3 ms·
There's a big unanswered question about whether "debate" is quite so useful at improving accuracy of answers when it consists of an audience with strong priors
by notahacker 8y ago
There's a big unanswered question about whether "debate" is quite so useful at improving accuracy of answers when it consists of an audience with strong priors listening to motivated reasoning rather than people deferring to the people who are most confident they have a decent grasp of the subject of a neutral trivia question. I think it's conceivable the opposite effect might occur if the experiment were be to repeated using polarising political issues, even if the questions themselves were fact-based (economic growth rates, crime rates, immigration figures, global temperature changes etc).
- wisty 8y agoThe backfire effect seems to be heavily exaggerated - https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2819073 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2819073 And just think about how the research is done. "Hello conservative test subject. Here's a 1 page article explaining why Climate Change is a real problem". What impact do you think it will have? How about this. Dear liberal, belief in a just world is psychologically healthy, and belief in an unjust world is linked to mental health issues, where's a wikipedia link - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis#Current_research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis#Current_... It seems likely to me that a couple of pithy arguments are unlikely to change a core belief, but is very likely to create some short-term pushback. If they do change a core belief then I think it will have stronger and longer-lasting impacts than the push-back. I also suspect there's a delay - arguments might take a while to sink in.
- patcon 8y agoIn the same experiment (but still unpublished) they actually find evidence that a similar CONSENSUS effect is observed in polarized issues with no clear "best" choice. https://www.ted.com/talks/mariano_sigman_and_dan_ariely_how_can_groups_make_good_decisions/transcript?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/mariano_sigman_and_dan_ariely_how_... The most interesting bit to me is the fact that a rare middle position stakeholder, a "high confident gray", allows groups to reach consensus more often. This potentially has huge applications in system design of the processes of democracy imho