can get any gain at all then why is it being done for only one company rather than in general as a matter of policy?