3 ms·
I see a lot of people in this thread that view band photographers as disposable chaff that don't deserve the same copyright protection as everyone else, but I d
by whatshisface 8y ago
I see a lot of people in this thread that view band photographers as disposable chaff that don't deserve the same copyright protection as everyone else, but I doubt that anyone would want to take legal rights away from migrant fruit pickers in California. Migrant fruit pickers are very replaceable, so that doesn't add up.
Edit: In response to the shadowbanned comment that I can't reply to, I don't think there is a line beyond which extremely poor economic negotiation power crosses over into reduced status in the legal system in any court system or even moral system in the world... Except for metal band photographers, apparently. (With the possible second exception of third world countries.)
- Chris_Chambers 8y agoFor your whataboutism to be valid, everyone in the world would need to have their own personal fruit replication device in their pocket. In that case, no, we really don’t need migrant fruit pickers in California anymore.
- 1337biz 8y agoI am wondering - did they even wave their rights away for commercial use by letting that guy take pictures of them? The way I am seeing is that he is trying to make money off them without compensating them as his 'models'.
- whatshisface 8y agoWell, the author claims that they never had any rights to the photo he took at all. They still could have used another photo, but they instead picked what they thought was the best photo (his), using it without even contacting him.
- 1337biz 8y agoBut he can't be taking pictures at a concert of people and bands without their consent and then try selling these pictures to brands for commercial use.
- ghaff 8y agoThe crowd doesn’t really matter but I would think the band itself would have publicity rights for any commercial (in the sense of marketing or promotional) use. The photographer could presumably sell copies, publish in magazines, etc. A press pass for a concert could have other restrictions I guess but the whole purpose of a pro photographer taking pictures is to sell them.
- ozgurozkan 8y agoI am wondering why you feel this way. Legally it's wrong. Even under GDPR it's art. Photos taken for art purpose doesn't need any consent which also protects even street photographers.
- detaro 8y agoparent explicitly was talking about not-art use: > try selling these pictures to brands for commercial use Also, GDPR does not have an art exception per se, but it allows member states to create them. Legality of street photography is a complex topic and viewed differently in different jurisdictions.
- ozgurozkan 8y agoTaking a photo is a different action. You don't need a consent for it in public. Just taking a photo is the sole art purpose if you the aim is not distributing it. Selling those pictures to brands is a different action. Selling those pictures to the subject itself is different action. Using those pictures as a papparazzi is a different action. All of them is as complex as street photography. Legality of all photography intents viewed differently in different jurisdictions.
- ozgurozkan 8y agoLegally you can take a stranger's photo for yourself and keep it if it's in public. Unless there is a being model case the photo belongs to the photographer. So anyone can take pictures of people and bands in concerts and they do. Thing is how they're using them. If you sell that to a brand there should be a model release. On every other case even for the person itself he or she should pay for the sharing license. Take real models as an example they are being photographed and they are released in stock photo markets the only thing they can do is finding themselves on that marketplace. Later on they share stock photo branded screenshots :). Because they don't pay for the original ones. They need to pay for the photos that includes them as the subject.
- barrkel 8y agoI'm not suggesting taking legal rights away from the photographer. I already said I think the photographer is legally in the right. I don't want courts to switch things up, or legislators to change the situation. What I am saying is that the economics of the situation exist. They can't be wished away. Outcomes tend to follow economics, even if they're illegal, as the existence of black markets, forced arbitration, legal battles based on spending and might rather than right, etc. show. And sometimes the economics are morally superior to the legality, even when the legality is nice and clear. Part ownership of content production would be morally superior to the bright line clarity of copyright ownership. Ideally, it would reflect how much of the global culture is a part of content, how much is ideas floating in the air, and the multitudes of people who contribute to the gestalt of a moment. But the accounting is impossible. So the legality is simple, and sometimes it creates conflict. The answer is usually more law - signed agreements up front, etc. A copyright that accounted for value added - if it were possible, calculable without continuous auctions and comparisons against alternatives, which is of course impossible generally - would accrue mostly to the band (and, recursively, to people who influenced the band), I reckon. But I think trying to implement something like that is impossible, and like I said, I don't think things should change. Instead, the band should make photographers sign something first.
- whatshisface 8y ago>Part ownership of content production would be morally superior Whether or not this is true, the band is transgressing a hidden rule that is actually more important than copyright. They are changing the deal after the fact. If they had required the photographer to sign away his rights, he would have had the option to find another band that didn't. By not requiring any signatures but then turning around and acting like they got them, they are essentially tricking everyone. The idea that you are not supposed to do this is both pretty intuitive to everyone, and also is more or less the fundamental axiom of contract law. I'd expect an anarchist metal band to be anti-civic, but not like that! ;)
- barrkel 8y ago> They are changing the deal after the fact What deal is that? The way I see it, the photographer and the band each had different ideas of "the deal". The degree to which the deal "changed" is the difference between prior conceptions of the deal and the reconciliation when the conceptions came into conflict and reached a synthesis. The band thought they were creating something and thought they could merchandise it. The photographer thought he was creating something and thought he could stop someone else merchandising it. The photographer was legally right. I suspect the band is more morally right than wrong in an ideal world of copyrights - and I think copyright is a very imperfect concept - and I think they have the economic power to ensure their merchandise is legally sound in future, having learned this lesson.
- pjc50 8y agoWait until you hear how the music industry treats session musicians...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sorum 8y agoThat sounds like an interesting thread in itself. Please share some highlights, or rather...lowlights.
- techopoly 8y agoIn the 70s, Clare Torry was paid £30 for providing the improvisational vocals in Pink Floyd's "The Great Gig in the Sky" on "The Dark Side of the Moon." Over the next several decades, she received none of the revenue earned from the massive success of this album. In 2005, she sued Pink Floyd and EMI for songwriting royalties, and reached a settlement with them. She is now credited as a composer of the song in modern releases of the album. Most session musicians probably aren't so fortunate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clare_Torry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clare_Torry
- geofft 8y ago"Legal rights" is a vague phrase. I certainly don't think migrant fruit pickers should be able to copyright their fruits! Copyright is a tool for giving a temporary government monopoly—a distortion of the free market—for the promotion of "science and useful arts". It attempts to emulate the market behavior of physical objects (like, oh, fruits) when the valuable work is easy to copy. I believe certain things about its appropriate use and the markets to which it is suited. That has little bearing on my beliefs about other markets or the value of free markets in general. I believe copyright is a bad tool to protect labor rights (just as I believe machine guns are a bad tool to protect labor rights); that doesn't mean I think labor rights aren't worth protecting. Besides, my actual belief is migrant farm laborers should be documented (i.e., we should have open borders, the historic policy of America back when it allegedly was "great") and unionized and receive a UBI and preferably live under fully automated luxury gay space communism. At that point copyright doesn't really matter, certainly not as a tool to protect fungible workers.
- baddox 8y agoIf migrant fruit pickers were claiming to have legal rights over digital representations of specific fruits, then I think people would have similar reactions.
- lmm 8y agoFruit picking is hard work. Photography is fun to the point that a lot of people do it as a hobby.
- beokop 8y agoSo is programming. Should clients be able to just take your code without paying for it?
- lmm 8y agoI'm talking about what is the case, not what should be. At the moment people with programming skills are much rarer than demand for programmers. No doubt if and when that crosses over we'll see the bottom fall out of programmer pay.