11 ms·
The Dating Brokers: An autopsy of online love
- cbhl 8y agoThis page reads normally on mobile, but on desktop it's eight columns wide, scrolls horizontally, with each column being 1/4th the screen width.
- thanatropism 8y agoIs this peak responsive.
- busterarm 8y agoWhat a horrendous experience that was.
- matte_black 8y agoThe horizontal scroll actually isn't that bad, but what killed it was using italics for the entire text. What the hell???
- dec0dedab0de 8y agoyeah I like weird layouts sometimes, but italics was a pain, especially since this is just text.
- ra__mm 8y agothanks for the feedback :), we will consider to change that
- currymj 8y agoi think you’re supposed to click on the links which open up more info written in standard font. in that context, the italics is sort of like how you might get a summary in italics at the start of a book chapter.
- ra__mm 8y agoyou got it!
- blattimwind 8y agoTurning on reader mode has it display the massive GDPR waiver / "partners list" instead of the actual article :)
- skullum 8y agoReader mode works for me in Firefox. What browser are you using?
- blattimwind 8y agoFirefox
- weavie 8y agoIt seems turning on reader mode displays the gdpr waiver, but then if you refresh the page it shows the article. I'd be interested to know how they managed to achieve that. The waiver doesn't seem to appear in the html source.. so I'm not sure where it is coming from and it is now too late in the day for me to investigate it further..
- ra__mm 8y agohi, i developed that page. But I don't really understand what you mean
- getcrunk 8y agoNot for me. What device/os/browser are you using
- unreal37 8y agoI'm having trouble determining what they discovered here. 1) They bought 1 million dating profiles 2) They traced it back to Match.com and Plenty of Fish That's it? That's the news? Where's the meat? What am I missing?
- munchbunny 8y agoYou can buy a large number of completely deanonymized profiles that tie together photos, names, sexual orientation, etc. (those were what stuck out to me) for a couple hundred bucks. Usually you have to go through the back door to get this stuff. Even advertising companies go further than this to anonymize you. This is a pretty blatant privacy violation. If the headline was just "Match.com sites are sharing your profile info between them" this would smell bad but wouldn't be a big deal.
- xxpor 8y agoCheck out the creator's main site: http://janavirgin.com/ http://janavirgin.com/
- munk-a 8y agoI assume the CO2 emission primarily comes from the excessively large fonts used? Just like printing in a smaller font to be environmentally friendly using a smaller display front is similarly advantageous - and don't even get me started on all-caps, you might as well be burning a mountain of coal if you type in all-caps. /s
- ra__mm 8y agothat is the design of the page
- BadassFractal 8y agoSpeaking of LTV, the power users in online dating can easily be worth several hundred a month. Super swipes and super likes are about $1 each these days and in crowded dating markets you have to rely on them heavily if you're hoping to cut through the noise of everybody else's profiles. I'm actually surprised Tinder and co haven't started selling an option to bid money to have your profile be seen first in your city. Same as any other real time bidding in advertising. Have users try to outbid each other to be within first x swipes in the city, instead of "potential match in position 10574" that nobody will ever swipe to. I realize it might mess with their products' Aha! Moment of seeing only super attractive members within your first few minutes of the user journey, but there's likely a ton of money in it, and a way to strike a healthy balance. I know I would probably end up using something like that. On an unrelated note, seeding your app with "fake users" siphoned from your peer companies sucks if you're charging for the service. You end up having your users spend hours swiping or paying money to connect with fake profiles. Can't be ethical.
- thanatropism 8y agoI met all my girlfriends including my wife in nightclubs. I didn't even like nightclubs but wanted to meet women. This probably sounds as quaint as arranged marriages nowadays.
- BadassFractal 8y agoI've done the whole bars and night clubs thing pretty actively in my mid to late 20s. My issue has always been that your ability to be selective in that kind of environment only extends to the looks. Also I don't drink and have a very consistent sleeping schedule, so prowling bars for women until 3 in the morning has lost a lot of its appeal when I spend the rest of the weekend feeling like shit. Online you get to learn a bit more about them before you invest your time: do they have similar values, similar interests, compatible lifestyles and socio economics? Not all of it is written as text, a lot of it can be easily inferred from the photos, which is why Instagram is so popular these days in online dating as a lifestyle resume. Yes, it's heavily edited to show the best parts, like a resume, but you can still draw some conclusions from it. Like with hiring for your company, the mode you do it, the better you are at guesstimating what that person is like from their profiles. Several hundred first dates and your model gets trained with a lot of data.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoSo, just to get an idea, i can buy 1million profiles including pictures for 130 Euros, which I should be able to match against stolen credit card lists (do those come with addresses?) and even old stolen passwords. I mean, yikes.
- BadassFractal 8y agoIt's a gold mine for social engineering. Age, location, sexual orientation, relationship status, employment status, interests, aspirations, lots of information based on their Instagram feed about things like travel destinations, friends, parents, pets etc. I'm sure the conversations themselves include a lot of personal information that one wouldn't want floating around the web.
- air7 8y agoHow would one go about monetizing this data?
- 55555 8y agoMake a publicly indexed dating site for people into bestiality and just upload all of these profiles to it. 'Restore' all of the accounts using their emails and password hashes. Like Ashley Madison, charge people money to delete their profiles. Accept only bitcoin. Thank you for granting me this exercise in creativity... now please don't do this.
- therealx 8y agoSome people have - searchable databases for collections agencies/the police/private eyes/anyone looking for someone else.
- matte_black 8y agoI don't think the conversations are for sale.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago
- ajiang 8y agoWe believe that the $0.57 average revenue per user that Match Group reported in their Q2 2018 Investor Presentation is just a fraction of the user profile's real value. At the risk of taking the wrong thing away from this article...IAC is an undervalued stock?
- shard972 8y agoUnless you think marrige and long term relationships haven't seen the bottom yet, I can't imagine why dating website user information should be worth a lot as people find the person they want to be with and move on.
- jerrre 8y agoThe information provided for dating, could be interesting for many other purposes....
- thomas93 8y agoOnly if you assume that the market was not already aware of this and therefore has not already priced it in. Companies are (at least theoretically) valued based on their future potential. Just because "real value" of user profiles may not currently be getting realized, does not mean that it isn't already incorporated into the value of the stock.
- ggm 8y agoBack before we thought intelligent machines were going to be a thing, (we're talking 1970s here) I discussed online dating with my brother, who proposed writing a simple DB to match random men with random women. Neither of us had considered the possibility. I think we'd got to the idea that if they both liked tennis, it was plausible to rank them higher. He got pretty quickly to "its unethical, but simple" Now we have AI and intelligent machines. I'm sure onine dating does a better job matching people up. (/s for anyone who is humour impaired) Actually, what works, is putting sweaty tee shirts in a bag, and letting women sniff. Turns out that how you smell is a pretty good indication of how likely it is, you can form an effective match. So on that score, the first online love broker who manages to capture digital nose moments, probably wins. Right now, I'd welcome good stats on how much better online relationship brokering does than other models. If you rank by income, you probably get more successful matches for rich people seeking partners for high value service, but there might be surprises: It wouldn't surprise me if down in the dollar-shop window, people do well, but better than random?
- julienmarie 8y agoI made that mistake when launching my first dating website By trying to be more efficient. Unfortunately, this market is not about dating, it's a dopamine delivery market. You want to keep people long, increase your LTV, show them an ever better possible "match" so you never settle. You don't want them to actually meet someone. Hence the crappy chat features ( while the rest of the tech stack is usually pretty solid ).
- ggm 8y agoRight. The apparent business model is "supply service to person x for service y" but the actual business model is "keep user online long enough to make them valuable eyeballs to sell to somebody else, be it another consumer of service, or an advertiser, or whatever"
- scythe 8y agoThe only honest incentive is if you charge a high price for a successful relationship. The downside is you have to send people a bill when they get married.
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agoI used to work for a German dating site called friendscout24 when it was still in it's early stages. we worked with a psychologist to help improve the quality of the match-making logic (now be2.com). I didn't really care too much about the product back then and was mostly trying to scale the backend which was my passion. Linux, Java lot of traffic and scaling issues everywhere in these pre-cloud days. The whole thing was built with affiliate marketing and also engineering was increasingly driven by the marketing team and their sometimes outrageous ideas. I remember the best idea that we had was to move to recurrent billing (profits went through the roof because people forgot to cancel the service) and not long after, it was acquired by T-mobile. That's when I left since the work suddenly was all about internal API's and not really interesting for a nerd like me. The craziest place at friendscout was the customer care. We had one student working there who did a master thesis in psychology and chose sado-masochism as subject. She was on a roll there with all the people asking crazy questions to customer care. She was kind of a student of the human condition I think and I had some very cool conversations in my time there. Friendscout wasn't targeting this (S/M) niche. However there were plenty of users that came from all sorts of dark corners and S/M was by far not the darkest. One guy (he was internally called the shit-eater because well no need for explanation) kept coming back with countless new pseudonyms every week ("brownsauce", "smellyjelly", "sh1tinyourmouth" and other words, very hard to filter out upon registration). He was an isolated individual no doubt but kept half of engineering and all of customer care busy for weeks. Most users were fairly normal though, albeit (looking back) vulnerable in a way that still makes me sad. At least those who engaged with the customer care. They were men (mostly) that hardly ever had a girlfriend whose name hasn't ended in dot-jpeg or the type of girls that would "power"-date 7 guys in as many days to find their "perfect love". For many it was like tinder but without labeling it as a casual dating site. But casual hookups were probably the main use (at least for guys). Since it was early days the product wasn't very specialized or settled into a specific vertical, that's why we had all types of crazy people mingle along "normies". (what is normal? I have no idea but I knew that place certainly didn't feel normal) The shit my colleagues from customer care have seen though was another level. Once they compiled the craziest stories into a book (verbatim conversations from users copy pasted for the amusement of staff) and handed it out to all employees as a Xmas gift. It was funny admitted but hardly ethical to put these customer-support emails into a book and then laugh about your stupid users at a company gathering. Thinking back, my biggest regret about the place was not leaving earlier. After the acquisition the founders also moved on to other projects. Founders were relocating their personal assets to Switzerland and learned how to capture all of the market. They formed various shell companies (e.g. Insparx in Luxembourg) through which to bootstrap much darker and more sinister "dating" ventures. They formed a company called c-date (c = casual dating which was the German front for Insparx). This allowed them to capture the lower segments of the market while keeping their names clean and also save some cash by funneling services through the low-tax structure instead of Germany. They also pushed into the upper segments like match.com (total market domination seems the point for any company so be careful what you get into because eventually they'll pivot into new domains and bootstrap it with what they have) ... but this isn't what I'm talking about here. According to one of my old colleagues from friendscout who moved on with the managers to build C-date (again actually Insparx), C-date was using the affiliate marketing scheme they had at friendscout but applied in this way: advertise on websites for women (fashion magazines, interior design, basically all the Grune+Jahr publishing brands - most of Grune+Jahr were also affiliates with Friendscout). The messages women saw when visiting burda.de would be something like "looking for Mr Perfect?" or some other drivel that only fashion magazine readers would be gullible enough to respond. The women would click on it and sign up in an iframe of the original (girly) site (and not have a clue that this was c-date). And men would be targeted with a more honest and different message (on xhamster, redtube, youporn ... you name it) which read: "looking for horny sluts in your area that just want to get f!cked - click here <blinky blinky text>". Absolutely fucking degrading. Both Jan Becker (and his mentor & former friendscout CEO Andreas Etten) managed to keep their names out of controversy and am sure are well respected individuals of the Munich & Zurich tech scene. But they're until today the names behind the Luxembourg shell companies and who signed off on these predatory strategies. They (and others) deserve to be burned at the stake for tricking these female (and quite frankly male) users with these growth hacking techniques. If you have read this from beginning to end you might have noticed that it all started out with good intentions: Bring people together based on match making rooted in science. It ended as one of the most disgusting things that I've ever come across. Meanwhile I've seen countless similar ideas go from best intention to a dumpster-fire (sharing economy LOL). Whenever somebody claims that their idea will make the world a better place, run!! Because these are the worst.