9 ms·
Sydney Opal Tower: Thousands evacuated after 'crack'
- ams6110 8y agoCreaking and cracking noises are common in tall buildings from my experience, but in this case it seems an actual crack in the structure has been found
- paranoidrobot 8y agoBut not suddenly starting and running for the course of an hour or so, and audible from neighbouring apartment blocks.
- _kyran 8y agoTo any structural engineers, what kind of tolerance are buildings like this usually built to? How much movement can they take? 2mm doesn't seem like much at all.
- saagarjha 8y agoAlso depends on what moved, and in which direction. I’m sure the building sways much more than that in the wind, or expands more than that on a hot day.
- tomarr 8y ago2mm is fine and normally within measurement error. However, buildings should be designed to not fail disproportionately, so there isn't sudden failure such as like with the Miami footbridge. Design errors can lead to sections being over reinforced or other issues which could lead to collapse with little warning, which is what the concern will be. Edit : also with cracks it depends on where they are and what causes with them. Cracks are normal for concrete and the size should be controlled through detailing. Where cracks are larger than this it can indicate whether there are issues in bending/shear. Structural design also often takes into account behavior of cracked concrete.
- maccas 8y agoBuildings are designed to move, because that's the way they absorbe energy without suddenly breaking. The deformation up to breakage is deemed to be in plastic mode, so the building "advises" when something is wrong by exerting plastic deformation and cracking. The modern building code of australia is aimed at plastic deformation, and the formation of fissures, that's considered a fair balance between safety and cost. The deformations seen in this building are in the millimetres, but if doors and windows are jammed, then there is a more serious problem, it could be a foundations' problem, it could be the precast system problem, it could be the main frame, or anything in between. I am an unemployed civil engineer because companies fill their vacancies with adventurers from overseas, pakistan or Filippines for example. I have been forced to work as a draftsman while these people, often on working visas take all the jobs, because they are cheap professionals and workers. this is how low the professions are falling in Australia. I don't see the moment to finish my masters and run from Sydney. I am sick of the things I am seeing here.
- matte_black 8y agoWill insurance cover this if the building is no longer safe for residents?
- becga 8y agoNot if the insurance companies can help it.
- twelvechairs 8y agoTheoretically the system is set up to do this but in practice its complex and takes time. Insurers and lawyers can have a field day over liability. Was it the builders fault? The structural engineer? The architect? Or caused after construction? All of these will have their own insurance and all will avoid paying unless its clear to a court that its their liability. Of course major issues like this dont happen so often so theres little to reference. But for example there was a recent case where the owners corporration insurance refused to pay for a roof flying off after a storm because in their view poor construction was to blame. Its a lot of time for residents to be without a home while these things are sorted https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/insurer-rejects-stormdamaged-lidcombe-apartment-building-claim-because-of-numerous-defects-20160408-go1kz5.html https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/insurer-rejects-stormdam...
- jpatokal 8y agoIn Sydney it's also common for builders/management companies/etc to declare bankruptcy to deflect lawsuits etc, then set up a new company to continue business.
- hornetblack 8y agoThey also don't have to finish everything in the building. Moved into a building where the construction company did this, many things were unfinished. Apparently didn't completely pay the workers, so they just took stuff when they left.
- cyphar 8y ago> It's a lot of time for residents to be without a home while these things are sorted. Though if you're renting, you can break your lease without fees and get your bond back if the building is no longer classified as being safe to live in (at least that's the NSW rental laws). But of course if you're renting then home insurance isn't your problem (usually you'd just have contents insurance).
- _fs 8y agoFascinating post by a structural engineer who actually inspected projects by this firm is over in the reddit discussion. https://www.reddit.com/r/sydney/comments/a91wit/opal_tower_structural_damage_sydney_olympic_park/ecg3tpz/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sydney/comments/a91wit/opal_tower_s...
- rwmj 8y agoA comment by someone in an adjacent building who heard the cracking sounds: https://www.reddit.com/r/sydney/comments/a91wit/opal_tower_structural_damage_sydney_olympic_park/ecfzjwf/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sydney/comments/a91wit/opal_tower_s...
- currysausage 8y ago"i kept hearing sounds every half a minute" - So there should be a recording available somewhere, possibly on social media?
- stefan_ 8y agoFeels like I could write the exact same post about software engineering. Some party apply directly (copy-paste with some crucial yet infinitesimal differences).
- ObsoleteNerd 8y agoI've lived in a Meriton apartment complex in Sydney. It was one of the complexes built right in the biggest part of the boom, when they were rolling out "largest development in Sydney/Australia" one after the other, trying to outdo themselves and each other. We moved in (renting) when it was brand new, peeling the plastic off the appliances etc. Within 1 year they were doing MAJOR fixes to building-scale defects in the construction, and within 2-3 years we had cracks in the walls, paint flaking off, doors that didn't line up, windows that didn't seal when closed. This is on a ~8th level apartment, and these aren't cheap apartments. They're not luxury, but they're comfortable in the "mid-to-high" end of the Sydney scale, just on the edge of the CBD. We since moved out of Sydney, but we'll never live in a new-build Apartment again. The hell we went through, just as a renter in those few years, was mind boggling. Giving engineers and tradies access to our apartment seemingly every week, sometimes every day for days on end, so they could inspect and fix issues. I can't even imagine how bad it is for people who got suckered/conned into buying those POS apartments.
- warent 8y agoI've never heard of anything like this. What happens now? Do they have to demolish the entire building and start from scratch?
- cronix 8y ago> I've never heard of anything like this. This is kind of small compared to the Millennium Tower in San Francisco. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/millennium-tower-san-francisco-leaning-tower-of-lawsuits-60-minutes/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/millennium-tower-san-francisco-...
- warent 8y agoI lived right near that thing and knew it was sinking a bit, but had no idea it was leaning so far and with cracks too. WOW! That's terrifying, and I'm more relieved than ever to be away from that thing. Do you think anyone is going to do anything about this before a catastrophe?
- cronix 8y agoI don't track it, but last I heard there was a proposal that would cost ~$100M to drive micropilons down to bedrock, which is what should have been mandated in the main design to begin with. https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Millennium-Tower-homeowners-propose-100-million-13440479.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Millennium-Tower... Some windows are starting to crack as well. https://sf.curbed.com/2018/9/7/17829328/millennium-tower-window-crack-highrise https://sf.curbed.com/2018/9/7/17829328/millennium-tower-win...
- HillaryBriss 8y agoI recall early stories about Millennium Tower and the builder basically claiming, through a law firm, that it was a normal amount of settling and everything was fine. Nothing to see here.... And I bet the same sort of response will come from the builder of Opal Tower in Sydney.
- danieltillett 8y agoI live in Sydney and I wouldn't buy any property built since 1970 and especially any property built since 2000. I have friends in the industry and the horror stories they tell me are shocking. The real problem is coming in a few years as the waterproof membranes protecting the rebar in all these high rise buildings has in almost all cases not been put in correctly - in 10 to 20 years the concrete cancer will be so bad that these building will need to be demolished.
- cauldron 8y agoFast economy then.
- darkpuma 8y agoA one kilometer evacuation seems extreme. I assume dust is the justification for that, but surely you could just tell people to close their windows if they're not in range for falling debris. And where are 3.14 square kilometers worth of people supposed to relocate themselves to while waiting for the building to fall? Do hotels in Sydney really have that sort of spare capacity? I wonder how many people are just going to ignore that 1km evacuation order.
- jpatokal 8y agoThe building in question is in Sydney Olympic Park, a relatively sparsely populated area far from the city center that used to be industrial wasteland and is now mostly sports facilities (surprise!): https://maps.app.goo.gl/uZDA8 https://maps.app.goo.gl/uZDA8 However, there have been quite a few shiny new apartments going up lately, including this one. And as is the case for almost all residential construction in Sydney lately, the quality tends to be shocking. Update: the wide evacuation has been cancelled and most tower residents can now return. However, 51 units have been declared structurally unsafe: https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/olympic-park-residents-make-new-sleeping-arrangements-after-christmas-eve-evacuation-20181224-p50o5h.html https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/olympic-park-residents-m...
- userbinator 8y agoand most tower residents can now return. However, 51 units have been declared structurally unsafe How does that work? That's a very strange statement to make. They're implying those 51 units may collapse and leave the rest intact...? Even if I wasn't in those 51, I wouldn't go back except perhaps to quickly get some stuff and move out.
- jfoster 8y agoThat's a good point. > NSW Police Acting Assistant Commissioner Julie Boon said "an internal support wall failed" in the building. If one failed, though, is there any reason why others won't?
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beerlord 8y agoJust for context, Sydney is growing by about 100,000 people annually, due to massive immigration from China and India. With this tower having 300 units, and assuming 2 people on average per unit, we would need to build 3.2 of these giant towers weekly to house every arrival... By 2067, Sydney is projected to reach 9.5 million people from 5.2 million currently, whereas with net-zero overseas migration it would fall slightly to 4.8 million over the same timeframe. Additionally, Australia's laws on real-estate money laundering are lax, so foreign criminals will dump their ill-gotten cash into Australian real-estate. Many of these apartment buildings are sold to Chinese syndicates, not Australian families, which is why so many of the apartments are tiny one-bedrooms (allowing a cheaper cost of entry). I've walked into some of the sales display offices of one of these developments before, and all of the marketing material is in Chinese. There are other failings at an institutional level, where building inspections have been outsourced and can now be conducted by private certified individuals, not Government officers. So in this case excessive immigration is literally destroying Sydney... And the NSW State Government agrees, as they are requesting the Federal Government reduce immigration numbers.
- kingofpandora 8y agoAh yellow peril.
- bouncycastle 8y agoAnnecdote: I often find that buildings in Australia vibrate / shake. One that stands out in my mind, there's a shopping center in southern Sydney suburb of Hurstville, at one particular spot, it feels like a short tremblor is striking every 10 mins, to the point where I looked up if anyone else may be concerned. There are a lot of cracks in the concrete, but I think that I've read somewhere that as long as the cracks are vertical, that's not bad. However, I'm somehow not convinced that this building would survive should a small real earthquake occur (rare for Sydney, but there was a Newcastle one in recent memory).
- jazoom 8y agoAlso anecdote: I've lived in 3 different Australian states over 30 years and have never once felt the ground or a building shake. This is not an "Australia" thing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jboles 8y agoThe Hurstville shopping centre is right above a train station; Australia is largely earthquake free.
- rjst01 8y agoI used to work on the 7th floor of the building at 1-5 Railway St, Chatswood. Sometimes at around 5pm the building would shake subtly but noticeably, we theorised it was from the trains passing underneath.
- cyphar 8y ago> However, I'm somehow not convinced that this building would survive should a small real earthquake occur (rare for Sydney, but there was a Newcastle one in recent memory). The last major earthquake we had in Australia was in the 1989 (and was the 5.6 Newcastle one you mentioned). Since then there have only been 15 earthquakes, many of them less than 4th magnitude. A major earthquake almost 30 years ago is hardly recent. We're in the middle of a tectonic plate, earthquakes are extraordinarily rare.
- maccas 8y agoI am a civil engineer, preparing my thesis for a masters in geotechnical engineering, and unemployed. Last job i had was with a precast crook employing chinese designers and workers. I was forced to work as a draftsman, because I could not get a job as engineer. I don't give two cents for the apartments they are building, and I will comfortably move out of sydney once I get my masters degree. That's the sole reason I am in Sydney. I may even contemplate the possibility of moving overseas, Australia is becoming toxic for professionals.
- Birks 8y agoThat's what you get for living at the godforsaken end of the world. Y'all have imported a third world mentality during the last two decades... A bit like the US.
- becga 8y agoReading a lot of the comments here about poor quality of new construction have resonated with my own recent experience: I left a luxury high-rise in Chicago that had been built within the last ten years. The building was a later addition to a retail building which contained restaurants and shops. Shortly after moving in, I'd come home to find old grease and trash smells or the smell which I can only describe as an old warehouse. Thinking it was just residual odors, I would clean and re-clean and later installed a couple of hepa portable filtration systems but the odors remained. Started looking around only to find there was little to no sealant around openings for the sprinkler systems, or underneath the sink unit/washing machine, or any of the flooring etc. Because the building was pressurized, the odors from the grease traps and/or trash units deep below would come in through even the wall sockets. Mind you, this wasn't every day but regular enough to be very unpleasant. Similar complaints from other residents about cigarette odors coming in their apartments but building management would never be able to trace down issue and would just have restaurants empty out grease traps. All this for an apartment I spent nearly 3,000 a month for. My advice to others is to be very skeptical of any new buildings no matter the location and to be very sure you know what you are getting into.