4 ms·
AMP is a fork of HTML that pressures limited developer resources to maintain a version for Google's visitors while only being fast because of arbitrary framewor
by manigandham 8y ago
AMP is a fork of HTML that pressures limited developer resources to maintain a version for Google's visitors while only being fast because of arbitrary framework limitations.
You can get a far better outcome by having search results consider site speed as a factor in rankings, which would make all publishers improve their sites overnight. The reason Google doesn't do this is because they also run the biggest ad network in the world which runs 80% of the slow ads you see on websites.
These projects within Google are common, similar to how it ranks down websites forcing web users to download an app, when their own websites do the same. AMP allows Google to keep people on Google domains, with better data collection and more control over the independent ad networks and analytics that can run on AMP pages.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> a version for Google's visitors And Microsoft's and Pinterest's and Baidu's and on and on. There are many search engines and link aggregators that preload AMP pages. You prefer that publishers make versions of their articles solely for Apple and other versions of their articles solely for Facebook? (Each has a proprietary competitor to AMP that actually have the disadvantages you listed.)
- robin_reala 8y agoI’d prefer they stuck to HTML and CSS, with a bit of progressively enhanced JS on top if needed.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoWhich is fine but not a substitute to Facebook's or Apple's solutions. People want their articles to load instantly, not merely quickly, which means you need a subset of HTML, CSS, and JavaScript that can be validated to be safe to preload, which is exactly what AMP is.
- manigandham 8y agoPreloading is just making server calls which is already possible, and preloading the HTML of the page will give you most of the experience of an instant transition without any need to validate anything.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> preloading the HTML of the page will give you most of the experience of an instant transition without any need to validate anything. It will also deanonymize the user to the publisher. I said AMP validates as safe to preload, not possible to preload.
- manigandham 8y agoWhy do you keep saying "you prefer" in comments? That's a poor way to frame arguments. What I actually prefer is HTML which is universally accessible by any device and service. No reason to have any proprietary formats like AMP or others.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> No reason to have any proprietary formats like AMP or others. Unless you want pages to load instantly, which is what AMP and its non-web competitors provide.
- manigandham 8y agoHackerNews loads instantly, as do many other sites. HTML works fine. The problem is the stuff on the page, like ads delivered by Google AdX. Removing or optimizing those will make any page faster. No AMP necessary. Slow sites are not a technical problem, they are a business and marketing problem.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> HackerNews loads instantly, as do many other sites. HTML works fine. They load quickly, not instantly. That's the fundamental mistake you have in understanding why people prefer AMP, Facebook instant articles, and Apple News.
- manigandham 8y agoThe average human response time is roughly 250ms so page loads within 1-2 seconds do not make a major impact on user interaction, especially if the actual text content is available immediately which can be done easily. AMP has little benefits to anyone but Google and the work it requires only takes away from the effort that could otherwise be spent on making the original website faster. We work with 1000s of publishers and every major adtech company, and over the years we've built the fastest ad network on the planet using techniques from TCP window sizes to counting bytes in HTTP2 streams. AMP is not necessary for speed, it only requires business prioritization, but you can't fix that with technical standards.
- srtjstjsj 8y agohttps://searchengineland.com/google-speed-update-page-speed-will-become-ranking-factor-mobile-search-289904 https://searchengineland.com/google-speed-update-page-speed-...
- manigandham 8y agoThe open secret in adtech and media is that this isn't used to any real effect, if at all. Google's own sites fail these performance reports.