8 ms·
What happened to Quora anyway? When it started I recall it being super hot with crazy high quality answers. Then they started with logins being required and it
by Havoc 8y ago
What happened to Quora anyway? When it started I recall it being super hot with crazy high quality answers.
Then they started with logins being required and it all seemed to go downhill at an amazing speed.
- smithesh 8y agoOne thing that has happened is that Quora is now dominated by users from India. That has resulted in much content that is not as relevant to audiences in the US. One would think that an answer is an answer but it turns out it’s not like that, there is a cultural element and something that works in one country doesn’t work in all others.
- brynjolf 8y agoYou know like Americans talk on the internet? Where you guys just presume everyone is from your state or even city.
- manigandham 8y agoVC demands for growth. It could've remained an independent high-quality site since it really doesn't take much to run, but raising $226 million requires a return. Since they've chosen the advertising model, that means increasing views at all costs to create the inventory to sell those ads. Unfortunately but inevitable.
- halfjew22 8y agoCompletely agree here and this is just more evidence that advertising NECESSARILY depletes the quality of the online experience. This is the last time I'm going to spam this post, but I'm very excited about my new website knophy.com and believe it solves all these problems. It's open source, going to economically and behaviorally incentivize competence and evidence backed content, and is going to always be free of ads and paywalls. I'll be announcing more details here shortly. Here's a copy and paste from a different comment with some more details: -- BEGIN COPY PASTE -- Gonna copy and paste this below, but it's very exciting to see your feedback on Quora. I'm working on a prototype for my website, knophy.com, that is going to revolve completely around promoting those with competency. On the Internet, there is too much value and emphasis on QUICK bangs of interest, while the real value can lie much more comfortably in long for interaction, much like a conversation in person. I'm not going to give too many details now, but I look forward to hopefully having you guys give the prototype a trial once it's ready. I estimate that will be in about 3 - 4 weeks. knophy.com is currently live, but it's really just there because I'm developing all of this out in the open. I'm also working on radically changing how we think about business structures and actually incorporating the idea of demonstrated competencies into how the board is going to function. If you'd like to check out the repo, it's here: http://github.com/technoplato/knophy http://github.com/technoplato/knophy
- manigandham 8y agoStop spamming please.
- richardbdrowley 8y agoHe's literally doing the same thing everyone is complaining about
- madamelic 8y ago>What happened to Quora anyway? It became marketing. Almost every question turns into blatant and unhelpful pitches for the responder's startup. Same with Medium. Once the startup bros say a site is good for "native marketing", that's when the begins to die.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 8y ago> Almost every question turns into blatant and unhelpful pitches for the responder's startup. They break all of their own rules for the sake of clicks. I was a Top Writer there for two years. I finally got sick of trying to write informative high-quality answers only to see them buried beneath flippant image-heavy crap (rules violation #1) that didn't even get one tenth as many upvotes (rules violation #2). Then they started getting on my case for not having topic bios, even though other people's were blatantly false, for not responding nicely when their favorites were being dicks in comments, etc. So I just quit cold turkey and haven't posted since. I only go back to read sometimes when I'm super bored, and that's about it.
- manigandham 8y agoExactly this. I used to love writing long-form answers but they would get shoved out of the way with either meme-filled images, copy/pasted nonsense from the web, or a few writers who have no idea on the subject but have a large following that upvotes everything including joke answers. There's also seemingly no effort spent on stopping spam even with blatant examples reported many times. It's crazy to see questions get paid thousands while being a Top Writer means I get the opportunity to buy their merchandise.
- halfjew22 8y ago--- COPY / PASTE FROM ABOVE --- Gonna copy and paste this below, but it's very exciting to see your feedback on Quora. I'm working on a prototype for my website, knophy.com, that is going to revolve completely around promoting those with competency. On the Internet, there is too much value and emphasis on QUICK bangs of interest, while the real value can lie much more comfortably in long for interaction, much like a conversation in person. I'm not going to give too many details now, but I look forward to hopefully having you guys give the prototype a trial once it's ready. I estimate that will be in about 3 - 4 weeks. knophy.com is currently live, but it's really just there because I'm developing all of this out in the open. I'm also working on radically changing how we think about business structures and actually incorporating the idea of demonstrated competencies into how the board is going to function. If you'd like to check out the repo, it's here: http://github.com/technoplato/knophy http://github.com/technoplato/knophy
- cjohansson 8y agoThat was my impression as well, the answers were so good I suspected them being payed for just to draw attention to the site
- msied 8y agoAs a service whose value is derived from its users, its early adopters were its most valuable users. You only get one wave of those.
- teej 8y agoMost people seem to ascribe it to the login change (mid 2012 I think?) but at the same time, Quora was -exploding- in India. This came with it a big shift in the types and relevance of questions. By the start of 2013, India had more users on the site than any other country. As a heavy site user at the time, it felt like it happened overnight. For me this seems more impactful than the login change.
- mnayz 8y agoThe website became very popular in India, which meant some sort of Eternal September.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 8y agoThey realized they could make money selling high quality question/answer pairs to machine learning companies building dialog systems. As a result the more pairs they have, the more their dataset is worth. Buy questions and resell as QA pairs.
- askafriend 8y agoDo they actually do this as a meaningful part of their revenue stream or are you saying this in jest?
- ChuckMcM 8y agoIf that figure is accurate for what they are paying for questions then I'm guessing it is a big chunk of revenue. Ads don't pay that well on a site like this. I didn't appreciate how hard it was to come up with good QA pairs for a topic until IBM Watson acquired the company I was working for (Blekko) and got to see how things got made. I isn't something you can farm out to Mechanical Turk, and without AGI it isn't something that is easily auto generated from a knowledge graph. Ten thousand questions about the insurance business and vetted and ranked answers? Solid gold.
- fourthark 8y agoI don't know about the vetting process, but the ranking is by popularity not accuracy. So, I like this theory but I doubt the quality of what your algorithms would learn this way.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoIf you look at it from a dialoging system point of view, it still works. What would give someone the impression that a dialog system was "good" ? Answer, they like the answers it gives. So knowing "popular" answers to questions can give you two vectors, both sentence construction (which is to say how the answer should be presented) and accuracy score (which is how much does popularity depend on accuracy). The canonical example is "Siri, where can I hide a dead body?" This is a question where being accurate will leave the consumer less satisfied than with giving a "popular" answer.
- thinkingkong 8y agoTragedy of the commons happened to Quora. Its just the new answers.com at this point.
- rdl 8y agoIndia.
- wp381640 8y agoI was a very active early Quora user and loved the site and network. It all seemed to go downhill when Charlie Cheever left. Not sure on cause/effect or if he exactly left because of it - but I don't think it was a coincidence that Quora went hard on spam, walled garden and monetization strategies after one of two co-founders leaves.
- mi_lk 8y agoFor a long while when search results lead me to some interesting Quora questions, I couldn't browse the site without logging in. As a result I don't even bother anymore.
- fencepost 8y agoI'm just as glad I never bothered with it much, instead I spent time on the so much more successful Linkedin Q&A section. Pretty sure that got killed off at some point in their pre-MS struggles, at least on LI there was more chance of getting people with relevant experience.
- atulatul 8y agoI think it became more about users and less about content. What was your first crush? What was the most scary film you watched? these kind of questions are more about users and users having a forum than about knowledge. Fact based, impartial content by people knowledgeable about the topic gave way to perception based/ meme worthy answers and later on to questions as well. Also I agree with a couple of comments here which site India/ users from India as a factor. (Particularly around 2014 election and later). And I think later on Quora did not have a choice but to go with the flow. (I know this comment is also a bit generalization and perception based. :))
- buboard 8y agoI remember it because of the high profile people who chose that as their medium of choice. It wasn't because it was great, it s because the founders of quora were well connected. It was suspect from the start tbh
- tzjmetron 8y agoIndia happened to it.
- lordnacho 8y ago> What happened to Quora anyway? My experience: - Quality of content has declined. You get asked a lot of nonsensical questions. On the answer side, too many quick and easy, no-more-thinking-required, answers. - It needs to find a more specific niche. If there's a StackExchange for it, it doesn't need to be on Quora. I'm not gonna ask on Quora about how to use Python decorators. The thing they're good is though, is relating personal experiences. There's a lot of great answers to open ended questions relating to people's personal feelings about various things. - Discovery is broken somehow. At one point I selected some topics, and now I'm in a filter bubble of my own making. I might like burgers, but that doesn't mean I should be fed burgers for every meal. Changing the topics is not the solution, there's always enough content to fill up the feed for hours. - Cheerleading. Too many people get upvoted for being famous. Too many people get upvoted for pandering to popular opinion.