5 ms·
The Juul Fad Is Bigger I Would Have Guessed
- exabrial 8y agoAnd juul is safer than inhaling the combustion products of smoke, correct?
- glibgil 8y agoYes
- untog 8y agoBut more dangerous than not inhaling anything. If people were swapping cigarettes for Juul I'd see your point, but as the article states, they is not.
- exabrial 8y agoI guess I have a hard time buying that when the article admits to strong bias like the following: Vaping in general, and Juul in particular, have wiped out years of hard work to get teens off of cigarettes
- untog 8y agoHow is that bias? The data clearly backs up that teen rate of nicotine product use (for want of a better description) was on a dramatic decline until the advent of Juul.
- jeklj 8y agoBut is nicotine the reason cigarettes are so bad for human health?
- hannasanarion 8y agoWhere is the bias? That's just stating the facts .
- exabrial 8y agoThe data shows teens are using Juuls, which are scientifially mostly harmless. The data does not show increased cigarette usage.
- hannasanarion 8y agoAll juuls have nicotine, which is decidedly NOT harmless. The best you can claim is that it is less harmful than cigarettes, which is a very very low bar.
- exabrial 8y ago"Nicotine, a substance frequently implicated in tobacco addiction, has been shown to have "relatively weak" addictive properties when administered alone. The addictive potential increases dramatically after co-administration of an MAOI, which specifically causes sensitization of the locomotor response in rats, a measure of addictive potential. This may be reflected in the difficulty of smoking cessation, as tobacco contains naturally-occurring MAOI compounds in addition to the nicotine." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monoamine_oxidase_inhibitor#cite_note-pmid16177026-31 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monoamine_oxidase_inhibitor#cit...
- chii 8y ago> But more dangerous than not inhaling anything. but if you're going to inhale anything, is it better that it is juul rather than tobacco?
- untog 8y agoSure. Equally, if you're going to punch yourself in the face, better to do it once than to do it ten times.
- ekianjo 8y agoPunching yourself is harmful. How much evidence regarding the harm of vaping do we have presently?
- untog 8y agoIt contains nicotine, and nicotine is addictive. So health risks aside (not to say there aren't any, I guess we'll find out) you are being exposed to a product that will make you physically dependent on buying it again and again. That's not a good thing for anyone except the owner of the company selling it to you.
- ekianjo 8y agoMost things humans like to do are addictive. Games are addictive. Gambling is addictive. Alcohol is addictive. Reading is addictive. Drinking coffee is addictive. Of course they all carry different kinds of risks but trying to make the point that every addiction is a problem to solve is a never ending issue. Humans love addictions and this is how we operate. there are just socially acceptable addictions and the rest.
- exabrial 8y agoActually, it turns oout the MAOIs are the addictive part
- rjplatte 8y agoCorrect. Literally thousands of times less deadly.
- theptip 8y agoCitation? I'm not aware of any research quantifying that in the medium-to-long term.
- jeffbax 8y agoMostly true, but there's definitely vapes that contain the popcorn lung chemicals as well as who knows what yet. It's new, heated chemicals going into lungs. I imagine the jury is still out disregarding the combustion part
- jeklj 8y agoI mean, that must have to be the case, right? And yet this article says more than once that vaping has “wiped out” progress of getting teens to stop smoking. It only makes sense to say this if you think the two are basically the same from a public health standpoint. And I just don’t see how that could be true. The panic over vaping strikes me as rather puritanical. Smoking is obviously terrible for one’s health, but decades of anti-smoking messaging seems to have warped people into thinking that anything even resembling it must be a personal moral failing.
- anigbrowl 8y agoThis would be great...if all Juul users wee former smokers. I am sure that you are a smart person who knows otherwise, so why lead the discussion in an erroneous direction like that, buddy?
- navjack27 8y agoI hate juul. I support traditional vape. Juul just seems like a horrible company with horrible intentions.
- manfredo 8y agoI'm not familiar with nicotine vaping. How is juul different from "traditional vape"? Not trying to degrade your post by use of quote marks, I'm just not sure what is meant by that term. Did people use to vape tobacco by by grinding leaves and using an oven vape - like vaping cannabis in, e.g. a PAX 3?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoAs far as I can tell they have 10x or 20x the nicotine strength of normal vapes, and a much harder hit. Juul seem to be 59mg/ml, most regular juice I've come across has been 12, 6 or 3. Highest I ever saw, online, was 18. Highest I ever tried was 12, which was recommended to start when I switched from a 20 a day cigarette habit, in a simple pen vape. I couldn't tolerate it for longer than about a week before dropping down to the next juice down. Traditional vapes break into 2 types. Pen vapes don't produce much heat so liquids tend to be a bit stronger. They'd use mostly 6, 12 or 18 strength liquids. Vape mods (silly name as they're not modified, so I don't know what the mod is meant to mean) have a larger battery pack with separate tank and lower resistance coil. They're usually a fair bit larger than any pen or cigarette. These produce much more vapour so usual strengths are 3 and 6. I would expect Juul to be at the lower end of vapour amount as the cartridges are so tiny. I can't imagine the hit from Juul, and can't imagine ever trying one. It'd be like chain smoking 4 cigs. I quit vaping totally already anyway. :) They haven't yet launched in the UK, but I'm doubtful they'd be allowed at that strength. (Israel banned them, having set max strength at 20mg/ml). Juul seem around 10x the price too. I used to pay £1 - £2 for 10ml of juice that would last well over a week, often 2. Juul cartridges are tiny, $4 each but supposedly last about a day or two. Last, but not least, they're 40% owned by Philip Morris (Marlboro).
- pandaman 8y agoJuul seems to have much smaller battery than vape "pens". It also does not produce nearly as much vapor. Their whole innovation is formaliting high concentration juice which would not make you barf (using a different nicotine-derived compound than the pure nicotine in the original e-juice) so it could be used in a low power device.
- rjplatte 8y agoWow. I had no idea that a single company had such an effect. I'll stick to my occasional pipe loaded with organic tobacco, and enjoy my continued lung health and lack of nicotine addiction. EDIT: Yes, I know about mouth cancer risks, and I also know that occasional pipe smoking puts one at approximately the same risk for various cancers as drinking hard liquor does. If you don't mix the two activities, you aren't raising your risk of anything, and you are lowering your blood pressure and stress levels, so much so that pipe smokers are estimated to live about 3.8 years longer, on average.
- EpicEng 8y agoRight, because tobacco never hurt anyone. On top of that, it's organic! Probably good for you really.
- rjplatte 8y agoRead my edit. I took up the habit to manage stress, and my blood pressure has come down to a healthy 115/70 from 140/100.
- dang 8y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- EpicEng 8y ago>Wow. I had no idea that a single company had such an effect. I'll stick to my occasional pipe loaded with organic tobacco, and enjoy my continued lung health and lack of nicotine addiction. I understand that, but what is the "strongest plausible interpretation" of this exactly? In what way is occasional pipe smoking a replacement for vaping? In what way does smoking a pipe ensure "continued lung health"? Is there no nicotine in organic tobacco? What is the intent of the comment to begin with? All I see is an ignorant endorsement of tobacco smoking over vaping. What am I missing?
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoOn the article’s comments, some people discuss whether vaping is as unhealthy as normal cigarettes. Curious to hear an opinion if any expert is reading this.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- whoisjuan 8y agoNot an expert, but there's plenty of research that shows that vaping is indeed less harmful than traditional smoking. E-cigarettes and vaping are endorsed and used as part of smoking cessation therapies. However, regarding vaping itself, is still too early to tell if it is safe. Safer than cigarettes? Yes. Chemical and toxicological studies show that vaping/e-cigs are far less harmful than traditional tobacco. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4110871/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4110871/ Not harmful at all? Unlikely. It's hard to determine at this point the level of harm, but it's fair to say that any form of chemical inhalation is bad for you (including the simple act of breathing in a city or area with high air pollution).
- theptip 8y agoThat's a good overview of papers in favour of vaping -- but note there's some conflict of interest concerns: > Conflict of interest statement: Riccardo Polosa... has served as a consultant for Pfizer and Arbi Group Srl (Milano, Italy), the distributor of Categoria™ e-Cigarettes. > Konstantinos Farsalinos ... has received financial compensation from electronic cigarette companies for the studies’ cost. And some bold statements like this point that seems to be strongly contradicted by the chart at the top of the OP: > Regulatory authorities have expressed concern about EC use by youngsters or by never-smokers, with ECs becoming a gateway to smoking or becoming a new form of addiction. However, such concerns are unsubstantiated; research has shown that EC use by youngsters is virtually nonexistent unless they are smokers. All that said, this review does provide some evidence that vaping is less harmful -- however I'd take it with a pinch of salt. For example, these two papers on negative effects of vaping on gene expression in the immune system have since been published: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4819171/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4819171/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5436899/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5436899/ (Reported in the popular science press e.g. here: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/06/160620141317.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/06/160620141317.h...)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fspeech 8y agoMy younger son (high school freshman) would agree. He informed me that it is very addictive. Some kids try it out of curiosity and then become very addicted. It is easy to hide at school. He calls their bathroom the vape lounge. Kids can vape at home without their parents becoming aware if they have enough spending allowance. I thought E-cig was going to help people addicted to cigarettes quit smoking. I didn't imagine it may become a new plague itself.
- fromthestart 8y agoI don't understand why people are anywhere near as worried about vaping as they are about cigarettes. Yeah, it's addictive because of nicotine. But there's no evidence that nicotine is harmful, in fact it may be neuroprotective, and vaping simply does not produce the type and quantity of carcinogens that cigarette smoking does. I think this amounts to hysteria because people associate nicotine with cancer. Not sure why the addiction is such a big deal.
- carbocation 8y agoDoes the best available evidence support your claim? I believe that vaping is likely to be healthier than smoking. I would need to see high quality evidence to believe that it’s harmless. If you can provide it in the form of published articles, I will read it and offer commentary. Nicotine products have killed millions of people prematurely. These companies have stoked a resurgence in nicotine use among young people. This is concerning.
- thatswrong0 8y agoWhat nicotine products besides tobacco kill people? Patches? Gum? Sure the level of use is a bit concerning, but I don’t think it’s going to be the health epidemic that the media is making it out to be.
- carbocation 8y agoDoes your argument hinge upon an absence of evidence, or do you have evidence to support your position?
- thatswrong0 8y agoDo you always demand that every person who comments on a subject compile a meta-study for your perusal? From what I’ve read, most of the damage from cigarettes comes not from nicotine but other carcinogens present along with the combustion. Of course more research needs to be done on nicotine itself as well as the other compounds present in vaping liquids.. but nothing I’ve read has indicated that nicotine is even close to being as dangerous on its own. It’s probably not harmless, but then again, many things people consume on a daily basis, like coffee, probably aren’t either.
- jostmey 8y agoQuote "I knew that the Juul fad had practically taken over American high schools recently...". After looking at pictures of their products I think I understand why [1]. I have the impression that some of these products are tailored to sell to teenagers. Last time I meet my younger brother, he couldn't go for more than a few hours without becoming agitated or vaping. Way to go and make that money 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JUUL#/media/File:Juul_with_pods_(29395579877).jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JUUL#/media/File:Juul_with_pod...
- str33t_punk 8y agoI was a nic addict for several years. Most of the time it was spliffs (weed mixed with nicotine) but my consumption rate was probably the equivalent of 4-5 cigs a day (8 king size spliffs per day). I also smoked here and there but I didn’t like the taste or throat hit as much. After having a prolonged cough, I switched to juuling. I loved it - tasted great, nice buzz, amazing (AMAZING) throat hit. I stopped smoking spliffs (positive was I was no longer high 24-7), my lungs felt better, I overall felt better. However, the issue with these things is it is so available. You can take tiny rips anywhere. And there is no quantized amount. You just take a few puffs but you have no idea how much that is, unlike a discrete cig. So my 4-5 cig a day habit turned into the equivalent of a pack a day habit. I found myself ‘going to the bathroom’ all the time at work to sneak a quick hit. I think my base level anxiety went up. So I quit the juul (quitting wasn’t as hard as I thought despite using a pod a day for 6 months, the anxiety of what would happen when I quit was really the big thing. In terms of withdrawals all I had was a desire to consume nic on my mind all the time for a few days). Really what I want to say is that the juul is a better cig. You can use it anywhere. You feel much less terrible and sickly (when your smoking you couch all the time). It tastes much better. However all of this makes it much more addicting than the traditional cigarette The science is out on how bad for you vaping is. Many point to the fact that nicotine by itself is really only bad for your heart - the extra stuff is more from smoke / chemicals in cigarettes. However nicotine addiction kinda sucks
- tantalor 8y ago> nicotine addiction kinda sucks Sucks more than caffeine addiction?
- tfehring 8y agoQuitting caffeine cold-turkey is worse than quitting cigarettes cold turkey IMO - the headaches are awful. But aside from that, nicotine addiction is way worse. Even when I drank ~20 "cups" of coffee a day, I didn't have cravings or headaches unless I somehow managed to go several hours after waking up without having any at all. Nicotine cravings are frequent and sporadic and prevent you from focusing on anything else for more than a few seconds at a time. With cigarettes, there's also the fact that you actually have to, well, smoke cigarettes. Sometimes that's great (if you're used to it), but when you have a sore throat, forcing yourself to smoke a cigarette one painful drag at a time is a horrible experience. Juul is a huge step up this way, though it comes with other issues.
- sayno3 8y agoThe litter is arguably worse. Instead of biodegradable cotton, these plastic things are all over the place. It took me about a year before I even realized what they were. Plus, now these damn, dirty apes will live longer and therefore litter even more!
- malshe 8y agoI don't know at this point we can call it a fad. Fad is usually by definition short-lived. It looks like this is gonna stay. https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/fad https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/fad
- AnonymousRider 8y agoMy grandmother had nine sisters. All nine of them died in their 60’s from emphysema and lung cancer. All told fifteen people in my family died from smoking related illness. These early deaths were absolutely devastating to us kids as they happened in rapid succession. Vaping saves lives. Vaping saves lungs. Let’s just continue to get people off of burning cigarettes and we can tackle nicotine addiction once cigarettes are a bad memory.
- carbocation 8y agoYou might be right for smokers who transition to vaping. I would bet money that you are right. When my patients ask me, I tell them my guess, and I am emphatic that it is a guess. We will know the right answer at some point. However, the concern is that nicotine use is on the upswing among young people (edit: previous nonsmokers) for the first time in many years. If vaping is anything short of harmless, which I think we must presume it is, then this is a brewing problem.
- code_duck 8y agoOne thing that’s overlooked is that half of smokers die from heart disease, not lung disease. It also causes strokes. Nicotine is terrible for your heart and vaping is as bad or possibly even worse in that respect.
- dehrmann 8y agoIgnoring the fact the the science is still out on vaping (though I agree that it's likely safer), if you look the graph in the article, vaping doesn't seem to be a substitute for cigarettes among 12th graders. The decline in smoking is unaffected. To say "vaping saves lives" isn't backed up by the data for 12th graders.
- verroq 8y agoVox did a video[0] on Juul’s marketing. Moral issues aside I thought the whole idea was genius. Not surprised they are printing money. [0]. https://youtube.com/watch?v=AFOpoKBUyok https://youtube.com/watch?v=AFOpoKBUyok
- dehrmann 8y agoA coworker recently left for Juul. It was an inside joke, of sorts, that a lot of their growth is driven by minors.