8 ms·
One of the things I truly will never understand about "Audiophiles" is their willingness to spend money on products that are, from a technical basis, indisputab
by walrus01 8y ago
One of the things I truly will never understand about "Audiophiles" is their willingness to spend money on products that are, from a technical basis, indisputably categorized as snake oil. For instance:
https://www.amazon.com/AudioQuest-Diamond-feet-Braided-Cable/dp/B003CT08E4 https://www.amazon.com/AudioQuest-Diamond-feet-Braided-Cable...
It's an HDMI cable! The video signal has CRC in it and is packetized, it's either going to make it or it isn't. The quality of video delivered at, for instance, 2160p 60fps 10bit color to an expensive 80" 4K TV is going to be literally indistinguishable from the same video delivered by a $16 Amazon house brand HDMI cable.
Or this, it's a $340 cable for 1000BaseT Ethernet:
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/07/gallery-we-tear-apart-a-340-audiophile-ethernet-cable-and-look-inside/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/07/gallery-we-tear-apar...
People actually make the claim that their FLAC "sounds warmer" when transferred through this. How, exactly?
That's not enough? How about the $10,0000 1000BaseT Ethernet cable? https://arstechnica.com/staff/2015/02/to-the-audiophile-this-10000-ethernet-cable-apparently-makes-sense/ https://arstechnica.com/staff/2015/02/to-the-audiophile-this...
I can sort of understand methodology and expensive equipment modifications to separate AC power from amplifiers, and shield AC power lines and such, keep AC power runs away from speaker wires, etc. That has at least some basis in technological reality.
- snovv_crash 8y agoOne theory I read (for good quality USB cables to a DAC) is that reduced packet loss reduces jitter, which means that the clock rate of the DAC doesn't have to adjust in order to keep the buffer populated, but not overflowing. Sounds plausible, but I'm not sure that packet loss is high enough to actually cause this.
- AdrianB1 8y agoA working USB cable does not create packet loss and definitely does not fix packet loss; if packet loss occurs because of the cable, the cable is defective, nothing else. There is no good quality and bad quality, there are cables that work as expected and cables that are defective.
- stordoff 8y agoMore or less what I thought about the network cable in GP's post - if the network cable is changing how your FLACs sound, it's _broken_.
- oneplane 8y agoBut there is capacity, and USB1.1 may need less than USB2. That said, we can assume that we are talking about USB cables that are tested/verified/certified, which means they have to follow a few rules about how much Mhz bandwidth it supports, how much EMI it can deal with and how much drop in power it's going to cause. But of course, those are measurable facts and still have nothing to do with the data packets getting 'warm' or 'fuller' or some other subjective term.
- atoav 8y agoYeah but still, the biggest loss is going to happen within your plug/jack connection. So if you really care, solder your cables in. Better than every gold plated connector your audiophile purse is ever going to buy. Also: Acoustics are what matters the most (and they are the hardest to get right, just by throwing money at the problem, that is why it is not usually beeing discussed that much).
- sjwright 8y agoJitter is itself an audiophile scam. The audible consequences of extreme jitter is an increased noise floor, which itself is being drowned out by the sound in a typical "quiet" room.
- ansible 8y agoThe examples you linked are crazy. It is possible, especially with the Ethernet, to just check the packet error rate, and see if there is a problem. There's something to be said for a bit of extra effort in filtering, but most of what audiophiles pursue has no basis in electrical engineering reality.
- lmz 8y agoI've always wondered whether I could sell audiophile SATA cables for those who listen to music from their hard drives... Edit: a commenter below has a link to an actual audiophile SATA cable.
- CharlesW 8y agoYes, you can absolutely sell "HD SATA" cables. To paraphrase, "There's a new audiophile born every minute". https://jcat.eu/audiophile-sata-cable/ https://jcat.eu/audiophile-sata-cable/
- rubito 8y agohuh, besides the BS, isn't the file loaded into RAM first anyway?
- tlrobinson 8y agoYes, which is why this is one of the more absurd pieces of audiophile gear.
- sjwright 8y agoAnything "audiophile" in the digital domain is all equally absurd. The only difference is that some require a half-second of consideration and others require literally no thought at all to identify as stupid.
- tlrobinson 8y agoI wouldn't go as far to say "anything", but certainly most. As long as a DAC with sufficient resolution and stable clock is being fed with enough bits, then yes.
- sjwright 8y agoI would go that far. If it’s all-digital and marketed to audiophiles, it’s a scam and/or absurd. You can’t improve upon bit-perfect. (Room calibration being a notable exception.)
- bazwilliams 8y agoI often counter with the idea of transmitting an ebook over the same cable. "Does it become more detailed, in depth with more character development?" The only thing I can agree is better on a digital cable is increased shielding to avoid ground noise.
- bb88 8y agoTechnically there is jitter in the digital domain, and it's possible to see problems at high bandwidth signals, but in low bandwidth transmissions like Flac, you're absolutely right. If you have nanosecond timing requirements, then those might be useful, but for audio they are overkill. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jitter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jitter
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y agoFLAC????? Ew... Every audiophile knows that WAV sounds the best. FLAC quality is mediocre compared to WAV. Update: geez, it was satire... ...or was it? https://serato.com/forum/discussion/1541194 https://serato.com/forum/discussion/1541194 https://www.head-fi.org/threads/flac-vs-wav-format-surprising-quality-differences.366271/ https://www.head-fi.org/threads/flac-vs-wav-format-surprisin...
- hydrox24 8y agoYou were not downvoted because people took your comment literally, you were downvoted because being snarky runs against the Hacker News guidelines, specifically: > Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say face-to-face. Don't be snarky. Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. Sometimes snarky comments will be forgiven if they are substantive. Yours contributes very little beyond what the parent/grandparent comments had already mentioned.
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y agoThank you for the quick heads up! I’ll make sure to familiarize myself with said guidelines. It’s very useful!
- lmilcin 8y agoThe difference is that with digital signal there is limited number of components that actually make a difference and as soon as a certain level of quality is reached (basically reliable transmission) nothing can be improved further. For listening purposes the transmitted data can be buffered on the receiver DAC. This means that as long as the buffer on DAC is not emptied everything else may be failing badly and it will have zero effect on your listening experience.
- village-idiot 8y agoI’ll pay a bit extra for a nicely wrapped cable with really good anti-tangle and strain relief properties, because that’s convenient.
- GuB-42 8y agoAnd that's exactly what real high quality cable is. Professional cables are usually flexible, with robust insulation and connectors. They may also be fire rated. Quality control ensures that cables will always be up to specs because people doing the installation have other things to do than dealing with defective cables. Like most pro stuff, pro cables are not "better", they are cables that won't be a problem.
- village-idiot 8y agoSometimes “professional” just means “designed to handle a lot of abuse”.
- stordoff 8y ago> it's either going to make it or it isn't This isn't _strictly_ true - I've seen basically the equivalent of noise in a HDMI picture (white dots all over the picture), and eventually tracked it back to a faulty HDMI cable. I did replace it with the cheapest (<£5) HDMI cable I could find though, so there is that.
- oneplane 8y agoThat's not 'noise', that is packets that didn't make it. It's not having a perfect picture vs. no picture, but about data packets either going from A to B or not going from A to B. Say the HDMI cable is crap and it can only do 100 packets per second, and HDR needs 1000 packets per second, the HDMI chips are going to negotiate a HDMI transfer settings without HDR. Going back further, say the HDMI data path is negotiated to do only basic HDMI, say, DVI-like video. If even that is too much for the cable to handle, say, it constantly drops a few packets, you would get either perfect pixels or missing pixels.
- Dylan16807 8y agoHDMI doesn't have packets. It's largely digital VGA. It's very easy to flick individual bits, and the effect is basically the same as analog noise. The only difference is the threshold.
- duskwuff 8y agoAnd then there's even weirder audiophile accessories like cable elevators, amplifier stands, CD "demagnetizers", and "quantum chip" stickers -- all complete nonsense which doesn't even have any plausible way of affecting the audio.
- robocat 8y agoIf you believe in the placebo effect, then perhaps the nonsense can have a verifiable effect!!!
- danaos 8y agoAdmittedly I chuckled. The amazon cable you referenced is full of satirical comments.
- itchyouch 8y agoOne thing I can say about copper is that it is noisy. We are running FPGAs (with NICs) and were getting lots of packet errors over the copper cable SFP cables. Turns out, we either needed to write out noise cleanup logic into the FPGA, or add in a noise cleanup module which would add an extra 50ns to packet processing to the FPGA. Simple solution was to convert to fiber and the noise and errors all went away. I'd say if audiophiles truly want unmolested electricity, they ought to use optical fiber for as much of the run as possible.
- lmilcin 8y agoDigital transmission/storage ensures the signal is not affected no matter how much noise is on the line (well, as long as it can be transmitted at all...) Now, what I think you mean is that the copper in the cable picks up noise either from the device on the other end or from the surroundings and that has the possibility of affecting the DAC. Even moderately well designed receiver should be able to galvanically isolate itself from outside sources of noise without having to resort to fiberoptics or wireless. It's just couple of dollars max for extra few components on the board.
- TylerE 8y ago> Digital transmission/storage ensures the signal is not affected no matter how much noise is on the line (well, as long as it can be transmitted at all...) There is no such thing as a digital transmission. All signals are analog.
- mrob 8y agoDigital transmission refers to the whole transceiver system, not just the transmission medium. If I can put a "1" in and reliably get a "1" out, it doesn't matter that it was only a 0.9 part way down the wire.
- TylerE 8y agoBut that's the question, isn't it? If 0.0001% of the time you get 0.45v instead of 0.9v on the far end, now what?
- baddox 8y agoObviously don’t spend $1000 on a normal passive HDMI cable, but I’ve found that increasingly the all-or-nothing argument doesn’t work for some reason. I recently had to upgrade all my HDMI cables to get 4k HDR video working reliably. Before upgrading, the video would work, but I would occasionally see white “sparkles” on the video output. Googling this problem led me to many people recommending upgrading HDMI cables if you have very old cables.
- sopooneo 8y agoI don't know this world. But could it be because the HDMI protocol doesn't require correcting all errors? And newer cables produced fewer corrupt packets which might have resulted in "sparkle"?
- lmilcin 8y agoDifferent HDMI cables have different bandwidth which is a result of their physical construction, same way as you have different bandwidth ethernet cables. Sending signal on the edge of cable's capability may be causing intermittent problems.
- kalleboo 8y agoCertainly there are bad cables, and sparkles are clear signal dropouts. The description of that cable though, says Perfect-Surface Technology applied to extreme-purity silver provides unprecedented clarity and dynamic contrast. An HDMI cable can not affect the "clarity" or contrast of the image or audio it carries. It can just succeed or fail (and failure results in obvious pixel noise, not some overall lowering of contrast or clarity like in analog)
- jmalicki 8y agoAll cables have some probabilistic failure of corruption, it isn't binary. It's the same as what going from 5 9s in your application to 7 9s, which involves a huge cost with distributed databases multiple data centers etc. etc... For most people it's a waste, but if you really value not having the occasional white speck, it could be worth a better cable, which may cost a lot more to recover design costs of making a cable very few will want to buy.
- eiz 8y ago> It's an HDMI cable! The video signal has CRC in it and is packetized, it's either going to make it or it isn't. I don't disagree with your main point, but this actually isn't quite true. The HDMI signal is split into 3 distinct interleaved periods: video data, data island and control. Video data is not packetized and the only possible error detection it has is from TMDS signaling, but no such error handling is required by the TMDS spec. You can absolutely get imperfect transmission of an HDMI video signal due to cable or other electrical problems. Auxiliary packets in the data island, including audio data, do have an error correction scheme (BCH + TERC4). Feel free to check out the spec: https://glenwing.github.io/docs/HDMI-1.4b.pdf https://glenwing.github.io/docs/HDMI-1.4b.pdf
- charleslmunger 8y agoYes, but when when there's signal degradation in an HDMI cable it shows obviously, not as a subtle video quality change. If you can see an HDMI signal with white blinking dots everywhere, you can be confident that the cable is not altering the signal in any really detectable way.
- chaboud 8y ago"If you can see an HDMI signal with white blinking dots everywhere, you can be confident that the cable is not altering the signal in any really detectable way." I have seen an HDMI transmission with white blinking pixels at content edges that were not from the original signal. I ran test signal through that source and verified the errors on an HDMI waveform monitor, after which I tested the cable and threw it away. HDMI video is not magically impervious to error because it is digital. It's actually a pretty straightforward transmission scheme. This was while working on an HDMI-output device, working with team members who had written the original HDMI specifications (so, yes, I've read them). It is possible to have subtle degradation in HDMI-delivered content. It's rare, but possible. As one might expect, comprehensive failures (e.g. black screen, periodic HDCP key mismatch) are far more common, as are negotiation/configuration failures (e.g. wrong resolution, wrong framerate, wrong color space).
- cheeze 8y agoI think this is a straw man, since a majority of audiophiles will tell you that a 1000 dollar HDMI cable is stupid. nobody actually buys that shit. What does matter is getting a decent HDMI cable. I'm going to get a braided cable which I know supports the bandwidth of HDMI 2.1 (I think that's the current version). 1k? No. Probably more like 25.
- leguminous 8y agoHDMI cables used to be a great example, but now there are something like 8 different levels of certification and only the highest have the bandwidth to carry a 2160p, 60fps, 10 bit, 4:4:4 signal. And as far as I can tell, they are all passive so your source or sink can't warn you that your cable isn't compatible. You'll just get artifacts. The AmazonBasics cable will do 18Gbps, so it can do 2160p, 60fps, 10 bit, but only with chroma subsampling (which is fine because most video sources have chroma subsampling). The Amazon cable may work with a 4:4:4 signal, but it's not certified for it. There's a level above that for 48Gbps cables. I totally agree with the general idea, though. As long as a cable for a digital signal meets the specifications set by the standards body, you're good.
- walrus01 8y agoOkay, so the last time I bought hdmi cables I got 2.0 rated. Just looked and HDMI 2.1 rated 48Gbps cables are $25-35 each for 6 foot. That's not totally unreasonable. Now how is a $350 cable or a $800 cable any better?