4 ms·
HackerNews loads instantly, as do many other sites. HTML works fine. The problem is the stuff on the page, like ads delivered by Google AdX. Removing or optimi
by manigandham 8y ago
HackerNews loads instantly, as do many other sites. HTML works fine.
The problem is the stuff on the page, like ads delivered by Google AdX. Removing or optimizing those will make any page faster. No AMP necessary.
Slow sites are not a technical problem, they are a business and marketing problem.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> HackerNews loads instantly, as do many other sites. HTML works fine. They load quickly, not instantly. That's the fundamental mistake you have in understanding why people prefer AMP, Facebook instant articles, and Apple News.
- manigandham 8y agoThe average human response time is roughly 250ms so page loads within 1-2 seconds do not make a major impact on user interaction, especially if the actual text content is available immediately which can be done easily. AMP has little benefits to anyone but Google and the work it requires only takes away from the effort that could otherwise be spent on making the original website faster. We work with 1000s of publishers and every major adtech company, and over the years we've built the fastest ad network on the planet using techniques from TCP window sizes to counting bytes in HTTP2 streams. AMP is not necessary for speed, it only requires business prioritization, but you can't fix that with technical standards.
- krageon 8y agoI was with you 100% about the AMP stuff, but a statement like "page loads within 1-2 seconds do not make a major impact" is just so laughably wrong that I have to wonder where you source your information. If you actually work in the space, it would behoove you to do some A/B testing on different page load speeds. You will quickly see that it does indeed make a huge impact on user interaction. That is leaving aside the fact that nobody is actually investing the time they'd spend in AMP to make their website faster. It's simply not something the really bad publishers (for example, a lot of the news space) care about, for reasons I have never managed to follow.
- manigandham 8y agoWhy is it wrong? My identity isn't hidden, you can easily check my industry experience. I'm speaking on TBs of data directly measured everyday on the publishers we work with. I also said "especially if the actual text content is available immediately", which it almost always is. It's the other assets on the page that slow down loading. If you check the top 5k sites, none of them load any faster than 1-2 seconds, but many focus on optimizing for the first paint experience while loading the full site content over a few seconds. This is basically what AMP does, but taken to an extreme degree. There are many other factors like content types, page depth, dwell time, user activity, etc. that all matter, and it really takes 3+ seconds to start seeing significant effects on user sessions and revenue. Publishers don't make performance a priority because of something called yield management and a host of other complex business reasons related to revenue. Making the site more performant is usually not worth the limited dev resources, which again are affected by things like AMP.
- kup0 8y agoAll AMP is doing is providing training wheels for developers to create non-crappy versions of their websites by restricting what they include. AFAIK, there is no special magic to AMP that makes it fast, that can't be accomplished with simple CSS/HTML. It's just an on-rails subset of web technologies Now, it may be arguable, in this screwed-up world, that the only way to remotely even get publishers to make better websites is something like AMP, because it's "marketable" or "friendly" compared to just saying "fix your slow website", I just wish this wasn't the case. But I believe anything AMP does can be accomplished through non-proprietary means using standard web technologies. Not to mention, publishers probably only care about AMP because they feel forced to do so (because of carousel visibility, etc).
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> AFAIK, there is no special magic to AMP that makes it fast, that can't be accomplished with simple CSS/HTML. It's just an on-rails subset of web technologies The reason AMP loads instantly is that it is possible to validate AMP pages as safe to preload, so they are preloaded (when you interact with the carousel). That's why it's instant instead of just fast.