5 ms·
So is it incorrect that nuclear energy is currently the second cheapest per watt all in?
by jjeaff 8y ago
So is it incorrect that nuclear energy is currently the second cheapest per watt all in?
- pfdietz 8y agoYes, that's very incorrect.
- nradov 8y agoThe correctness or lack thereof really depends on how you account for the externalities.
- philipkglass 8y agoIt also depends on how you define "is currently." If you only count the reactors that are already built and still operating, they are pretty cheap sources of electricity. The old nuclear projects that were abandoned before completion won't be part of your "power per dollar" denominator. The reactors that were shut down 10 years ago because they were too expensive to keep running will also be missing from the denominator. The late and over-budget reactors that have yet to enter service will be missing from the cost denominator as well. Once you limit the field of inquiry to the surviving, operating nuclear plants, they're pretty affordable. If you interpret the question as meaning "nuclear energy is currently the second cheapest per watt [to add to a nation's electricity supply]" -- no, that's incorrect for anywhere with half-decent wind or solar resources. The final question that prevents me from being a 100% renewables triumphalist: what happens to the relative cost of nuclear vs. more renewables + storage as renewable penetration rises? Storage is hardly needed at present penetration levels. Only a modest amount of storage (overnight) may be needed for 50% or even more penetration. But what happens at 80%, 90%, 100% decarbonization of the electricity supply? It's possible that even expensive new reactors will be cheaper than reaching 100% with storage and renewables alone. It remains an open question.
- pfdietz 8y agoTo answer your last question: As renewables, getting cheaper, are added and longer term storage becomes needed, nuclear is placed in a horrible position. That's because nuclear needs to sell its power a high percentage of the time or its economics become ridiculously bad. So what happens when solar/wind/short term storage are covering things 80% of the time, at a cost (during that period) the nuclear reactor cannot come close to, on a levelized basis? The cost of power from the nuke goes up by a factor of as much as five. Nuclear plants are horrible as intermittent fill-in sources. It instead becomes more economical to add low-efficiency long term storage options (like hydrogen) and to just overbuild the intermittent sources.
- philipkglass 8y agoYes, nuclear reactors are terrible as peakers. I think that they would make sense mostly to put a floor under worst-case-minimum scenarios for renewable power generation (like "a week-long period of intense winter cold, far from the equator, while wind isn't blowing much.") In that scenario, there would still need to be some long-duration storage system like hydrogen in salt caverns but the storage reserves don't need to be as large as in the 100% renewable scenario. The lower bound on daily generation is higher. Reactors would run at near-constant levels like now, the only difference being that they'd recharge storage systems at low-demand times. Or it could turn out that building very large storage systems, even capacious enough to e.g. ride through Germany's entire winter, is less expensive than building new reactors. I'm just trying to keep an open mind about a future role for new reactors. I'm pretty skeptical about starting new reactor builds right now. My strongest present opinion about power reactors is that it's a shame to close working units while their attached grids are still consuming fossil combustion power.
- pfdietz 8y agoThe best case for nuclear in the future will be if new designs can reduce the levelized cost of energy to be more competitive with renewables. This requires new designs -- light water reactors can't do it. It will be a long shot in any case. I am favorable to Moltex's SSR, which uses molten salts but avoids some of the more vexing issues typical MSRs encounter. Small molten salt reactors might also address industrial process heat markets, where they'd have a possible advantage over renewable sources as their heat could be used directly.