5 ms·
The article is missing some critical details. What does the fund do? The article suggests they do arbitrage. Those opportunities actually tend to increase when
by lordnacho 8y ago
The article is missing some critical details.
What does the fund do? The article suggests they do arbitrage. Those opportunities actually tend to increase when things are volatile. Also while you can lose money doing it you wouldn't expect a precipitous collapse in NAV. If you discover you're slower than everyone else you can shut down.
Volumes aren't necessarily correlated to price either, so that isn't entirely convincing.
I've also heard that plenty of arb guys are doing fine.
If he's speculating and not just running arbs, what is he doing? If he's just punting the cryptos that would seem more in line with what's happened, but it's not clear what he's up to from this.
Also, with arbitrage it's limited how much capital you need. A lot of HFTs use very little. If you're getting money like a hedge fund you have to be sure it can be put to use.
Ex HFT and fund manager.
- GreaterFool 8y agoI also hear arb is doing fine. I wonder how it works though. Most exchange APIs are terrible and it is simply not technically feasible to do anything using those APIs. Also prices at too many exchanges move in absolute lockstep. Must be private, privileged access to better (internal) APIs, profit sharing, rip the face of "retail" investor kind of deals. After all the "exchanges" are not really exchanges as we know them in other markets. They're more like forex trading. I think the crypto market would benefit from a (semi-)regulated impartial exchange where other firms can become members and act as brokers to direct retail flow. But unless there's some sort of regulation about it it would just be a private business that could kick out any member for any reason. To much risk for the members.
- polkapolka 8y agoYou bypass the API completely and fill orders "manually".
- bhaak 8y agoWhat do you mean by "manually"? The general web page of an exchange is horrible slow compared to their APIs and often breaks during high volume periods.
- polkapolka 8y agoDid you run into latency problems doing arbitrage this way? Or do you rely on API's?
- bhaak 8y agoI didn't do arbitrage but running bots for statistical data via API. I think latency is not even the big problem, although of course you have to account for it when doing arbitrage. The latency can be quite high even during calm periods (also don't forget that exchanges can be on different sides of the globe, that already adds quite a bit of latency). During times of high volumes as in the period of the last rally, the websites of many crypto exchanges break easily and even the API are not that stable. You can also see that on reddit. Every time the price spiked, you got people complaining about exchanges breaking. There's still a long way to go for crypto exchanges.
- module0000 8y agoForget the 3rd party exchanges with their homegrown APIs. If you are dealing with size(1k+), you go straight to the CME and trade crypto futures contracts. Dealing with the CME also adds the regulation necessary(ie CFTC) for your investors.
- bhaak 8y agoThis interview[1] sounds like they called bottom at 6k and then the floor fell out: "We thought it was a bear market. I went into it thinking in the long run crypto is going to be a real structural shift in the world and I can just hedge my portfolio. And to be fair, we did a really great job not losing money the first 60 percent down. What you forget is that a market like Bitcoin that’s down 84 percent has dropped 60 percent—and then another 60 percent. That’s where the pain happens. You start buying Ether again, because it’s only $400 after being at $1,300. But then it drops to $100, and you’ve lost 75 percent of your money. We haven’t done horribly in that context, but we’re still down. [...] I did think Bitcoin was going to hold at $6,200. It stayed there for four months. It felt like the selling was finished." [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-11/mike-novogratz-explains-why-he-s-still-all-in-on-cryptocurrency https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-11/mike-novo...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 8y ago"Felt like". That's beautiful. The dude had a feel and lost the equivalent of 2300 years of labor (at the US median income). There's this bit in Taleb's first book, "Fooled by Randomness". This was before he made a shit-ton of money. He pointed out that a lot of the nominally successful traders he worked around would declare a strategy, make a few bets, make a lot of money, and then act like geniuses for thinking up the strategy. However, they'd never really examine the obvious alternate hypothesis: they got lucky. I used to work for a proprietary trading firm. We'd get new traders by taking very confident, driven people (e.g., former Olympic athletes), making them be clerks for a while, and then turning them loose in the pits. The CFO kept a very close eye on them early on because their natural confidence combined with early successes lead them to believe they were gods. It wasn't until they got really hammered by a bad bet or two that she'd begin to trust them. It reminds me of a favorite line: "Every corpse on Mount Everest was once a highly motivated person with a can do-attitude."
- _hardwaregeek 8y agoHonestly the schadenfreude is real. What part of the crypto graph made him believe he could make assumptions about, well, anything?
- startupdiscuss 8y agoYou need volume for liquidity which you need to execute the arb. So, for instance, cryptoA trades for $99 on exchange 1, but $101 on exchange 2. Quick, buy on exchange 1 and sell on exchange 2! Congrats you made $2 on each trade x 5 cryptos. That is hardly enough volume to make it happen. Now imagine that the volume is so thin that after you bought the first one on exchange 1, the price gap closed, and by the time you sold on exchange 2 it collapsed.
- koolba 8y agoDon't forget to throw in significant counter party risk in dealing with fly by night exchanges. There's a non-zero chance that your entire balance held at an exchange disappears overnight.
- lend000 8y agoAny arb strategy requires holding reserves, so while the amount of the asset you can afford may increase by 4% per month, it's not a great business to be in if you're measuring from the start of a bear market. Same goes for a lot of stat-arb funds in the space, which are currently measuring their performance against the market, but which are significantly down YTD.
- Animats 8y agoThe article suggests they do arbitrage. They blamed their failure on "increased competition for arbitrage opportunities." Properly, arbitrage is low risk exploitation of differences between two markets in the same thing. Cryptocurrencies used to look like they had arbitrage opportunities, with differing prices between exchanges. Mostly, that was because it was so hard to pry cash out of the underfinanced cryptocurrency exchanges. They always had some excuse for delaying paying out. Arbitrage requires the ability to move cash quickly from one exchange to another. As that situation improved, the spreads between exchanges narrowed. Opportunities for low-risk arbitrage disappeared. These traders reacted to this by going into higher-risk forms of trading. Which is about typical for traders. It didn't end well.
- revel 8y agoI think you're completely right that his fund isn't just performing straight up arb. In fact, I don't think it can generating most of its P&L from arb since (from what I remember at least), Galaxy Digital simply has too much capital to put it to use with an arb strategy alone. My guess is that his fund got locked into a levered position on one of the exchanges like BitMex for trying to trade too much then couldn't get out for 24 hours. This kind of thing is more common than you might expect. There are also very few exchanges that allow margin trading, leverage or shorting, and all the ones that do have, uh, questionable compliance practices.