3 ms·
I wonder if part of the reason we don't have any great open source Slack competitors (yes I know about Mattermost, Zulip, etc.) is that so many open source deve
by IshKebab 8y ago
I wonder if part of the reason we don't have any great open source Slack competitors (yes I know about Mattermost, Zulip, etc.) is that so many open source developers (or at least commenters here) seem to be under the illusion that IRC is a reasonable alternative to Slack.
- mgbmtl 8y agoWhat's wrong with Mattermost? We use it for our FOSS community (and I use another instance for our company), works well.
- simonsaidit 8y agoOur company still have a lot of guys on irc so a bridge was put in place to mattermost :)
- clarry 8y agoJust terrible UX in general, and a very bloated & power hungry client. Search is borderline useless, and it's difficult for me to find anything that was talked about a couple weeks ago (meanwhile I can easily grep IRC logs for things that were said years ago). People at work turned off mobile notifications because they sometimes work, but usually not when you want them to work. I wish we'd just switch to IRC.
- SamWhited 8y agoWhat protocol does Mattermost use? I was under the impression that it was XMPP, but I can't find anything that says that now that I'm glancing at it. Did they invent their own as well?
- SamWhited 8y agoIRC isn't an alternative to Slack at all, which is why this argument is frustrating. IRC is a protocol, not a service. Slack could have been entirely based on IRC but they are greedy assholes who want to lock you into their clients. It could also have been entirely based on XMPP and federate with the broader ecosystem. Or based entirely on Matrix or whatever other protocols are out there. Unfortunately we as a community tend to mischaracterize things and position the public Jabber network or "IRC" as a competitor even though it's not even the same sort of thing. Another way of phrasing it is that we don't need to encourage people to use the Jabber network necessarily, we need to encourage companies like Slack to adopt the protocol and interop with the network. Then people can choose whatever they want.