9 ms·
Nvidia's $1,100 AI brain for robots goes on sale
- snops 8y agoActual link to the module, with tech specs: https://developer.nvidia.com/embedded/buy/jetson-agx-xavier https://developer.nvidia.com/embedded/buy/jetson-agx-xavier A good set of links to resources: https://elinux.org/Jetson_AGX_Xavier https://elinux.org/Jetson_AGX_Xavier Overall, looks incredibly powerful for the form factor and power usage, with a ton of high speed camera, display, and PCIE interfaces. I don't see any mention of production lifetime gaurantees, presumably that's a "please ask". Other SoM manufacturers promise a few years (up to 10), so you don't have to worry about redesigning your product every year. For the Jetson module, it's designed to be fairly tightly integrated and hence an swap out would not be trivial, e.g. you need to design a heatsink system for it yourself so you can choose a fan or heat pipe it to the enclosure walls.
- amelius 8y agoHow does it compare to e.g. an Intel Movidius neural compute stick?
- jahewson 8y agoThat’s an apples and oranges comparison - the Xavier is an entire computer, the Movisius is just a single accelerator chip.
- amelius 8y agoWell, nowadays you can buy an entire computer for a few dollars (e.g. in the form of a small PCB board containing an ARM processor), so I think the comparison is valid.
- mtgx 8y agoMovidius targets sub-1w. I haven't read the article but I assume this needs at least an order of magnitude more power.
- jl2718 8y agoMovidius Myriad chips have a Leon RISC cpu on-die.
- mark_l_watson 8y agoImpressive compute in a small form and running on 10 watts. Also interesting going after a non-consumer market although I think the chip would be a good fit in a handheld gaming device that supported some inputs from watching the player and had the power for very interesting/fun ‘game AI.’
- dejv 8y agoHavent tried Xavier yet, but I am using TX2 in my work (which is previous generation of this type of device) and CPU is very weak to allow any serious gaming.
- tonyarkles 8y agoAnecdotally, a friend has been using TX2s and got a Xavier to test out. He was blown away by the performance delta. It’s got an octocore ARM for a CPU, and while I don’t recall what the TX2 has... that’s a lot of CPU cores to work with. I’ve got a Xavier sitting on my desk too, but haven’t played with it much. Running OpenCV on it and doing some light live video processing was really smooth.
- dejv 8y agoFor games you usually want smaller number of high performant cores than many lesser performant. Haven't done much game programming in recent years, but I still remmember the terror of programming PS3 Cell CPU.
- twtw 8y agoWere the CPU cores of Cell (PPEs) hard to program? I had the impression that the difficulty of the Cell was in the need to manage the 8 SPEs, not in writing software for the Power4 core. The 8 core Carmel CPU in Xavier is not like the SPEs in Cell.
- dejv 8y agoIt was hard to utilise all those cores. I am sure game architectures evolved during the years, but back then we didn't know how to split the code to optimally utilise all available resources.
- sandworm101 8y agoThey should task this chip with proofreading that article.
- KineticLensman 8y agoI clicked through the various 'manage settings' dialogues starting at the 'before you continue...' splashscreen and eventually found a list [0] of Oath partners who "participate and allow choice via the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) Transparency and Consent Framework (TCF)". The list contains more than 200 different organisations. I decided not to read the article. [0] https://guce.oath.com/collectConsent/partners/vendors?sessionId=3_cc-session_2f4e2e70-b63f-4f48-a2a3-647120b9d27e&lang=en-GB https://guce.oath.com/collectConsent/partners/vendors?sessio...
- dgzl 8y ago> Interactive Advertising Bureau Why does this just sound terrifying to me?
- eutectic 8y agosounds better than the alternative...
- ethbro 8y agoPersonally, I would prefer to batch my advertising. Ideally while my eyes were not on the screen.
- djtriptych 8y agoFunny because they're about the least scary entity in the digital advertising space.
- Semaphor 8y agouBlock Origin & uMatrix allow you to read the site without seeing that popup or sending data to the advertisers. I realize that you shouldn't need to do that, but imo it's the reality we leave in.
- KineticLensman 8y agoI run uBlock Origin & uMatrix in my browser of choice. Because (reasons) I opened the article in Edge and was dropped into the reality that I ignore most of the time. I posted because I don't think it hurts sometimes to be reminded of reality.
- Symmetry 8y agoThis look really compelling for cases where a robot isn't big or stationary enough to just use an industrial PC. I'm really looking forward to seeing how NVIdia's newest iteration on Transmeta's core does in benchmarks. From the Wikichip Spec results[1] and quick Phoronix tests[2] it doesn't seem too far off from an Intel chip clocked down to a similar speed. The whole approach of JITing form x86 or ARM instructions to an exposed pipeline VLIW design is just a really interesting one. For the last generation that was used in the Nexus 6 it did very well in areas that VLIWs are traditionally good at like audio processing and did sort of mediocre in areas where VLIW tends to be bad. A JIT running underneath the OS has the freedom, in theory, to add things like memory speculation across library calls that an OoO processor could do. But the software to do that is, of course, really hard to write. I hope it's improved in the years since the Nexus 9 came out. [1] https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/nvidia/microarchitectures/carmel https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/nvidia/microarchitectures/carme... [2]https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=nvidia-carmel-quick&num=2 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=nvidia-c...
- dejv 8y agoAlso the GPU is usually lacking in typical industrial PC. I am using TX2 for this exact reasons: small form factor and good performance for gpu enabled code (running openCV and ML models). Plus you can easily add your own hardware and it act as kind of a RaspberryPI on steroids.
- agumonkey 8y ago1000 GBP at https://www.siliconhighwaydirect.co.uk/product-p/900-82888-0000-000.htm https://www.siliconhighwaydirect.co.uk/product-p/900-82888-0... not bad
- tim333 8y ago>You're not about to buy one yourself -- it costs $1,099 each in batches of 1,000 units On the site it has: "Members of the NVIDIA Developer Program are eligible to receive their first kit at a special price of $1,299 (USD)" (https://developer.nvidia.com/buy-jetson?product=all&location=GB https://developer.nvidia.com/buy-jetson?product=all&location...) The specs seem quite impressive really.
- pj_mukh 8y agoIs there a devboard?
- tim333 8y agoKinda. This video shows what you get https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoWW5HiGHsg&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoWW5HiGHsg&feature=youtu.be
- jdc 8y agohttps://www.nvidia.com/en-us/autonomous-machines/embedded-systems-dev-kits-modules https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/autonomous-machines/embedded-sy...
- xvilka 8y agoToo bad this comes from the worst company to the open source. I wish something other than CUDA and NVIDIA dominated modern AI industry.
- twtw 8y agoI wish the economics of the present were somewhat different, and that money didn't exist in the 21st century. And yet, in the world we live in, I have a hard time faulting a corporation for not giving away their core products for free.
- xvilka 8y agoWell, for example, many other corporations have a friendlier stance to open source. It is not only about money and profits.
- TomVDB 8y agoNvidia, the worst company to the open source, has 127 open source repositories on GitHub.
- twtw 8y agoCue the argument that these "don't count" because they use CUDA.
- xvilka 8y agoBy the way, are you an NVIDIA employee? Judging by your comments and submissions. Then it would explain all the protective arguments.
- twtw 8y agoObviously, I have a bias coming into this discussion (and so do you). Mine comes from experience in a world of hardware and physical products that gives me a greater affinity for the business model of hardware companies than "open source friendly" advertising giants. I have a fascination with the war of words free software adherents wage against nvidia - the company could give out candy to children and it would get criticized because Linus gave them the finger. I'll also admit that I am entertained by the no true scotsman squirming that occurs when I point at things that nvidia has done that don't support the story that it is the evil empire.
- saosebastiao 8y agoDoes it have onboard memory? I feel like calling it a system-on-chip kind of implies it, but I didn't see anything about it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- monocasa 8y ago"SoC" is pretty orthogonal to having memory, but system on modules almost always do. This one has 16GB.
- joefourier 8y agoIt's interesting how each major iteration of Nvidia's embedded boards keep increasing in price by a significant amount. The TK1 was $199, the TX1 was (at release) $599, and now the Xavier is $2,500/1,299 (with rebate). The TX2 is priced identically to the TX1 at release but was an incremental update. With the TK1 being EOL, it seems there is no longer an embedded SBC in the $100-$200 pricerange that has comparable GPU performance, despite the TK1 being over 4 years old.
- scottlocklin 8y agoMaybe this should be an 'ask HN' thread. About 10 years ago I considered taking up robotics as a hobby, and thought better of it upon asking a robotics professor I did deadlifts with in the gym. My goal was an autonomous robot which could fetch me arbitrary things from a refrigerator with minimal trickery (aka radio tags on beer cans, magnetic tape on the floor, etc). Seemed impossible at the time, or at least a pretty serious Ph.D. thesis type of effort. Is there some list of 'open problems in robotics' by which I could inform myself if this is still an insane goal?
- sjf 8y agoDepending on your definition of trickery, you could probably do it right now with a vending machine fridge and a conveyer belt.
- scottlocklin 8y agoYeah, when I was originally thinking of this, the conclusion I came to was that this would be a more honest version of the available 'robotics' solutions.
- Qworg 8y agoIt is an open problem still. I'm unsure of a list though. There have been some great advancements in grasping and embodied decision making lately though, so it could fall soon.
- robkop 8y agoAbsolutely not an insane goal. If you want to see progress in picking items a good starting point with a bunch of resources is the Amazon picking challenge. In terms of navigation, magnetic line following is trivial and more complex navigation really isn't that hard these days. Just look at how any of the modern robovacs navigate. If you want to generally see where things are I'd recommend checking out some papers or even some writeups from the last icra. EDIT: Just looked at the Amazon picking challenge for the first time in quite a while and it's not as impressive as I remember it to be.
- tlb 8y ago
- syntaxing 8y agoI bought a TX2 recently at a discount and it was extremely fun to use. I would love to use a Xavier but it is a bit out of my price point so I guess they priced it solely for the industry. It's still amazing to see something priced only at $1K (relatively speaking, this stuff was always expensive). I highly recommend others to buy a TX2 if they want to dabble in embedded electronics machine learning. Shameless plug, if you own a TX2, I recently designed a case for it: https://www.powu3.com/cad/tx2/ https://www.powu3.com/cad/tx2/
- techsin101 8y agoCould someone eli5 this? I assume it runs coffee in gpu so do you need to know since special programming language
- p1esk 8y agoIt's a Linux board with an ARM processor and 30W Volta GPU. You connect one or more cameras to it, and develop GPU accelerated computer vision apps using the supplied SDK (CUDA, CuDNN, TensorRT, OpenCV, etc): https://developer.nvidia.com/embedded/jetpack https://developer.nvidia.com/embedded/jetpack You can also install Tensorflow on it.
- jkravitz61 8y agoThe development kit has been available for the last month. One of the problems no one talks about is that this platform (along with tx2/tx1) runs arm64 which makes it a HUGE pain for getting many libraries to work. I’ve been using these for a while, and consistently need to hunt down library source code and compile it for arm64 since most libraries are distributed without arm64 support. There’s also plenty of device specific closed source SDKs (such as point grey ladybug cameras) which just don’t support arm64 so your only option is to attempt to write your own or pressure the manufacturer to publish an arm64 version. I do not recommend this platform for hobbyists for this reason- go buy a small x64 computer and spend 1/10th the time designing a better battery system.
- jacquesm 8y agoIf you're into this kind of thing a little bit of compilation should not scare you. The norm in the embedded world is to bootstrap your toolchain first, the availability of a good compiler and libraries that are endian clean is amazing progress.
- jkravitz61 8y agoI would argue that it should scare you. This is targeted towards people who are working in the AI world and are likely not embedded experts. Also, the bigger problem is closed source libraries and drivers that choose not to support arm64.
- jacquesm 8y agoWhen building a product for embedded applications closed source libraries and drivers that do not support your platform are no obstacle at all. You contact the vendor and make a deal. That's in their - and your - interest. This is a totally different world than the open source world that you are referencing, likely that embedded product will also not be open source. Commercial licensing is your only option in that case anyway, unless you are just looking for FOSS stuff with permissive licenses, but in that case those won't be closed source to begin with... So the problem you perceive simply does not exist. The biggest questions will revolve around commercial viability, proof-of-concept and time to market. Rarely around such details as closed source libraries or drivers. Though, in case your supplier goes belly up those could become factors, but for that you have escrow agreements.
- perpetualcrayon 8y agoI think most consumer robots will be driven by centralized computing power. There's probably no need for the brain to be on the robot, just a good wifi connection. EDIT: That is of course for robots that won't need to leave the house. Then again, I can't imagine the future won't have global high bandwidth cellular coverage with at least 5 9's availability.
- ianai 8y agoSo long as there’s enough low latency bandwidth.