8 ms·
Apple Computers Used to Be Built in the U.S. It Was a Mess
- pinewurst 8y agoThis is a very stupid article. It describes* the lack of economic success of two somewhat automated factories built to produce large numbers of computers during an interval when neither's products were popular enough to justify their scale. It's like judging the economics of the Edsel factory in 1959 and generalizing that large scale US auto production was a stupid idea. *Fixed - bad wording choice
- RossBencina 8y agoI found the article to be an interesting chronological journey. It's worth a look just for the photos of the 1984 Mac production line, and 1990 NeXT production line. > It cites the lack of economic success It describes the lack of economic success. I'm not sure what thesis you think the article is "citing" in support of.
- miles 8y ago>> It cites the lack of economic success > It describes the lack of economic success. I'm not sure what thesis you think the article is "citing" in support of. Nothing wrong with "cites" in this context. From the OED: "4. To bring forward an instance, to adduce or allege (anything) by way of example, proof, etc."
- Armisael16 8y agoYes. The article doesn’t use the lack of economic success as an example or proof of anything. Merely mentioning something is not enough to be citing it. There has to be a larger purpose.
- robdachshund 8y agoIs arguing over semantics productive?
- orionblastar 8y agoApple has the resources to make them without a mess now.
- unnouinceput 8y agoNo it doesn't. Even with its 100 billion cash that they sit on, they can't. That was the conclusion of the article when it said it needs to bring back the entire web. Well, getting back that web is going to cost more then 1 trillion, the entire Apple value, so no, they can't.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI don't see how that follows necessarily - there is a severe lack of details supporting their conclusions. I am aware that the supply chain is complex but you really don't need to bring back the entire supply web. That is like saying that you can't build houses because you don't have iron mines which you need for the steel foundries you don't have which you need for the nail factories. What you need to do is to start bringing back the parts which it makes sense to do so and expand from there. Assembly plants for cars sold in any significant amount makes sense period just because of the physical volume of cars vs their parts - the assembled cab takes up a lot of excess space - and that is before any tariff issues.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoWhat if it doesn't make sense for any parts? What if the supply web has fixed points which make it impossible to transfer it in small-enough chunks? I doubt Apple haven't considered all of this. Currently China owns this space because the country invested absolutely insane amounts of money to build supply chains and manufacturing, to staff all of the above with competent educated (and mostly docile) workers, and to build supporting infrastructure. The US (and the UK) have done the opposite - crapped all over public education, allowed infrastructure to rot, and deliberately moved manufacturing offshore, because profit. And also - in the UK at least - because it helps keep the workers from opposing you. You can't turn around an entire sector by bringing parts of the supply chain home unless there's some obvious benefit. "Patriotism" is certainly a benefit, but if it kills your margins it's a double-edged benefit at best. This is where the US political system has failed. The US (and UK) haven't had a credible industrial strategy - or actually much of a credible economic and social strategy either - since the 60s. "Leave it to the markets" turns out to be an exceedingly stupid idea over the medium and longer term. You get your profits and your frothy stock market, and you get a stand-out sector or two which keeps some of the educated middle class minority docile. But you lose your industrial autonomy and your security, the rest of your middle class shrinks to nothing+debt, and ultimately your competitors eat your lunch. In the end game - still to come - they eat you.
- julienreszka 8y agoI don't understand why Apple is still considered an American company today
- oneida 8y agoPlease finish your thought. What should it be considered?
- bunnycorn 8y agoYes, because it's a multinational.
- astrange 8y agoNot only an American company but a Californian company. (Apple isn't registered in Delaware.)
- snaky 8y agoMaking all the chips in Texas.
- wolco 8y agoDidn't apple re-register in Delaware after orginally registering in California?
- lifekaizen 8y agoCalifornia was given in the most recent annual report. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/320193/000032019317000070/a10-k20179302017.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/320193/0000320193170...
- redial 8y agoiOS, macOS, iCloud, the App Store, iTunes are made 100% in the US.
- nwellnhof 8y ago
- GreenToad5 8y agoYet other personal computers were being built in the U.S. at that time and it was somehow not a mess... Jobs was a great idea man for technology and UX, but not so good at many other areas (such as we see here with manufacturing). I know that this article is trying to make a case that the problem was the US culture ETC (pro globalism), but if that was the case... why were so many other so successful where Apple failed?
- patrickg_zill 8y agoDEC computers used to be built in the US. As well as Cisco gear and much more...
- door-mat 8y agoWhy does it seem like every NYT article these days is usually pushing some absurd agenda? What happened to reporting the news?
- gulbanana 8y agowhat kind of "absurd agenda" do you think this article is "pushing"?
- jhbadger 8y agoIt pretty clearly is arguing that manufacturing in the US is a bad idea, apparently because it "lacks a manufacturing culture" to quote Gassee. Whether or not that is true, it really isn't a news article.
- scottlocklin 8y agoThat we couldn't possibly put any stinky, messy factories up and manufacture in the US. Because Gassée had a hard time with screwdrivers and "you can't bring manufacturing back." All that must be done in China now you see, because reasons It's definitely an agenda, definitely pushed, and fairly absurd.
- IAmEveryone 8y agoAre there any specific facts in the article that are wrong? Because otherwise, you just seem to be arguing that any facts that may be used to advance some side of some argument must not be published? That would seem to succeed only if the NYT were to ship a bunch of blank pages, seven times a week. Here’s also a story, just three weeks old, that paints manufacturing in the US in a positive light: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/23/nyregion/the-brooklyn-army-terminal-new-yorks-next-manufacturing-hub.html?rref=collection%2Ftimestopic%2FFactories%20and%20Manufacturing&action=click&contentCollection=timestopics®ion=stream&module=stream_unit&version=latest&contentPlacement=12&pgtype=collection https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/23/nyregion/the-brooklyn-arm... The NYT seems to (also) suck at coordinating their “agenda pushing”. It’s almost as if it’s a newspaper publishing ideas that don’t always neatly align to ideology.
- newnewpdro 8y agoIn a talk Jobs gave at MIT [1] he described the NeXT automated manufacturing facility in a positive light. I can only begin to imagine how much better it could be done today than back then. Articles like this one like to point out the number of people involved in the Chinese iPhone manufacturing as if that's somehow indicative of something other than simply using cheap labor instead of automation. If we wanted to manufacture this stuff in the USA, we definitely could, and it would be done using fewer people through automation. My understanding is the core reason we don't do manufacturing here anymore is it's a lot cheaper to do it where industrial pollution goes unchecked, where regulatory bodies are immature or entirely nonexistant. When China gets its shit together enough to protect its lands and people from the toxic output of all this industrial activity, large-scale manufacturing will move on to the next victim. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gk-9Fd2mEnI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gk-9Fd2mEnI
- froindt 8y agoI've read articles about the supply chain impacts of being in China, very near all your suppliers, compared to being in the US. When you need the screws in your first production run to be 0.1 mm shorter, you can call the screw manufacturer, they'll make a new mold right away and get you screws in 3 hours. Your screw manufacturer is almost certainly more than a 3 hour drive if you're in the US. [1] Looks like labor flexibility is another factor. In the US, culturally, you can't summon people from their sleep to start making phones urgently. Apparently this happened after the iPhone prototype Steve Jobs had got a scratched plastic screen 6 weeks before launch. [2] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/apple-america-and-a-squeezed-middle-class.html?pagewanted=all https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/apple-america-an... [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/willyshih/2018/11/05/apple-only-in-china-can-you-change-your-forecast-like-that/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/willyshih/2018/11/05/apple-only...
- ardy42 8y ago> When China gets its shit together enough to protect its lands and people from the toxic output of all this industrial activity, large-scale manufacturing will move on to the next victim. That's already happening: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-pollution-zibo/chinas-ceramics-capital-struggles-to-adapt-amid-war-on-smog-idUSKBN1DU0UM https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-pollution-zibo/chin... An acquaintance recently told me that Chinese ceramics production capacity is getting relocated to places like Cambodia.
- zwaps 8y agoYes, replacing early automatic factories with an army of Chinese workers who slave away in so miserable conditions that a big logistical consideration becomes how many of them kill themselves... Good on ya NYT. Keep shilling for the CCP, telling us how manufactoring can never, ever move out of China... Especially now when people start considering this, right? Ugh.
- doe88 8y agoAlso one aspect not discussed in this article is that now China is dedicating huge efforts [1] in order to maintain and secure its access to natural ressources needed for manufacturing, while most occidental countries have likely lost this capacity. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative
- tambourine_man 8y agoI've heard the “trash can” Mac Pro was and… well…
- campercoder 8y agoEven before manufacturing, the design is still a mess. 4 broken keys on a 2016 MB Pro. I don't type all that hard. How is that "pro"? It's got me very seriously considering switching over to linux.
- inieves 8y agoThis was a disappointing article on a few levels. 1) it doesn’t make a clear logical case for why manufacturing isn’t done by Apple (or many other companies) in the US, right now 2) it doesn’t give reasoning about why sotuation is unlikely to change, or if it does change, how it will not look anything like industrial-era factory labor manufacturing 3) it doesn’t explain that these realities have nothing to do with Apple, except that Apple finds these economic realities faster than other companies 4) it ends completey abruptly without drawing any real conclusion or thesis or adding any insight (based on solid reasoning) === The fact that Jean Louis Gassed can’t use a screwdriver has nothing to do with anything... Manufacturing of complex computer systems is complex, therefore requires many different competencies, said competencies must communicate to resolve challenges, and that in and of itself is hard. This hardness requires (literally) an ecosystem of skilled workers to address. Could Apple (or any other company) build such an ecosystem? Yes, if they did it from scratch early on, when the cost to build it was low because the ecosystem was relatively simple. But now, its not a simple ecosystem, and it would be painfully expensive to replicate. It should be noted that there is probably a strong difference in the complexity (therefore difficulty) of manufacturing high tech products versus other consumer products like cars/trucks, general electronics. That difference is the velocity/pace of new features going to market, required to drive sales. Tech products literally compete on feature sets. Sales of cars and toasters and espresso makers can depend on many factors and so they are not constantly racing to update the product every 6-12 months. I could be wrong here, but I believe the conclusion that tech manufacturing is like all other kinds of manufacturing is baseless. And in fact, the fact that so much has moved to China is the strongest evidence that it can’t simply exist anywhere.
- mc32 8y agoMaybe not the best examples, since the companies don’t exist anymore, but weren’t NeXT and Sun Micros built in the bay area in the early days? I think Sun hung on to the newark facilities nearly to their shuttering. Were they a mess too?
- bluedino 8y agoGood examples but they didn’t really do volume compared to the consumer brands. Gateway built computers in a South Dakota. Compaq and Dell in Texas.
- Kurtz79 8y ago"But unlike Detroit’s automotive model of the mid-20th century, relatively few middle-class jobs were created, and the region is marked by a vast concentration of wealth in the upper, white-collar reaches." After reading it about one thousand times, I still struggle with the definition of "middle class". Is everyone working with a white-collar job considered "upper class"? Are traditional manufacturing blue-collar jobs considered "middle class"? What is considered "working class"?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoA combination of the company you keep and the security of the quality of life you and they have. Can your wife afford to stay at home if she wants to? Can you work from home if need be? Do you need to budget when you go on vacation? Do you need to budget when you go out in town with your friends/family? If an emergency happens, how fragile is your support system? Which school system (zip code) can you afford? Do you have to work on weekends or overnights? Household income and profession is probably the easiest way to numerically define it. But I think (in the US) there are two distinct classes being formed, one that is and feels secure in their future due to having a well funded 401k or defined benefit pension, careers at large and prestigious companies with friends also at other large and prestigious companies (who can help you get work if need be), paid leave of various kinds, access to the better schools and health systems etc. The other class will be those that are setback forever by 1 medical emergency or mistake, have jobs instead of careers, who aren’t really able to plan for the future because they’re skating by and hoping it all works out and they can keep making their debt payments.
- mcny 8y agoBy income, I'd guess research assistants, teaching assistants, and college assistants are working class. You can declare a PhD candidate's "tuition" is ten million dollars a year and then "pay" the worker $10M in tuition credits + $20k living expenses but we all know the actual pay is $20k a year.
- Symbiote 8y agoBut by aspiration, these people are middle class. A teenager carrying a golf bag might still be upper class, if they're doing it because their father owns the golf course and sees it as a networking opportunity.
- Amezarak 8y agoYou'd think an NYT article about how Apple computers used to be built in the US would find it worthy of mention that Mac Pros are produced in the US today.
- carlob 8y ago1. Do they still make them? I know they still sell them, but given that they have been unchanged for 5 years... 2. I would say assembled rather than produced (if I buy components and assemble a PC at home is it produced in Italy?)
- Amezarak 8y ago> 1. Do they still make them? I know they still sell them, but given that they have been unchanged for 5 years... There's no indication I can find otherwise. > 2. I would say assembled rather than produced (if I buy components and assemble a PC at home is it produced in Italy?) In that case, iPhones are not produced in China, since the parts thereof are manufactured in many different countries, including the US, and only assembled in China. For what it's worth, photography from the plant shows there's a little more going on than is typical for building a desktop at home. https://twitter.com/tim_cook/status/474935247335743489/photo/1 https://twitter.com/tim_cook/status/474935247335743489/photo...
- reasonablemann 8y agoTim Cook loves the narrative that it's impossible to bring manufacturing culture back to the US. There was an article a while back about how lazy people were on the Mac Pro line. How is Tesla able to succeed? Something doesn't add up.
- baybal2 8y agoTesla makes a super duper expensive car with arguable manufacturability and a lot of non standard parts. That works for a $100k a piece car, not $30k, let alone $10k. You probably read comments that were Tesla be made by an established player, it would've been made for half the cost? Tesla's success slash failure is thanks to that absence of the established manufacturing culture in light industries. USA is still is a big manufacturing country, it's curse is that their industry manufacturers "invisible goods," and that its companies are low profile. For examples, almost all "picoprobes" in the world are made by one small company in USA that you can't even google. On the other hand, even a third tier smartphone maker in China has high media profile, and every highschooler will be able to name a few.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoWait, the iPhone is cheap? I had the first version ( well 3g actually) and never bothered since, because I thought it would only get more expensive
- baybal2 8y agoApple doesn't wants its good to be cheap to make, they want them to be borderline free. Have you read that for every iPhone, Chinese economy only gains single digits of value? Electronics is one of the most automated industries on the planet already. You can run in anywhere you want where you can put an SMT line. There are electronics factories even in African countries. What matters is being able to run in cheaper and better than the next competitor, and you can't do it with three quarters of the global electronics manufacturing ecosystem sitting in a single city - Shenzhen. IF Apple will agree to sell their products at less than triple digits markup, than they will be free to make iPhone in America.
- baybal2 8y agoI amazes me reading that they weren't even able to do a screwdriver level assembly in US, but that story is not that uncommon. I heard many horror stories about "Chinese company tries to run factory in US, runs away in horror in 6 months time." 1. Work culture - very few people with manufacturing experience 2. Work ethics - not stellar, were you fire people for low work attendance as they do in China, you will have to fire 70% of your workforce in US 3. Workforce education - US has a lot of high school dropouts, lots of PhDs, lots of community college educated clerks, but nothing in between. 4. Labour resources - cheap cities in US are small cities, having access to a lot of labour resources in one place is simply an unattainable dream for US.
- reacharavindh 8y agoManufacturing is fast evolving with the influence of high tech automation. As business relations gets too much to manage and brings more and more risks (trade war with china), I'd imagine companies will start investing in automated manufacturing plants stateside. Perhaps, the many of the components would still come from cheaper parts of the world, but I can see custom microprocessors being manufactured in the west, and say iPhones's body machined in the US, parts assembled into the enclosures at the US - by robots anyway.
- HeadsUpHigh 8y ago>I can see custom microprocessors being manufactured in the west This would really depend on the node used. For anything modern I think the only company left in the west that can do it is intel and I don't know how much of a market friendly option they are. Maybe with a lot of investment there could be some 28nm fabs in a few years which would then take forever to get a ROI, at which point it's anyone's guess what kind of technology will be used for chip manufacturing.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoIt seems to imply that because Apple didn't have success making computers in the Bay Area that manufacturing in the Bay Area isn't possible. Not true of course, Sun manufactured computers here, Force computers made millions of computers here, and there are still manufacturers around. That said, today it is greatly reduced. But it isn't clear to me at least that this is a permanent state. There is definitely a "community" aspect to this stuff (that part the article seems to get right), but the causality is not clear. If people started manufacturing more things in the Bay Area the community would get stronger as supply chains were shortened. As I see it, you start building things, and you order all of your components from far away. Then one of your suppliers creates a local factory / warehouse to cut down on shipping costs, then another. At which point you have a lot of things nearby. Similarly for services such as rework, tooling, and metrology.
- CydeWeys 8y agoLand (and thus labor) are way too expensive in the Bay Area to see a resurgence of high volume manufacturing. It'd be more likely to see manufacturing make a comeback a short flight away from SF where land is plentiful. That way you could easily make day trips to the factory and receive goods via truck within a day.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI disagree, there are already quite a few manufacturing facilities in the bay area. They don't grab the headlines but when you drive through the industrial parts of town they are all there. There is the Tesla plant (fairly high volume), there are three glass/window factories in Oakland (fairly high volume), probably a dozen printed circuit board houses of various volumes, a number of tool and die shops around south SF and Berkeley and elsewhere, at least two sheet metal fabrication plants in south San Jose. Intuitive Surgical has a surgical robot factory in Sunnyvale I believe. Nothing like a Foxconn "city factory", that is pretty clear. There is however the Gigafactory which is outside of Reno (to your point of being easy to get to). There is a lot of activity though.
- harrumph 8y agoI'm proud of HN for mostly seeing through the steaming crap in this piece. This article is the latest entry in a many decades-long campaign of capitalist propaganda dedicated to promoting the concept of "markets" as choiceless forces of nature -- as weather fronts that determine outcomes. The forbidden truth is that markets are the result of decisions made by ownership, and you can't read this terrible article without leaving the truth very far behind. This deterministic concept of markets is employed constantly to present howlingly absurd statements that serve as cover for the costly-to-the-US-middle-class commercial decisions that Apple made and still makes. You can tell this article is propaganda because of what it delivers: Deliverable #1: The headline alone tells you exactly what to think about a historic, complex outcome -- that is to say, this trillion-dollar company's hands were and remain tied by the market. Won't somebody please think of the trillion-dollar company? Deliverable #2: Personal experience is very sketchily generalized to a historic conclusion. A French exec struggles with his (two whole days' worth!) of work on an assembly line, therefore the entire US factory-building effort could never have worked. Irrevocable factors that define Fordist manufacturing -- division of labor, training, choreography -- these all vanish, dissolved by the power of a irrelevant anecdote. Deliverable #3: Orwellian ahistoricism deftly applied: Standing in North America, decades after success in WWII left it the only undevastated manufacturer on Planet Earth, someone actually states that the place "[Doesn't] have a manufacturing culture". No, really, that's something someone thought up and uttered, quoted in the NYT. See: "we've always been at war with Eastasia". Deliverable #4: Eliding troublesome counter-facts: As persons here have pointed out, Apple is on its sixth year of manufacturing its heavy hardware in Texas. There is no "mess" there, and this fact will be lost on millions of laypersons who have taken in at minimum the headline in Deliverable #1 and now think exactly what Apple prefers they think. There are more of these deceptions in even this short piece, but the point is made. Apple manufacturing is not centrally in the US because Apple leadership made that decision. The "market" did not, "culture" did not. Maximizing shareholder value -- at any social cost -- did.
- mietek 8y agoThis would have been a content-free article if not for the beautiful photos. Here’s a video tour of the Macintosh factory that used to be in Fremont, CA: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dk306ZkNOuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dk306ZkNOuc