3 ms·
I don’t buy the thermodynamic argument. Here’s a version I would believe: if you have a gadget that, exposed only to the sun and to empty space, heats some tar
by amluto 8y ago
I don’t buy the thermodynamic argument. Here’s a version I would believe: if you have a gadget that, exposed only to the sun and to empty space, heats some target hotter than the sun, then that gadget must not work if you take away the empty space part. This is because your gadget could be used to drive a heat engine, which is impossible without a temperature difference, and the sun is more or less a blackbody emitter. Lenses and mirrors aren’t magically taking advantage of the cold parts of the sky, so there you go.
But the moon is not blackbody, and I think the whole argument falls apart. Here’s a thought experiment: go stand on the moon, and assume the moon is made of rock that diffusely reflects, say, half of the indicent 500nm light. Stand somewhere that’s in shadow, so you can’t see the sun. Wrap a piece of paper and some air in perfectly insulating, perfectly reflecting material, except that the material lets 100% of 499-501nm light through, but only on the moon side. The target will be in a bath of 499-501nm light at 1/2 the intensity (energy density per unit volume) of the sun, which is far more than half the temperature of the sun. It’ll catch fire after a while.
Now do the same experiment on the Earth, at night, with lenses to bathe it in moonlight from all sides. Fire! So I claim that lenses+mirrors+filters can start a fire with moonlight.
Another interesting question: can you use a luminescent solar concentrator or other fluorescent material to pull this off without taking such egregious advantage of the spectrum of moonlight? These types of materials can violate conservation of étendue.
- Dylan16807 8y ago> The target will be in a bath of 499-501nm light at 1/2 the intensity (energy density per unit volume) of the sun, which is far more than half the temperature of the sun. It’ll catch fire after a while. Unconcentrated sunlight is slightly under 1400 watts per square meter. It's equivalent to a temperature of 122C. You can concentrate sunlight coming from the sun, because the sun only fills five millionths of the sky. With a simple lens you can focus hundreds of megawatts per square meter onto a surface. But once you bounce that light off a diffuse surface, whatever concentration you had becomes the new maximum. In your experiment, bathing something in moonlight would max out at 700 watts per square meter. 700 watts per square meter doesn't set things on fire. It can only heat a blackbody to 60 degrees C. Even the full brunt of unaltered sunlight can only bring a blackbody up to 122C. - Treating the moon as a blackbody or not doesn't actually change the equations. The important property is that it diffuses light. It resets your maximum concentration of light, because light that comes evenly from every direction can't be concentrated. (I'm ignoring the part about wavelength filtering because it's confusing and would only make your piece of paper heat up less.)
- amluto 8y ago> 700 watts per square meter doesn't set things on fire. It can only heat a blackbody to 60 degrees C. > (I'm ignoring the part about wavelength filtering because it's confusing and would only make your piece of paper heat up less.) I’m afraid you’re ignoring the interesting bit. You say that 700 W/m^2 doesn’t set things on fire. This is not true. Sure, 700 W/m^2 applied to some target that is allowed to radiate its own blackbody light out to the sky won’t get it very hot, but that’s not what I’m suggesting. I’m suggesting that you insulate the target very well so that its blackbody emissions don’t escape, but you let in the short-wavelength moonlight. Thermodynamics requires that you also let out the short wavelength blackbody emissions, but those are negligible until the target gets very, very hot. This effect isn’t science fiction — it’s just the greenhouse effect, amplified. Greenhouses (the glass ones and the atmospheric ones) exploit the fact that sunlight doesn’t match the Earth’s blackbody spectrum, so a filter (glass or gaseous) can allow incoming radiation in but trap most outgoing radiation. In effect, I’m suggesting that a very good greenhouse plus some lenses could get hot enough to start a fire.
- Dylan16807 8y agoI see. I couldn't quite follow which parts you were saying to insulate, and your mention of "half the temperature of the sun" lead me to misinterpret. That's fine then, I think. Not an expert on wavelength filters.