5 ms·
> established ICE car companies are going to find that their electric cars are facing a headwind because it is not in their dealers' interests to sell car that
by clouddrover 8y ago
> established ICE car companies are going to find that their electric cars are facing a headwind because it is not in their dealers' interests to sell car that require less maintenance.
I'm not convinced by this. Nissan's been selling the Leaf for 8 years now. All manufacturers are moving to non-ICE cars because they have to. Customers want them and legislation has been introduced in various countries and cities which will ban ICE cars in future. Aston Martin, for example, has an electric conversion program so you can keep driving your vintage car after the bans are introduced:
https://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/classic-cars/a25414229/aston-martin-heritage-ev/ https://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/classic-cars/a25414...
Dealerships are going to have to sell electric cars or stop being in the car dealership business.
What probably will happen though is that the auto mechanic industry as a whole will contract as electric vehicles become more common.
- grecy 8y ago> Dealerships are going to have to sell electric cars or stop being in the car dealership business Interesting you should say that. Virtually all dealerships actually run at a loss "selling cars" (front of house), and turn a profit from "fixing cars" (back of house). Going back to your quote, there is no such thing as a profitable "Dealership business". There is only a profitable "fixing" business. I believe your prediction is correct, they will stop being in business.
- jjeaff 8y agoThey definitely won't go out of business. They have a legal monopoly on selling cars. They will have to increase their front of house margins though. And since all dealerships will be in the same boat, they will all have to increase their markup so it won't be a problem for them. Either that or they will find new ways to hide the true costs of the vehicles. You'll probably see a lot more leases. Complicated leases are a great way to squeeze extra money out of people.
- btilly 8y agoThe legal monopoly is weaker than it used to be. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_US_dealership_disputes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_US_dealership_disputes for some information about the battled that Tesla already fought on this issue. That said, it is a lot easier for Tesla to sell direct than an established manufacturer with a network of dealerships to placate.
- clouddrover 8y agoHyundai is (or will be soon, depending on where you live) selling the Hyundai Kona Electric and the Kia Niro EV. Both have the same powertrain, have good range, and are price competitive with other electric cars ($36,450 USD before incentives for the Kona): https://www.hyundaiusa.com/kona-electric/index.aspx https://www.hyundaiusa.com/kona-electric/index.aspx https://www.kia.com/us/en/content/vehicles/upcoming-vehicles/2019-niro-ev https://www.kia.com/us/en/content/vehicles/upcoming-vehicles... How can Hyundai do that if the dealerships are a problem?
- btilly 8y agoHyundai can ship all the cars that it wants to the dealerships. But the sales people will steer people towards the cars that they want to sell. And can choose how hard to negotiate if you insist on getting the electric car that you see.
- ams6110 8y agoSales people want sales, for the least investment of their time. If you come in wanting to buy an EV, that's what they are going to sell you. If you come in wanting "a car," sure they will try to steer you to whatever is currently the most profitable one for them. In my experience, the car they try to sell you is the one you are looking at.
- btilly 8y agoYour experience may be what it may be. But in my experience, they steer you towards the most profitable for them car that they think you'll buy. https://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/dealerships-dismiss-electric-vehicles/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/dealerships-dismiss-... provides evidence that I am right - and that in practice dealerships really do steer customers away from electric vehicles.
- fludlight 8y agoI have seen the financial statements of dozens of dealerships and they absolutely turn a tidy profit. What you call the "front office" only loses money during recessions and when WTI is above a hundred. The effect of the latter varies wildly based on product mix. Also, the service dept is not sufficient to save a struggling dealership during a bad economy. The main drivers of dealership economics are sales revenue relative to local and national peers and cost/availability of wholesale/retail financing. Not a top dealer for your market? You're screwed. Regional recession? Screwed. Lender pulled your flooring? Screwed. It's suddenly illegal to charge usurious interest rates (and fees!) for $4k used cars? Joe Schmo can't get cheap financing for a $40k brodozer? You get it.
- corey_moncure 8y agoI'll tell you my true experience with my LEAF. I bought my used 2013 leaf at a sticker price of around ~9,500 USD before taxes and fees. A few months in, I began to experience an issue with the braking system. After depressing the brake pedal and slowing to a stop, the pedal would sink slowly, and the car could creep forward again until I applied more pressure. After enough cycles of this I'd have pushed the pedal all the way down, and there would be no way to hold the stop. I immediately set up an appointment with the local licensed Nissan dealer for maintenance, and began putting the car in park at intersections. I noted that the brake fluid was very low, but not empty, when I brought the car in. I figured all it needed was to be refilled, but there were some other minor squawks I wanted to have them look at. After service, the rep sat me down and explained that the part that balances brake force between the regenerative and friction braking systems "had failed", and this part was going to cost nearly $2000 to replace. He clearly represented to me that the maintenance mechanics had uncovered a problem with this part, that it was failed, and absolutely necessary to replace. I paid for the appointment and said I'd have to think about the replacement part. I looked over the paperwork very carefully and there were no error codes in the testing results. I've been driving the car for over a year since with no issues. The problem with the brake pedal resulted from low brake fluid, which they topped off during the maintenance. I've resolved not to take the car to the dealer for any issue unless I absolutely can't handle it myself, which I'm guessing means "never". So I definitely give credence to the idea that the electric cars are a threat to maintenance revenue.
- taneq 8y agoI've only had a couple of experiences with dealer service centers but, like yours, they've been not good. I've come to the conclusion that dealer service standards are lower as they rely on a funnel of new car sales to provide customers. Our local independent service center is cheaper, more responsive and far more transparent about what needs doing to our cars.
- snowwindwaves 8y agoThe Brake fluid reservoir level becomes low when the fluid leaks out somewhere in the system. Brake fluid isn't something that is consumed in normal operation. When fluid can be pushed out as a leak that is lost force that is not applied to stopping. When fluid can get out air can get in and air is compressible so this makes the hydraulic braking system feel spongy. Adding more fluid and bleeding the air out of the system may temporarily make it seem like there is no problem but if you note the level dropping then you ought to find the leak or you risk losing control of your vehicle and run in to some thing or some one. I can't believe it got so bad you were putting it in park at intersections. That is really dangerous!!
- ardy42 8y ago> Aston Martin, for example, has an electric conversion program so you can keep driving your vintage car after the bans are introduced Are those bans really going to be that strict? I would hope that they'd exempt genuinely collectable cars. From a preservation/living history perspective, it seems wrong to force such drastic modifications.
- clouddrover 8y agoYes. I suppose they'll have some kind of ticketing to enforce it: http://fortune.com/2017/10/12/paris-combustion-engine-ban/ http://fortune.com/2017/10/12/paris-combustion-engine-ban/
- fossuser 8y agoThey may have to stop being in the car dealership business. I went to go look at a volt a few years ago when they were new because it was unclear from GM's (terrible) marketing of it whether it actually had limited range or whether it could run on gas alone. The ads kept advertising its range, which I found odd if you could just refuel, and it wasn't clear if it needed some battery for the generator to work or not. It was early on so search results were inconclusive. The dealer I went to didn't know anything about the car, if it could run on gas alone, how the generator worked, etc. Tesla's move was smart - the dealership model won't survive the transition to autonomous EVs and if they don't go gracefully they'll probably take the old car manufacturers down with them. Just look at GM - while they bought Cruise and have the long range (ugly) Bolt they've relegated the really great Cruise tech to only a few models with over complicated controls and they're not focused on the EVs. I'd guess somebody over there knows that this is an existential risk for them, but they need somebody at the top that understands it.
- Shivetya 8y agovery very few customer's want them. you would be surprised at how little most people care. Oh sure many will say they want an EV but that drops fast when costs go up and so on. I have a Tesla Model 3. I work at a company that is heavily car involved, and you would be surprised at how many people don't realize it is all electric. There are people who still don't associate Tesla with cars! Plus lets be honest, unless you own a Tesla your ability to take standard trips any petrol car can do is very limited and even with Tesla it gets limited in winter. I can see losses of twenty to thirty percent and I am just in the Southeast for temperature swings. Yes dealerships will need to sell them but before that a large number of people need to want them. We haven't reached that point for many reasons, some include 1) cost 2) education 3) range (numbers are mild weather only) 4) not all vehicle types are represented 5) not much selection 6) the tech is barely ready 7) the charging system is not settled nor widespread this list can go on and on and I am en EV owner/supporter. as for the article, another company which hasn't gotten really to step 1 making declarations about the wonders that await us is nothing new, actually doing it will be the issue. Seeing that Volvo has a lot of manufacturing in China it would be far easier to come in under a known nameplate but legacy brands have cost numbers well established and may be limited in how low they will aim
- woodandsteel 8y ago>Oh sure many will say they want an EV but that drops fast when costs go up and so on. EV prices are going down due to falling battery costs, increasing economies of scale of manufacture, and improved understanding of how to design them. The experts say around 2023-2025 they will become as cheap as ICE vehicles, and then they will take over the market. Oh, and Tesla's big problem is working through its huge backlog of orders, and that is even though just started selling in Europe. You know, you say you are an EV owner and supporter, but your comment is so negative I have doubts that is actually true.