8 ms·
My understanding is that a city boundary in the US is a big deal. The police force on either side can be completely different, things that can get you in a lot
by chrisseaton 8y ago
My understanding is that a city boundary in the US is a big deal. The police force on either side can be completely different, things that can get you in a lot of trouble like gun laws can be different on either side, prices and taxes can be very different.
In the UK a city boundary doesn't really mean anything. There might be a nice 'Welcome to X' sign but nothing really changes as it would in the US. I'm not even sure there is a legal boundary for cities here? There is for parliamentary constituencies and for local government areas, but not for cities unless they happen to overlap, that I know of.
So city boundaries in the UK don't really matter so aren't rigid, where in the US they are important and so rigid and so carefully designed.
- captainbland 8y agoIt depends a lot I think. London's an interesting case, because depending on what part of London you're in you're dealing with a totally different police force - in the City of London, there's the City of London police but this only covers the square mile. Most of London is policed by the Metropolitan Police. Administratively, the City of London and everything else in London it's totally separate. The City has The Lord Mayor of London, the rest has Sadiq Khan. Most of London has boroughs and councilors. The City has a bizarre system where so-called Aldermen are elected by guilds from businesses local to the area, along with an amount of councillors representing the local population. Councils do have the ability to set policy for how certain laws are enforced and have some powers to create bye-laws although I'm struggling to remember the specific pieces of legislation which are relevant to this at the moment.
- dullgiulio 8y agoThe City of London is the exception, not the norm. The history of how it came to this situation is also pretty interesting (the City is what should be called London, not the rest of the city.) It's a less extreme version of what happens in Rome with the Vatican, which is a completely different country. But in either case, it's just one inclave. The article talks about jigsaws happening in almost every city.
- cobbzilla 8y agoIndeed. CGPgrey did a nice video about these peculiarities of London: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LrObZ_HZZUc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LrObZ_HZZUc
- Normal_gaussian 8y agoThe city of London is such a small and specific case; and it really isn't relevant to the jurisdictions of the outer boundaries (:. shapes) of British cities.
- wlll 8y agoInteresting article/video on the City of London http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/the-secret-city-of-london.html http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/the-secret-city-of-london.html
- mattmanser 8y agoIt does make more of a difference than you think, though as you say it's nowhere near as marked as America. My city, Nottingham, likes volunteering to trial things. So we were the first or one of the first cities to have average speed cameras years ago, we also introduced a workspace parking levy. The former has gone nationwide, but the latter hasn't been adopted anywhere else. The planners in Nottingham also love traffic lights and are utterly shit at roundabouts. It's a frustrating city to drive in, but has great, regular, buses and now trams. That's very different to other areas, like Colchester where I lived before had loads of roundabouts and tended to phase out traffic light junctions for roundabouts. But it used to have fairly rubbish buses to the nearby towns.
- chrisseaton 8y agoRight but that's comparing a city in the north to a city miles away in the south. We're talking about the immediate boundary between outside a city and inside a city, aren't we? My local city is Chester, and I couldn't even tell you where the limit of Chester is now - I presume it's no longer the old Roman walls. When you cross that boundary wherever it is, nothing changes. It's still the same local government authority, still the same police force.
- mprev 8y agoIsn’t there a welcome to Wales sign on one side of the city? I always find it fun driving over the border and suddenly you can araf at the gwasanethau for a paned o de.
- chrisseaton 8y agoBut that's because you're leaving the country, not because you're leaving the city. The city boundary isn't relevant there - the country boundary is.
- mprev 8y agoWell, sure, I’m not saying otherwise. It was just a comment unworthy of a parry.
- pjc50 8y agoThe UK is an extremely centralised state by comparison with the US or even most European countries - almost all decisions are made at Westminster, and the central government can override the devolved assemblies if it really wants to. The taxations powers devolved to councils are fairly minimal and also overridden by central government at whim. And there's no history of segregation.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoTrue sadly, 1974 local government reorganisation set us on the route to ever more centralisation. That seems to have continued under every government since. Go back earlier and local government actually had ability to achieve things. Things that suited the locality. Now everyone from county and town councils can vote against x (eg fracking) and Whitehall happily steamroller over it. The north shall have the ugly stuff, the south east the infrastructure and spending.
- ChrisSD 8y agoThere is some rigidity in the UK. The "green belt"[0] is meant to constrain urban sprawl. Admittedly these constraints aren't set in stone and can be changed. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_belt_(United_Kingdom) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_belt_(United_Kingdom)
- Spooky23 8y agoCorrect. In some states cities are like counties and have more legislative power from the state. In the past cities had much more political power than towns, and were able to annex and do other things. My city looks sort of like a pork chop, as they annexed railyards at the city edge in the late 19th century for tax revenue.
- cjf4 8y ago>My understanding is that a city boundary in the US is a big deal. The police force on either side can be completely different, things that can get you in a lot of trouble like gun laws can be different on either side, prices and taxes can be very different. The biggest thing that changes is the school district. City schools tend to be worse than suburban counterparts, and that completely drives a cities ability to retain young families, thus altering the demographic makeup and tax base of the city.
- amha 8y agoIt depends on the state. At least here in New York (the state, not the city), school district boundaries have nothing to do with municipal boundaries (which, yeah, adds another layer of confusion!)
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThe larger cities and suburbs of New York definitely do have distinct district boundaries that follow the municipal boundary. It's only the smaller communities that expand their draw to township boundaries.
- cjf4 8y agoFor the major NY urban districts, the municipal and school district boundaries are essentially the same.
- prostoalex 8y agoThat's a contributing factor, but unlikely the decisive one. Some city schools are excellent, and business case for a private or a charter school is stronger in a city. There's also wider availability of various after-school programs. There's the space concern for those who wouldn't mind a backyard and a pet or two, safety concern associated with letting the kids just play outside, transportation concern as far as effort required to drive them to school and various after-school programs.
- bobthepanda 8y ago
- mikestew 8y agoMy understanding is that a city boundary in the US is a big deal. I’d be hard-pressed to think of a time it made a lick of difference to me, having lived in the U. S. my entire life. “Don’t carry a handgun to Chicago”, okay, file that one away. “If you’re black”, and I’m not, “don’t stop for gas in Martinsville, IN”. Though that one might not still be true, I’d still stay away from Elwood, my Afro-American friend. Other than that, with the caveat of being a white male, I can’t say I’ve ever had need to pay attention.
- chrisseaton 8y agoA good example is that the Las Vegas Strip is actually very carefully just outside Las Vegas, in order to avoid the control of the city. If you search you can easily find examples of people being arrested for doing something inside a city, which (presumably) have been legal if they'd done it just outside of the city. https://www.jcolaw.com/discharging-a-weapon-within-city-limits.html https://www.jcolaw.com/discharging-a-weapon-within-city-limi...
- mikestew 8y agoThat’s my point: why do I care where the strip is legally located? Casinos have reason to care, I don’t. And if you’re discharging a firearm, yeah, you better make for damned sure you’re allowed (what was my one example that wasn’t related to race?). Your linked example calls out towns I’ve lived near (lived in Gastonia), and the reason there’s a need for such lawyers is due to morons that think ownership of a firearm and a box of ammo is all they need to shoot in their suburban backyard. But that’s not city-specific, it’s a safe bet that if you’re within city limits anywhere in the U. S. you best assume discharging a firearm is illegal (it probably is) until proven otherwise.
- daveFNbuck 8y ago> it’s a safe bet that if you’re within city limits anywhere in the U. S. you best assume discharging a firearm is illegal (it probably is) until proven otherwise. That's an example of you having to care about which city you're in. You can't just rely on your knowledge of federal or state law there.
- bane 8y agoIt can depend on the particular U.S. State. It's sometimes useful for non-Americans to think of the U.S. like a federation of weak semi-autonomous countries. Each state more or less runs their own affairs unless there's some federal interest in which case the national interest overrides the state one. What this means for this topic is that states organize their territories in sometimes different ways that can seem sometimes bizarre to outsiders. For example, Connecticut divides itself into eight large counties and those counties are further divided into towns. Thus the meaning of "town" in Connecticut means a geographic subdivision and may have nothing or little to do with there actually being a cluster of buildings or even any interesting population at all. In fact, in Connecticut, a city is located within a town and is subordinate to it! Towns may set their own general method of local governance but are subordinate to their counties and then to their state. Louisiana is divided into Parishes that mapped to the Catholic Parishes present in the 19th century instead of counties and are generally run by a governmental body called a Police-Jury which is a combined legislative/executive body with enormous local powers. Virginia is divided into counties, which may have towns and other kinds of human settlements. But cities are independent of their surrounding county and act at a parallel level to counties in terms of political power. The county seat where the county government resides may or may not be in a city, but if it is there will be a parallel and equally powerful city government in the same area. Cities in Virginia, as defined governmental territories have very controlled borders, but may have very small populations. But in other areas, the cities are so large they no longer exist within a county at all and the historic county no longer exists. This has impacts mostly for taxes, schooling and property. But practically the most you would notice is that you could eat at a restaurant on one side of a street and cross to the other to get some coffee and pay a different sales tax on either side. It goes on from there. From a practical standpoint, it almost entirely affects the locals and can be a deciding factor with where people choose to live. For outsiders, it doesn't matter much except that your sales tax might be highly variable as you transit through local governing zones.
- tboyd47 8y ago> It's sometimes useful for non-Americans to think of the U.S. like a federation of weak semi-autonomous countries. That may have been true in the 18th and 19th century, but since the early 1900s, I don't think it's accurate to say that anymore. Nearly every state power has been checked by the federal court system at some point during the 20th century [0]. I didn't know about the Police-Jury system, but it's surely the exception. Wouldn't you agree that state and local governments mostly act within the bounds defined by the federal government? [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_R...
- hbosch 8y agoRelated note: the latest season of the podcast Serial touches on a case where a kid was arrested and beaten over a joint. He thought he was in Cleveland, where you won’t be arrested for such a small amount of weed... but he was actually in a neighboring suburb called Euclid, and he wasn’t aware of the prosecutorial difference.
- DoubleCribble 8y agoYou're absolutely right. City police are often a completely different organization from the county sheriff's office which is undoubtedly different from the state police. Serial predators like the Golden State Killer[0] have leveraged this to their advantage and avoided capture for decades using this ONE CRAZY HACK. (exploit the jurisdictional morass by just moving around a bit) [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_State_Killer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_State_Killer
- Symbiote 8y agoThe UK has some unitary authorities which are cities, like the City of Leicester, which is administered separately from Leicestershire. As you said though, it makes close to no difference. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitary_authorities_of_England https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitary_authorities_of_England