4 ms·
The thing about ultra-high-speed is this: your benefits (travel time) grow linearly with speed, but your problems (energy, capacity, curve radii, etc.) grow qua
by jcranmer 8y ago
The thing about ultra-high-speed is this: your benefits (travel time) grow linearly with speed, but your problems (energy, capacity, curve radii, etc.) grow quadratically.
Actually, it's worse than it sounds. Travel time has a big impact on demand--but only within a small-ish window, about 2-4 hours. Outside of that window, demand does not respond that much to changes in travel time. That means that higher speeds are ultimately about trying to bring more destinations within the acceptable travel time window, but you also have to give up destinations within that window because the stop time penalties are too high.
Switzerland has the issue that it's just too small. With conventional 300-350km/h max-speed HSR, going from the eastern to the western edge of the country could be done in about 2 hours (recall that average speed is going to be less than max speed, particularly when stops are included), which is around the point where going faster means getting no practical benefit for people. It could serve international routes, but then Switzerland is bearing the costs without reaping the benefits, which the citizenry tends not to favor very highly.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoEven the HSR that operates in Switzerland, the TGV, doesn't get up to speed until it is well within France. Switzerland tracks aren't straight enough for HSR, and it would cost a lot to straighten them out. There also isn't a lot of demand for Geneva to Zurich in an hour.
- m_mueller 8y agoI think the demand would come after it gets built. Even bigger would be demand for Bern/Zurich and Basel/Zurich in 30min, bringing these cities comfortably into commute distance. People do that today but only if they really must. There is an aspect of Swiss economy that makes HSR attractive: high degree of decentralization.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThose cities already feel close enough together. More to the point, I don’t think Switzerland probably wants the kind of growth that HSR would enable and encourage.
- snovv_crash 8y agoNo they really aren't close enough together. For example, I know someone who moved from Zurich to Olten so that their girlfriend's commute to Bern would be reasonable. Now you have 2 people with 50 minute commutes instead of 1 person with 1h45 and another person with 15min. If there was a 30min connection from Bern to Zurich it would be perfectly reasonable to live in one and commute to the other.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoAgain, does Switzerland really want to become one big mega city? It is up for the Swiss to decide, but a huge commute draw between Bern and Zurich (or even Bern and Lausanne) would lead to something more like Japan.
- m_mueller 8y agoMaybe that’s just me but I don’t think of Japan as a bad model in how to have a dense population that is prosperous. If anything their biggest problem currently is depopulation of remote areas.
- wavefunction 8y agoThe question is about density and whether that's something to pursue even if it's prosperous.
- yayana 8y agoIt's an incongruous question. Hyperloops between Basel, Bern and Zurich would make them into one virtual Mini-City. The loops would also reduce density in the travel corridors preventing a California catastrophe kind of sprawl inbetween.
- wavefunction 8y agoOn the mountains that the hyperloop would traverse? ok dudes
- jfoutz 8y agoThere is an eaisier question. Is it better to have more ambulances or faster ambulances. Faster wins every time. Analogy is a terrible argument. But I kinda think faster transportation beats more transportation every single time.
- crispyporkbites 8y agoWhat do you mean? More ambulances would mean you could be nearer to the patients (imagine an ambulance on every street corner) so the net journey time would be less. You can also administer care from the ambulance (e.g. narcan, cpr, stopping bleeding etc.) which can save lives. A huge number of ambulance journeys aren't time critical either (e.g. a broken leg) but not having an ambulance means getting a taxi or other transport which exacerbates problems. Probably better to have more ambulances overall, and maybe a few ultra fast ones (e.g. helicopters) for time critical situations.
- mcny 8y agoI think they're trying to talk about latency versus throughout. Latency matters more than throughput for an ambulance if you assume that only a small portion of the population will have a heart attack or needs emergency medical attention at any given time.
- mcny 8y agoIt is obvious to me that you're correct though. Overall, the throughput matters. There are only so many people you can pack into a single F train and it won't help much if the train could go 60 mph all the way if the only scheduled trains arrived every two hours.