3 ms·
Recommendations + Discovery = Filter Bubble. These mis-features are exactly what we should be moving away from!
by ryandrake 8y ago
Recommendations + Discovery = Filter Bubble. These mis-features are exactly what we should be moving away from!
- ip26 8y agoNo discovery = isolation bubble
- Kye 8y agoI found this out when I switched from Pocket to Instapaper. Instapaper has a curated list of articles updated about once a month, and I don't read half of them. Pocket recommends articles based on what you read, and it's not just more of the same. I'm probably going to switch back.
- wasdfff 8y agoYou can follow hn and other aggregators like reddit via rss. I have it set up for hn where I only get posts that have hit 100 points, otherwise it’s a firehose.
- marcosdumay 8y ago> Recommendations + Discovery = Filter Bubble. Yep. When it decentralized you can control how strong are the bubble walls and can try different bubbles from time to time.
- davidivadavid 8y agoI'll take good recommendations, thank you. I'm surprised so few people here have picked up on the fact that "filter bubble" is a rhetorical trick about as obvious as the "pro-life" and "pro-choice" dichotomy. People like getting good recommendations, and they'll always like them. "Filter bubbles" are here to stay.
- stcredzero 8y agoGood recommendations are like a convenient browser that comes with your OS. The problems come in when it's just one company that has the public locked in to their particular solution.
- davidivadavid 8y agoWhat problems?
- stcredzero 8y agoIE 6
- dasil003 8y agoSure, we all want good recommendations, but how do we define "good"? I see some obvious problems with the way tech recommendations are playing out that have nothing to do with the filter bubble issue. First, we are outsourcing recommendations to profit-driven corporations. At best, the recommendations I want to see will be mixed with the ones advertisers want me to see. Revenue expectations of social media companies currently ensure this is a non-trivial issue with no easy middle ground. Even assuming the recommendations are reasonably good, you still have the problem that these ML-type recommendations require massive datasets and therefore it naturally gravitates towards a winner-take-all situation. Having one giant borg of a recommendation engine is bad. We are replacing a rich tapestry of individual word-of-mouth and small-scale communication channels with a massive mono-culture. Scalability is worshipped in tech companies (it's great for getting rich!), but it's not a inherently a good thing. In nature we find diversity trumps scalability, and I feel the same way about culture.
- aldermeer 8y agoGoogle News claims to include other sources in a story's feed, to expose the readership to other points of view. That sounds like a great way to burst the "social media bubble".