9 ms·
Nor should it be. The way discussions about Facebook policing content are framed rubs me the wrong way. Facebook should not be put in a position where it's res
by AlexandrB 8y ago
Nor should it be.
The way discussions about Facebook policing content are framed rubs me the wrong way. Facebook should not be put in a position where it's responsible for dealing with authoritarianism, extremism, and other societal ills. The only reason it seems like it has to do this is that we've allowed Facebook to become a near-monopoly on a certain form of social networking.
The solution is not trying to compel or convince Facebook to act as an arbiter of morality for the world; it is to break Facebook up and restrict it's ability to monopolize the online space. Real competition in social networking would mean communities could form their own rules and norms around what's acceptable - like in the forum era - without relying on a central authority such as Facebook to do it for them. A decentralized protocol/system like Mastodon allows this kind of partitioning of the social space.
Would this stop authoritarianism? No. But it would turn censorship into a game of whack-a-mole, and limit the spread of authoritarian ideas to the social networks whose communities are already OK with that.
- api 8y agoI think Facebook helped create some of this problem with the algorithmic timeline. Content is prioritized to drive engagement. What drives engagement? Hate, fear, outrage, and extreme inflammatory rhetoric of every kind. Same goes for YouTube and its algorithmic recommendation system, which subjectively seems much worse to me. If you program a computer to select social content to drive engagement, you are pretty much programming it to push negativity. Negative, controversial, and divisive content always gets the most attention. The media and entertainment industry have always known this and used it, but never before had the feedback loop been so tight and efficient.
- kbrisso 8y agoI think you are right. It amplifies bad stuff based on shares and likes. It doesn't post things in linear time order. I wish you could filter those stupid political memes too. That's what I like about Reddit or this place I choose what I want to see.
- dvtrn 8y agoNegative, controversial, and divisive content always gets the most attention. The other side of this pendulum are affects worth mentioning as well-when we talk about the 'algorithmic platform', not long ago there was a discussion about Tumblr and it's recent decision to remove certain types of material: is the very nature of "optimizing for engagement" itself. Someone came along and shared a tale of how his pre-teen daughter got addicted to blogs and content that promoted and encouraged anorexia on the platform targeted at her because of her likes, follows and interactions and eventually developed an eating disorder and serious anxiety issues. More than one person came along and commented along of how they've seen friends go into similar communities and come out a different person, often times for the worse, with several longstanding and previously healthy relationships irreparably damaged and in some cases wholesale destroyed when the platform optimized for engagement and sends innocent people down destructive rabbit holes. The other side of the negative, controversial and divisive are the isolating, unhealthy, and dangerous to individuals susceptible to manipulation through plain jane ignorance/not knowing better when presented with material that might not be divisive because of trolls, bullies or agents of political avarice, but encourages destructive tendencies to the uninitiated or ill-equipped. All facilitated because 'the platform' rewards you for likes and shares.
- api 8y agoYes that's another similar and related phenomenon. There are similar stories around of parents finding their teenage kids programmed with neo-Nazi or similar ideologies from spending time in video game forums and then following some rabbit hole. I remember following rabbit holes as a teen but for some reason my natural tendency toward skepticism defended me from the crazier stuff. If anything contact with nutty sorts of conspiracy theories and cult ideologies just made me more of a skeptic. It seems that some people are more prone to getting sucked in.
- dvtrn 8y agoIt seems that some people are more prone to getting sucked in. Obligatory cautionary/curiousity-laden counterpoint to inquire if people are more prone to it now or if we as observers are exposed to more examples of the phenomenon taking place-thanks to social networks and the one-to-many nature of broadcasting our every thought out to the aether?
- te_chris 8y agoBut they do already control what we see! The alogrithmic timeline is the exact feature that causes all this bollocks and its so mis-designed.
- sdenton4 8y ago...when gradient descent proceeds by goose-steps...
- cabalamat 8y ago> it is to break Facebook up and restrict it's ability to monopolize the online space. Real competition in social networking would mean communities could form their own rules and norms around what's acceptable - like in the forum era - without relying on a central authority such as Facebook to do it for them. Yes. One thing holding back competition is network effects, i.e. if I create a new social network, it isn't very useful until a significant number of people are on board. Fortunately now we have the federated social networking with the Fediverse, so a new network can piggyback on all the users in the Fediverse (and the new network in turn helps grow the Fediverse). > A decentralized protocol/system like Mastodon allows this kind of partitioning of the social space. Nitpick: Mastodon is a system, the protocol is ActivityPub.
- Alex3917 8y ago> if I create a new social network, it isn't very useful until a significant number of people are on board. That's a common misconception. As a social network creator, your job is to create a substantial amount of single player value in addition to multiplayer value, precisely to avoid this sort of chicken and egg problem. If your social network isn't both useful and differentiated (i.e. doing something completely different than FB) even when no other people are using it, then you have a real problem. That's why when Facebook launched it was basically just a prettier skin over the Harvard student directory, so that way it was valuable even if there were no other people using it.
- tivert 8y ago>> if I create a new social network, it isn't very useful until a significant number of people are on board. > That's why when Facebook launched it was basically just a prettier skin over the Harvard student directory, so that way it was valuable even if there were no other people using it. Facebook also launched in small, elite communities first, which allowed it to exploit network effects in communities that were more manageable than the global internet. I think that many people make the mistake of thinking of the "social" network as global-level vat filled with a solution of essentially identical nodes, and the "network effect" as a power caused by a product having a high concentration in that solution. In reality, the global "social" network is more like a warehouse full of jars, and smaller players start by building up their product's concentration in a fraction of those jars, instead of all the jars at once.
- pohl 8y ago[crosses fingers] hope the authoritarian wannabes in power are keen on antitrust regulations, then.
- Iv 8y agoForce facebook to have an open api. The rest will follow naturally.
- saddlerustle 8y agoFacebook giving away your data through its api is exactly what got us access to everything in the hands of cambridge analytica and huawei. They shouldn't be allowed to have an open api.
- whatshisface 8y agoIf Facebook closes their API, then Facebook still has the data. I understand how letting many companies have the data is worse than only one company having the data, but I am not so happy that Facebook has it in the first place.
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agoI wonder if some of this could be solved with stricter checks on where an ad-campaign is purchased from and by limiting the reach to that country / region. Say, a company in Overtheristan buys a campaign to target French users it should be prohibited to do so unless it has a physical presence in France which can be sued. Maybe it would limit the meddling/damage that can be done. Not that this is very elegant, but it seems better then the suggestion often aired in media and politics which discriminate against free speech ... This sounds silly (probably because it is) but would be interested what the rest of you thinks. Personally I'd have no problem with totally regulating ad-tech in a way that prohibits targeting users in other countries/jurisdictions. Also facebook should be held responsible in that country so that when a genocide like with the Rohinga happens then the CEO of that entity can answer questions in The Hague
- RandomTisk 8y agoI'm a huge proponent of nearly unlimited freedom of speech. What I think is a great solution is a platform that allows nearly unlimited free speech, but requires opt-in tags for all content. So if one wanted to talk about "highly controversial topic x" whether in a way that's neutral, flatteringly or not so flatteringly, the content needs to be tagged as "highly controversial topic x" content before it's made public or the user will get banned. The upshot here is that both users and advertisers could easily find and avoid content they want and don't want exposure to, and nobody has to be gagged and dragged down to the ministry of love.
- brosirmandude 8y agoCan't this be done using NLP, or even just pulling term frequency within content? I imagine FB (& whoever else has access to the data) has to be doing this on the backend somewhere for their own research. We essentially need a Google (the framework which they use to algorithmically understand web content) for social networks with a front-end UI for topical mapping. -- Also to add to your idea, I'd be very interested in a social network that can do that, but also requires real ID's and has some sort of public display of the topics that any user talks about and engages with often. That way if I'm talking to someone I can gauge if they're really someone I want to be talking to about a particular topic. (can also be used to better map taste to reviews of products/services/companies/etc)
- empath75 8y agoIf Facebook becomes a haven for nazis and racists, normal people and advertisers will stop using it.
- robertAngst 8y agoI tried using Voat, toxic community. SO I can agree with this comment. Heck, FB sucks. Or rather, seeing my supposedly libertarian friends support Tariffs and Wall spending has sucked.
- amiga-workbench 8y agoI tried both Voat and Gab, they're complete shitholes with Gab being the most egregious. I've been somewhat active on Mastodon for about a fortnight and I'm finding the experience much better. I'm peered up with people with similar interests and it doesn't feel like I'm screaming into the void as is the case on Twitter.
- nkkollaw 8y agoAgree. Being an American company, if Facebook were to _officially_ edit content it would become a publisher rather than a platform, and having to follow laws that publishers have to follow would make them go bankrupt in no time.
- closeparen 8y ago"Communities could form their own rules and norms around what's acceptable" is exactly the problem. The criticism against Facebook is that it failed to stop this, and communities emerged with norms too far away from mainstream. Facebook "didn't do enough" to enforce mainstream norms on all its dark corners. Facebook critics generally want more centralization so that people are exposed to opposing viewpoints and a uniform sensibility on what is and isn't true. More decentralization is a recipe to spiral further and further into fragmented echo chambers with their own self-reinforcing ideologies and their own alternative facts.
- ForHackernews 8y agoBut with fewer people subject to them! There's always been echo chambers of extremists out there, but they aren't big enough to swing elections in most democracies.
- philwelch 8y ago> Facebook critics generally want more centralization so that people are exposed to opposing viewpoints and a uniform sensibility on what is and isn't true. No. Facebook critics want centralization so that people exposed to viewpoints within the narrow, mainstream window of acceptable opinion and completely isolated from anything outside that window.
- ViViDboarder 8y agoThe article doesn’t seem to be making as much a point about Facebook policing content but rather protecting individuals who are being jailed, beaten, or killed by their own governments for things that they post.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nopriorarrests 8y agoI'am not sure that you can break facebook up without very far reaching consequences for US market and economy in general. This is half a trillion company, after all. The cascade of margin calls will remind you about bear sterns in 2008.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoThey said the same thing about Standard Oil, except after it was broken up there were a bunch of new companies to invest in and make money from.
- nopriorarrests 8y agoAt this moment the only facebook product I use is whatsapp, which is free of ads thanks to being sponsored by instagram and facebook itself. Once whatsapp becomes an independent company, I will probably start getting personal messages from Ford, Nike and KFC. It will be a great company to invest to and make money from, I agree.
- Apocryphon 8y agoMaybe the founders will return, reinstitute the plan for a dollar a year subscription. They seemed to have their values right.
- philwelch 8y agoAnd AT&T, except after it was broken up, all the different pieces all started merging with each other again.
- e1ven 8y agoMicrosoft was worth approximately 1 trillion dollars in 1999 (adjusted for inflation). There was a plan in place to split them up, which was only scuttled because Pres. Bush won the election.
- nopriorarrests 8y ago
- simplecomplex 8y agoSo I shouldn’t be allowed to use Facebook because some people see ads and vote republican? Because I can post what I want whether or not it’s true or you agree with it? The only authoritarianism here is your call to forcibly break up Facebook to silence speech you don’t like.
- TomMckenny 8y agoThe article is about the Bangladesh government using torture to force people to login to Facebook and jail and beat them further if they have criticized their right wing government. Does that make it anti Republican?
- perfmode 8y agoThis would turn regulation into a game of whack-a-mole. How do you break up something as pervasive and nebulous and interrelated as FB? What prevents the separate entities from forging close partnerships? I don't see how breaking up FB would work in practice. Maybe someone more knowledgeable could clue me in.
- tragic 8y agoYou could split off the ad selling wing from the rest of it for a start. It would be drastic, for obvious reasons, but forcible de-merging huge businesses is always drastic, cf Hollywood, Ma Bell, and so forth. Nothing would stop close partnerships but GDPR-style regulation would hopefully stop the most egregiously invasive kinds of data brokerage. The truth is that regulation is always and everywhere a game of whack a mole, and as long as capitalism exists someone will have to wave the comedy mallet around.
- Pyxl101 8y ago> You could split off the ad selling wing from the rest of it for a start. Normally when businesses are split up, they are broken into multiple pieces that each have their own revenue and are viable standalone businesses. In this case, the ad-selling part of Facebook is the entire business as far as financials are concerned. It's the only material source of revenue for Facebook. If you were to split the ad-selling wing from Facebook, then the "remaining part" would have no revenue. A regulator action along these lines is tantamount to crippling or shutting down the business. Source: Facebook Q3 2018 earnings show that the only material revenue is advertising at $13.5 billion (Q3 2018): https://investor.fb.com/investor-events/event-details/2018/Facebook-Q3-2018-Earnings/default.aspx https://investor.fb.com/investor-events/event-details/2018/F... For comparison, Microsoft reports earnings from many separate lines of business including Windows OEM, Office, Office 365, Enterprise Services, LinkedIn, Azure, server products, Gaming, etc. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/Investor/earnings/FY-2018-Q3/press-release-webcast https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/Investor/earnings/FY-2018-Q3...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]