6 ms·
TL;DR: A long, insightful, and at least partially correct critique of the "state" of Ethereum as of today. My humble 0.02 is that what's current is immature an
by simonebrunozzi 8y ago
TL;DR: A long, insightful, and at least partially correct critique of the "state" of Ethereum as of today.
My humble 0.02 is that what's current is immature and unstable, but there's a decent chance that Ethereum, or Bitcoin, or both, will at some point in the future provide some interesting technical solutions/services.
The fact that Ethereum is not there yet is not a good enough argument for me.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoOther than making some people really rich, what problems would it solve that aren’t better solved by existing solutions which don’t burn energy to create secure entropy?
- gamma-male 8y agoDNS
- coralreef 8y agoYou kind of asked a loaded question, but to answer your question; whatever thing needs decentralization.
- alexkcd 8y agoPoW will centralize towards cheap energy access. PoS will centralize to majority stake holders. I would bet that such energy access or stake follows a power law distribution. So long as that is true, neither system will ever provide decentralization.
- coralreef 8y agoOkay, but what happens to energy prices when enough miners flock to low-cost centers? Prices go up. In a long enough time horizon, opportunity to take advantage of energy prices basically gets competed away. I haven't read much on energy production, but as far as I know there are many places on the planet that cheaply produce renewable energy.
- alexkcd 8y agoEnergy production is heavily regulated and centralized to a few entities. Very much like financial institutions. It's highly unlikely that the free market somehow sorts this out in the future, considering that it's the free market that gave rise to these power law distributions to begin with.
- coralreef 8y agoI get your point, but I'm not really sure what the purpose behind your argument is. There will always be some limiting factor or theoretical vulnerability. If it's not ISPs/Internet infrastructure, then its the exchanges and fiat on ramps. But yet, its been pretty hard to kill illegal filesharing, VPNs, etc. It's even harder to stop those things when the population doesn't believe in legislating against it, at least in a democracy.
- alexkcd 8y agoMy point is that neither PoW nor PoS are decentralized. Which was in response to the original comment. I’ll let other people prognosticate as to what, if anything, that means for their future.
- nonbel 8y ago> "existing solutions which don’t burn energy" Like what?
- yoshuaw 8y agoMost computer programs don't rely on brute-forcing hashes to produce results. Programs that don't require brute-force commonly use many times less energy than programs that do rely on brute force. This extra cost is often seen as wasteful.
- nonbel 8y ago>"Programs that don't require brute-force commonly use many times less energy than programs that do rely on brute force." Can you give an example of a program that gives similar results?
- antonvs 8y agoMany of the things that people want to use smart contracts for can be implemented using a model involving some degree of trust between vetted participants. Anything involving a distributed value chain for an industry, for example.
- nonbel 8y agoHow much energy does generating this trust require?
- maxxxxx 8y agoDo you think these questions are clever? How about YOU give an example for a crypto use case that can't be achieved with traditional methods?
- nonbel 8y agoIt is a currency that acts like gold over the internet, ie no chargebacks and (is expected to) appreciate over time as more dollars/etc are created.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoRemittances without high fees. I think as entropy becomes very inefficient to produce (difficulty multipliers increasing on crypto as the network expands...) it will become more clear that the expensive part about sending money internationally is trusting all parties involved. You pay VISA/MASTERCARD a 3% fee because you trust them to protect your account in the case of fraud. Moneygram takes 2% of all transcations over $900 because you trust them to move money from your account to the recipients account without losing it. Even in computer security, you have to put your trust in something. Somebody picked cryptography and high numbers of CPU cycles. Anyway, you asked what problems crypto could solve, and I guess my answer is, maybe it will cost less to send money around the world. As it turns out, there's not necessarily a way to make it free.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoI don’t pay a fee on my credit cards, the merchant does, and in case of fraud I can issue a chargeback to boot. As long as I pay my balance each month, my credit card is free, plus generating rewards. That’s almost the opposite of cryptocurrency, where far from being able to tackle fraud, it makes theft or loss nearly impossible to remediate. A credit card is also one of the easiest things to use, and all of the hard work on security is undertaken by merchants and the credit card issuer.
- StavrosK 8y agoIf the merchant pays something, you pay something. Where do you think the merchant gets the money from?
- yebyen 8y ago> I don’t pay a fee on my credit cards, the merchant does While that may be technically correct, it's ignorant of the fact that costs are always passed down the line in any economic relationship like you're describing. That fraud protection costs the card issuers, which is the basis for that merchant fee, and the merchant passes the cost on in the form of higher prices. (Merchant accounts with higher fraud rates will pay higher fees!) So from another perspective, you actually are paying the bill for those unknown percentage of frauds, which you wouldn't be as much on the hook for so directly if only everyone was responsible for their own individual security.
- arisAlexis 8y agoseems that you like many people are very preoccupied that some people that took a huge risk got back a huge reward. This is totally irrelevant but keeps coming up in arguments stressed like in your sentence.
- DennisP 8y agoA simple one already deployed on Ethereum: online gambling, where you don't have to trust the casino to run fair games or hold your money. As with most things, this can be sort of solved with heavy regulatory structures and enforcement, but I would argue that it's not better solved, especially once proof of stake eliminates the problem of burning energy.
- gnarbarian 8y agoI agree. Your position is reasonable and cautiously stated. Unfortunately the crypto hate here on HN is real and pretty disappointing really. Crypto Currencies are an emerging technology that have value far beyond currencies. IPFS for example, d.tube etc.
- api 8y agoThe crypto hate comes from a combination of fatigue and a reaction to the incredible number of total scams in the crypto ecosystem.
- smokeyj 8y agoEven in purely technical discussions people providing information get downvoted. HN is a crypto “safe space”. Just don’t talk about it here.
- wpietri 8y agoExactly I would have absolutely no problem with them if these things were obscure little open source projects like most tech experiments are. When I first read the Bitcoin paper I was skeptical but interested to see where they'd take it. My problem is that these projects are simultaneously treated as humble little experiments and the perfect future of the global financial system, deserving of hundreds of millions of dollars of investment and endless public attention. If they would pick one or the other, I'd be fine with it. But I've dealt with years of a radical, quasi-mystical pro-crypto contingent who believe they deserve all of the upside with none of the accountability. I am 100% over it. In short, the crypto hate is a reaction to the crypto hype. I have very little sympathy for people who profited from the hype, delivered approximately nothing of use to the rest of the world, and now have a sad that there are consequences.
- jnbiche 8y ago> In short, the crypto hate is a reaction to the crypto hype. Actually, as someone who was very interested in Bitcoin in the early days of 2011-2012, I disagree. If anything, the hate on HN was even greater back then, way before Bitcoin became hyped. So many people were convinced it was a pyramid scheme. It was clear to anyone familiar with the Bitcoin community back then that there were a lot of highly technical, talented people, and very few scammers. But most of HN reflexively despised Bitcoin. In fact, Bitcoin on HN is actually a lot less hated now, which tells me it has little to do with the hype, and that something else was going on. Bear in mind that I disassociated myself from Bitcoin once the scammers, con-men, and get-rich-quick types infiltrated the community around 2013 and 2014. But even back in 2011, there was a very high number of HNers who seemed personally affronted by the very idea that money was a social agreement. They seemed to believe that money was some kind of official, government activity, end of story. And that anyone who believed otherwise was an evil heretic, to be ridiculed. > I have very little sympathy for people who profited from the hype, delivered approximately nothing of use to the rest of the world, and now have a sad that there are consequences. This I agree with 100%.