3 ms·
Surely it is, considering the purchase cost of a car. But the daily cost is not insignificant. And if you can't afford a car, you pay the daily cost forever.
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
Surely it is, considering the purchase cost of a car.
But the daily cost is not insignificant. And if you can't afford a car, you pay the daily cost forever.
Cycling for an hour you burn maybe 2000 calories. That's a whole day's food. It can be your 2nd largest expense if you're poor. And the time spent on bicycle maintenance (tires, chain, wheels, adjustment etc) is 'easy to do yourself' for well-paid middle-class folks. After 12 hours in the factory or on your feet in a big box store, the time may not seem so cheap.
Then add in job risk when you get a flat on the way to work. Not insignificant if you're on a clock at a minimum-wage job. Could lose that job.
Its easy to enjoy bikes when well-employed and your time is your own. But for many they are part of being poor, part of the reason they stay poor.
- nradov 8y agoYour numbers are way off. Even elite pro cyclists are unable to burn 2000kcal/hr when racing. The estimate of 500kcal/hr is more realistic for regular people. Getting a flat is insignificant. You can change a tube in less than 5 minutes. New tubes and patch kits are very cheap. And cars also get flat tires.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoOk that estimate is better, 500 calories per hour. But how many calories per mile? That's the proper comparison. And again, 'very cheap' is relative. In a minimum-wage job it can be your entire discretionary income for you shift. And when I commuted by bicycle I got several flats over a year. I've driven a car for decades without a single flat that interrupted my trip (slow leaks). And actually not many folks can change a bicycle tire, certainly not in 5 minutes, not at the side of a busy street. All this glib dismissal of the cost of bicycling seems to stem from a fairly comfortable viewpoint.
- nradov 8y agoA typical cyclist burns about 48kcal/mi. In terms of cost of calories that's about $0.06 worth of Russet potatoes at Walmart. Call it $0.10 total if you include cooking costs. Very cheap. And remember that people burn a few calories just sitting in a car as well. https://caloriesburnedhq.com/calories-burned-biking/ https://caloriesburnedhq.com/calories-burned-biking/ Every cyclist I know can change a tube. Most people learned how to do this as children. For those who never learned, ParkTool has a great series of videos showing how to do basic maintenance. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqR6nlZNeU8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqR6nlZNeU8 The real reasons that people don't commute by bike include safety, comfort, time, security, and cargo capacity. It's not a cost issue. (I totally understand that bike commuting isn't practical for most people.)
- adrianN 8y agoThe 20€/month that I pay while not doing any maintenance myself is still cheaper than the insurance for a car. Cars can break down as well, frequently if you drive a pile of junk because you can't afford a good car. Flat tires are of course annoying, but they don't happen very frequently if you have for example Schwalbe Marathon tires and changing an inner tube is not terribly hard. Certainly easier than fixing a car, and at least an order of magnitude cheaper than a trip to a car mechanic. A more realistic problem with bikes for poor people is that you can't do terribly long commutes on a bike, so it limits the number of job offers you can accept without moving.
- cr0sh 8y agoRegarding flat tires on a bike - I have to endorse Amerityre's products here (as a satisfied customer - at least when I last rode a bike): https://amerityre.com/our-flat-free-products/flat-free-bicycle-tires/ https://amerityre.com/our-flat-free-products/flat-free-bicyc... They aren't cheap, but they also aren't your standard airless, flat-free tire, either. They don't feel like "mush" when you ride on them, making you have to pedal harder - they feel identical to a regular air-filled bicycle tire. You can drill a hole through them, and they still feel and work perfectly fine. If you ride a bike and tend to get a lot of flats, take a look into their products - you won't be disappointed.