9 ms·
EPIC Lawsuit to Suspend Deployment of Body Scanners at US Airports
- sstone 16y agoAlmost no politician would ever vote for removing this awful "security" measure. They would risk being blamed when another incompetent terrorist mastermind passes security and hopefully gets stopped by, now much more vigilant passengers. Going to the courts seems like a good way around that - sue the TSA. If someone with experience on these types of issues could comment I would be very interested to learn if this has any chance of removing those damn machines from airports.
- pchristensen 16y agoHelp us grellas, you're our only hope ...
- geuis 16y agoMake a list of congressmen and senators that require you to let nude photos of your children to be taken by government employees. It's all about how you frame the argument
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mhb 16y agoThat's good for the thin end of the wedge, but it might suggest that if the children are exempted from this nonsense, then the problem is solved. Also it sets up what could be spun as a bargaining chip. Exempt the kids and they can scan the adults.
- plmiujhbvnh 16y agoWhat age? 11, 16, 18 ,21 ?
- ryoshu 16y agoIt depends on how you position the wedge. You start by asking officials why they want to take naked pictures of innocent children. Once they are sufficiently embarrassed about the notion of taking naked pictures of children, you ask why they want to take naked pictures of innocent adults. Every time a TSA or DHS official talks about how they don't store the pictures, bring up the US Marshals Service storing naked pictures of children and adults (http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-20012583-281.html http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-20012583-281.html) using the same technology, despite providing the /exact/ same assurances the TSA is providing now. When the TSA officials talk about the opt-out process and the subsequent genital groping, ask about the TSA agent that was charged with raping a kid (http://www.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view/20100310child_rape_charge_rocks_tsa_logan_employee_pats_down_air_travelers_at_scan_stations/ http://www.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view/20100310child...) and wanting to keep that child as a sex slave. Do parents really want strangers feeling up the breasts and genitals of their underage children? What type of person applies for a job where they are allowed to grope children? Is it any better when those same agents want to grope adults? It's not advanced screening technology, it's a machine that takes naked pictures of children and stores them. It's not a thorough pat down, it's having your genitals groped by strangers. Control the language and you control the discussion.
- pjscott 16y agoI suppose so, but such blatantly manipulative tactics make me feel unclean.
- geuis 16y ago"They" aren't similarly so squeamish about waving fear and flags around to force body scans and invasive pat downs on us. This is an issue that is important and we must use tools that work to get it to stop.
- tjmc 16y agoBetter still - post the backscatter photos of those congressmen and senators online. I just hope I don't see them!
- palewery 16y agoWhen some congressman's 14 year old grandchild gets felt up by a perv things would change very fast
- LiveTheDream 16y agoApparently Congressman Jason Chaffetz introduced a bill against the full-body scanners[1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jason_Chaffetz http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jason_Chaffetz
- sstone 16y agoHis intention is to make them secondary. I'm sure the TSA would have none of that - it would just be magnetometer set to the highest sensitivity first - scanner second - for everyone.
- eli 16y agoA good first step would be to eliminate separate security lines for First Class/VIP and everyone else. I suspect security lines would end up being shorter if our elected officials had to go through exactly the same process as the rest of us.
- Zak 16y agoAs a hack, just go through the first class line regardless of the class you're flying in. I know several people who do this, and none have been questioned about it. The obvious response is: "Why should paying the airline more money get people better treatment from the Federal government?".
- tptacek 16y agoPresumably because the airlines fund the priority lines.
- Zak 16y agoQuite possibly, but since that isn't made clear, a bit of civil disobedience seems in order to me.
- daten 16y agoIn my experience this works every time at Dulles international (IAD) but never works at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International (ATL). At ATL you get sent to the back of the normal line.
- jrockway 16y agoThe hack is to print FIRST on your boarding pass. The person checking whether or not you are allowed in the priority line does not have access to the reservation system to check that you are actually in first class. You keep your real boarding pass in your pocket and show that to the TSA and gate agent. Note: untested. I get to use the first-class lines anyway :P
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yuvadm 16y agoEPIC lawsuit is epic.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- warpwoof 16y agoAwesome, Bruce Schneier is part of the lawsuit: "Three frequent air travelers are joining EPIC in the lawsuit: security expert Bruce Schneier, human rights activist Chip Pitts, and the Council on American-Islamic Relations legal counsel Nadhira Al-Khalili. The Petitioners have brought claims under the Administrative Procedure Act, the Privacy Act, the Video Voyeurism Prevention Act, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and the Fourth Amendment."
- sstone 16y agoYes, he has been following this thing for a long time. "Only two things have made flying safer [since 9/11]: the reinforcement of cockpit doors, and the fact that passengers know now to resist hijackers." http://www.schneier.com/news-072.html http://www.schneier.com/news-072.html
- geuis 16y agoThis isn't about religion. It's about invasion of privacy and degradation of the human spirit by an uncontrolled government bureaucracy that thinks it has a free hand by waving around the fear flag. This smells like the McCarthy era.
- donohoe 16y agoOf course its not about religion in itself. Religion is only one aspect of this, there were others: "Administrative Procedure Act, the Privacy Act, the Video Voyeurism Prevention Act, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and the Fourth Amendment"... there 4 other reasons. Not sure why you choose to pick on religion in itself when it was within context of other reasons. For those of a religious persuasion the invasion of privacy may be an additional problem on top of the normal intrusiveness of these scanners.
- latch 16y agoRights, like a muscle, must be exercised. However, I feel entering a country which I'm not a citizen of (like the US), is a privilege, not a right. Thus, they can ask anything of me they want..and I can chose not to enter the country.
- ojbyrne 16y agoBody scanners aren't just used at entry to the US, they're used to get on domestic flights also.
- sstone 16y agoPeople in the lawsuit are US citizens. They just don't want to get naked and receive more radiation every time they board any flight in the US. People outside the US must also sometimes fly to the US for business purposes. It is not easy sometimes to choose not to go to the US.
- ataggart 16y agoNote that (unless otherwise worded) the Constitution's "protections" are actually restrictions on the government, and apply everywhere and always to government agents acting under constitutional authority. As such, the nationality of the those with whom the government interacts is irrelevant. I imagine that you can opt-out of the electronic strip search, just as US citizens can. An interesting, though sadly irrelevant note: the Constitution does not grant to the Federal government the power to regulate foreign immigration.
- TallGuyShort 16y agoAs exciting as this sounds, the dates are all at least several months old. Anybody know more about the current status of this, or the direction it's heading?
- warpwoof 16y agoI think you are looking at other news items on the page that are several months old? The actual document submitted to the court is dated November 1, 2010. [PDF] http://epic.org/privacy/litigation/EPIC_Body_Scanner_OB_Final.pdf http://epic.org/privacy/litigation/EPIC_Body_Scanner_OB_Fina...
- kia 16y agoFrom my experience full body scanners are much faster and more convenient compared to traditional system when you take off your shoes and go through metal detector. If you are unlucky an airport worker additionally scans you with a hand metal scanner. With full body scanner you just enter the cabin and voila! The scan takes 3 seconds.
- ck2 16y agoThat's because the person in the other room can stare and share your image for quite some time after it's taken. 3 seconds for you, but as long as they want for them.
- jonnathanson 16y agoIt's not even the nudity that bothers me, personally. It's the radiation. I didn't sign up for unshielded exposure to dangerous levels of radiation when I bought my airplane ticket. Ultimately, I think a public health angle would have been a far more effective tact to take in the lawsuit or in the arguments against these scanners. It's the trump card. Privacy always loses an argument to fear and "security" in our post-9/11 national discourse. Sad to say, but that's true. Health, though? That's a different matter.
- mhb 16y agoWhy do you think the amount of radiation is dangerous?
- plmiujhbvnh 16y agoWhy do you think it isn't ? There are over 800 million airline passengers in the US each year. If this radiation causes cancers in 1 in a million thats 800 people/year.
- evgen 16y agoIf this procedure causes 800 cancers per year then the flights themselves would be causing nearly a hundred thousand cancer cases per year. The radiation from the scanner is far, far safer than the exposure you receive during the flight that caused you to get scanned in the first place.
- ck2 16y agoWhy didn't they add some kind of protection act for children to this lawsuit as well? They are making children go through these things and then showing them naked to who knows? That violation should surpass the far more vague "religious freedom".
- daten 16y agoCan both sides play the "think of the children" card in the same fight?
- pjscott 16y agoOn that note, who says only two sides can play the "think of the children" card? To demonstrate otherwise, I'm going to make a third side which says that naked children aren't inherently that big a deal, and that greater harm comes from the implicit sexualization of children, and the paranoia about sexual predators that it causes. I don't really mind backscatter machines in airports; I find them funny and entertaining, if only for the vaguely Caramelldansen-like hands-above-the-head pose they had me assume last time I went through one. What does bother me is how every time there's a sensational incident -- a terrorist attack, or someone getting kidnapped, or whatever -- people start screaming for someone in the government to DO SOMETHING!!1, and we end up spending an inordinate amount of time and resources guarding against something that happened once and isn't too likely to happen again. Smart terrorists would stay the hell away from airports; they'd get a higher marginal return on their efforts if they went for easier targets like sports stadiums or crowded subways. And if that starts happening, what are we going to do? Put backscatter machines and security guards everywhere? Completely sacrifice all privacy to assuage our fears about the most unlikely events, while neglecting the real killers, like car crashes and cancer? So to hell with it. Go ahead and make me remove my shoes at the airport and strike a ridiculous pose in a backscatter machine; I'll just laugh it off. What worries me is the preposterous irrationality, and where it'll lead if we give it free rein for long enough. Won't somebody please think of the children?
- th0ma5 16y agoI take from what you say as touching on something I've often thought, we're treating the symptoms of an example problem as though it was an epidemic. I think that there are two sides to the security theater, what they show, and what they don't. I think that these devices will catch people sure, and make a great number of people like yourself sort of a comfortable indifferent, but I do believe that there is indeed a total package of risk management, and these public faces of the effort is just the tip of the iceberg. The evidence I have of this is when I went to Mexico one time and my significant other bought some kind of pill with my card. They could care less about me at the border, they went for the exact pocket of her purse. It took a matter of minutes, and we were on our way. I have some theories about how they might have done it, and I'm sure it was simple, but it is by no means obvious (maybe my CC info? the way she carried herself?) exactly how it was done.
- daimyoyo 16y agoI want the airlines to pay attention to what I'm about to say: Until these electronic strip search machines are taken out, I will NEVER fly again. I've done nothing wrong and I will not tolerate being treated like a criminal simply because you think you can get away with it.
- wjy 16y agoWith all due respect, if you want the airlines to listen to you, you should say it to them, not HN.
- Silhouette 16y agoI'm with the GP, and we do better than merely saying it to the airlines: we vote with our wallets. Given the recent comments by air industry bigshots in the UK, it appears that they're starting to get the point, too.
- michael_nielsen 16y agoIt's not the airlines. It's the TSA, an entirely separate organization. I've little doubt that most of the airlines hate this - it almost certainly negatively impacts their bottom line.
- marquis 16y agoI wonder if women might, on mass, protest these machines by saying 'I may be pregnant' or 'I am breastfeeding'. If this is a suitable means of gentle civil disobedience, perhaps another method is suggest for men? I myself am considering to use the 'possibly pregnant' method next time I fly in the US and am curious what the response will be, and how I am treated in the pat-down.
- eof 16y agoI've been thinking about how to work myself up to a hard on before going through as a form of reverse molestation.
- waterlesscloud 16y agoforget court, write airlines and tell the why you now fly less. they have more power here.
- random42 16y agoAs an Non-American, While reading the article, I got the vibe, that the ideology at the TSA security check is, Unless proven otherwise, everyone is a terrorist (criminal) IANAL, but where does US constitution/judicatory stand on it?
- wrs 16y agoThe purpose of this lawsuit is to answer that question. Though I have to say that for the past 9 years, the constitution, judiciary, and legislative branches of the U.S. haven't seemed to have much influence on anything that is supposedly "needed to fight terrorism".
- tptacek 16y agoThat's not true. The lawsuit doesn't challenge the doctrine of administrative searches, and goes as far as to concede that full-body scans are constitutional as a secondary screening measure (for people who set off the metal detector, or who can't go through the detector, or have prosthetics, or are on a watchlist, or become random selectees). At issue in this lawsuit is the specific question of whether an electronic strip search can qualify as an administrative search, which must balance the public interest against the intrusiveness of the search.
- tptacek 16y agoThe Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of "administrative searches", which aren't targeted, don't require a warrant, don't require individual suspicion, and which are used to protect public safety and not to conduct criminal investigations.
- cowboyhero 16y agoIANAL, but I believe this also allows the cops to set up random DUI roadblocks (ie, untargeted, no warrant, no individual suspicion, public good, etc).
- tptacek 16y ago
- knodi 16y ago"Those who are willing to trade freedom for security deserve neither freedom nor security." - Benjamin Franklin
- tptacek 16y agoMy guess is they're going to get shellacked. The first thing you have to understand here is that the constitutionality of airport searches isn't in question. SCOTUS has upheld a doctrine of "administrative searches", taken in order to advance public safety rather than criminal investigations, which are explicitly intended to apply universally, without a warrant, and without individualized suspicion. The second bit of background you should have is 49 USC 44925, which mandates that the TSA research and deploy advanced screening technology, specifically to detect nonmetallic objects. I'm no lawyer, but I do enjoy reading SCOTUS civil liberties opinions, and by and large the court seems to give deference to the legislature when no clear constitutional issue is at stake. In sum: the court has an "out" here, which is "the intent to search passengers is already constitutional, so if this variant of the search is so bad, pass a law". The Supreme Court has not outlawed strip searches (obviously they can't, as virtually everyone who gets arrested and booked is strip searched, guilty or not). If you read the Savana Redding opinion (8-1 "it's unconstitutional to strip search an 8th grade girl for ibuprofen"), you'll see things like "Its indignity does not outlaw the search, but it does implicate the rule that "the search [be] ‘reasonably related in scope to the circumstances which justified the interference in the first place.’". That is, unfortunately, not a hard case for TSA to make. The fact that the Savana search was for "nondangerous contraband" also factored into the opinion. (If you want to throw up in your mouth a little bit, track down Clarence Thomas' dissent which argued that it is indeed constitutional to strip search a 13 year old girl in school to track down Advil.) Finally, the arguments EPIC makes here do not seem awesome. Part of their argument turns on administrative rulemaking procedures at TSA, which TSA seems to dismantle efficiently in their response. Other parts drag in things like the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which is (a) a longshot argument for petitioners who can claim no personal religions infringed on and (b) is neatly sidestepped by the TSA "opt-out" rule. Speaking of opt-out: EPIC claims that there is no effective opt-out procedure, which is also a hard argument to defend without an example of someone refused an opt-out. And on this janky scaffold of arguments, EPIC wants an emergency injunction against the scanners? Don't get me wrong, I'm obviously in their corner on this. I'm thrilled if they win. And they've got some painful evidence, such as FOIA docs showing TSA required machines with store/transmit capabilities (oops!). But my guess is that if we want to get rid of the strip search machines, we're going to have to do it by voting out the people who approved them.
- oiuyftgrghjk 16y agoOf course if you were a terrorist wouldn't a line of hundreds of people all being crowded into one space BEFORE security make a much nicer target? And if somebody did detonate a backpack full of nails in the security queue how they react - more security and make the queues longer?
- SapphireSun 16y agoIt seems to me the most expeditious way to keep people safe from bomb attacks at the airport would be to have more flights with smaller airplanes that way you reduce the concentration of people and remove the queues. If you have 40 passengers on a plane and 10 of them are terrorists, then that leaves 30+crew to resist them less small children and cripples (so probably, pulling a number out of the air, 15-25 people to resist 10).
- oiuyftgrghjk 16y agoBut you still have queues as 100,000 people all have to get into the airport through one security point. At my local airport they have even built it underground so you queue for security in a long sloping concrete passageway - brilliantly designed for maximum casualties, hardest exit and most difficult to fight a fire in
- mmaunder 16y agoI'd settle for TSA employees working naked - a kind of Orwellian nudist colony. At least I could giggle back.