9 ms·
Through all of this I can't help but be reminded of the 2008 financial crisis and think "this is not going to end well." One part of that crisis was Icelandic B
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Through all of this I can't help but be reminded of the 2008 financial crisis and think "this is not going to end well." One part of that crisis was Icelandic Banks making a huge push for savings all over the UK and other parts of Europe ("IceSave") with the promise of better interest rates. When it all went belly up those savers realized these Icelandic banks were not quite the same thing as UK banks and Iceland refused to make depositors whole.
If Robinhood had offered this as a normal bank with FDIC insurance I would have been impressed. For now it just seems they're just moving a little bit higher up the risk/reward curve and trying to pretend the risk is the same.
- binarymax 8y agoI remember (but cannot find a citation) in ~2005/6 AIG was offering 4% saving accounts. I'm having deja vu all over again.
- benmarten 8y agoIn Germany 5% was common at that time for savings.
- elif 8y agoyeah i had a 4% account from HSBC around that time. This immediately brought up an uneasy feeling for me, like this is the "pump" side of a pump and dump or the books are so ugly they need cash deposits at any cost to make it look sane.
- toast0 8y agoThat wasn't an unreasonable rate at that time[1], I don't recall the exact timing, but my credit union was at 4% on savings for a while, before fed set interest rates to near zero for many years. [1] https://www.depositaccounts.com/blog/archive/2005.html https://www.depositaccounts.com/blog/archive/2005.html
- syncsynchalt 8y agoCDs were in the 5.10% range in 2006-2008, I had a ladder of them. Many of the institutions I had CDs with were dissolved and I was refunded the principal (without interest) by the FDIC. Compared to the losses everyone else was seeing I was more than happy with my 0% "return".
- axiak 8y agoThat's extremely reasonable for a savings account. The fed rate at the time was around 5% [1]. Today's is much lower which raises questions about where this rate is coming from. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_funds_rate#Historical_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_funds_rate#Historical_...
- fooker 8y agoLong term bonds are just above 3% now.
- pembrook 8y agoThat’s because interest rates were around that level at the time and the bank was also getting paid that much to hold your money. It wasn’t a conspiracy. Consumer savings accounts had absolutely nothing to do with the crisis. Like, on the list of “things that caused the crisis,” they would literally be dead last. Did you know your parents had savings accounts that delivered 10% interest at one time? Look up historical interest rates in the US. 4% is like average.
- geezerjay 8y agoIIRC, high interest rates are caused by an economic boom, as raising interest rates is caused by both an increase in demand for cash flows to finance investments and also as a monetary policy to put economic pressure to control inflation. Currently the world in general is very far from an economic boom, and central banks are actually implementing desperate monetary policies to jump start inflation. Thus, we are very far from those times to the point that nowadays a 3% interest rate is considered huge, as the norm is for interest rates to remain below the inflation rate
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pembrook 8y ago3% is not huge for the US right now (we have been the most aggressive of the developed markets in normalizing). 3% is only a bit above the federal funds rate right now. When you account for the investor cash that will subsidize this service as a loss leader offering, it’s not unreasonable. The only risk is we enter a severe recession and the fed has to drop interest rates to 0 again. In that scenario, robinhood simply has to lower the rate of their offering as well. This isn’t some big existential risk.
- pianom4n 8y ago> Consumer savings accounts had absolutely nothing to do with the crisis. That's just not true. A significant contributor to the mortgage crisis is that banks loan out savings that are backed by the government. Savers deposit their money with banks even if those banks are underwriting risky mortgages
- Spooky23 8y agoThat was a real bank. Historically savings accounts are in the 2.5-5 range.
- all_blue_chucks 8y agoShort term investment grade debt has a default rate of near-zero and pays more than 3%. See for yourself: https://investor.vanguard.com/etf/profile/VCSH https://investor.vanguard.com/etf/profile/VCSH It is entirely possible for them to safely promise a 3% account under these conditions. This is not at all like the financial crisis. It's just wrapping an investment grade bond fund in a bank account interface.
- JimboOmega 8y agoYeah. But MMFAs can default in ways that aren't guaranteed by the government. The distinction between zero and near zero matters.
- howard941 8y agoThis is an important distinction. When the money marketeer redeems a dollar for less than a dollar it "Breaks the Buck" [0]. Cowen's MM account IIRC was the first one to do that back during the 01 crash. [0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/breaking-the-buck.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/breaking-the-buck.asp
- xxpor 8y agoThe rules around breaking the buck were significantly changed after 08. Funds can suspend transactions instead now.
- theseatoms 8y agoAs if not letting people out is better than letting them out at a haircut. Need to maintain the illusion of safety I suppose.
- xxpor 8y agoYeah. And the haircut is usually quite small. If I sold my money market for 98 cents on the dollar in a financial crisis I really wouldn't be that upset.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gammateam 8y agoInvestment banks were leveraged 40:1 The consumer banking side of the story has almost nothing to do with it
- BurningFrog 8y ago> Iceland refused to make depositors whole As I recall it, the 340,000 people of Iceland had no chance in hell of covering the enormous amounts even if they wanted to.
- xxpor 8y agoEdited: Iceland isn't a member of the EU, so my comment didn't make any sense.
- tpm 8y agoIceland is not a member of the EU
- PaulHoule 8y agoSIPC insurance is entirely different from FDIC insurance. FDIC insures the value of your deposits. SIPC covers the case where your broker or mutual fund cannot keep operating (eg. pay the help) In a case like that all of your stocks and bonds are still there and have most of their value, but you can't get at them because there is nobody to process the transaction. Somehow the holdings need to be transferred to another brokerage or liquidated, and SIPC is there to make sure the resources exist for that happen. Circa 1970 there was a crisis on "Wall Street" in the sense that many brokerages failed, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_Investor_Protection_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_Investor_Protection... for a backgrounder on why we have the SIPC. The danger that the FDIC protects us from is even more pernicious because fractional reserve banking is one of the most dangerous things people do. By design the assets and liabilities of a bank are very close to each other, in fact far larger than the equity of the bank. If the depositors want their money out, a bank might not be able to support the cash flow -- which means depositors REALLY want their money out. The stock market on the other hand is "risky" because stocks can go up and down, but it is not dangerous systemically because if your stocks went down you have to accept that they went down. The bank is legally required to pay you back what you put in and promising to do that 100% of the time is a big promise. If people don't trust banks and banks don't trust each other then you can't cash your paycheck, get money out of the ATM, buy groceries, and then you really have a problem...
- ineedasername 8y agoYou seem to be indicating that SIPC wouldn't protect the liquid (cash) assets in the account, only reunite you with your stocks/bonds/etc. Based on the SIPC site [0] this is incorrect, and they get you your cash as well: " SIPC works to restore to customers their securities and cash that are in their accounts when the brokerage firm liquidation begins" [0] https://www.sipc.org/for-investors/what-sipc-protects https://www.sipc.org/for-investors/what-sipc-protects
- snowwrestler 8y agoThis is correct but most people don't carry a lot of cash in their brokerage account for very long. They either use it to acquire securities, or they move it out to a real bank account. So SIPC is not equipped, financially or logistically, to act like the FDIC. Incidentally, here is a really good article about what happens when the FDIC takes over a bank: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=102384657 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=102384...
- avar 8y ago> When it all went belly up those savers realized these Icelandic banks were not quite the same thing as UK banks and Iceland refused to make depositors whole. That's a very inaccurate recalling of history which you can see from reading the intro to the relevant Wikipedia article[1] and a summary of the EFTA Court's decision on the matter[2]. The case centered around a dispute between mainly Britain, The Netherlands and Iceland about how to interpret certain EFTA regulations. Iceland's position ultimately prevailed in court. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icesave_dispute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icesave_dispute 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EFTA_Surveillance_Authority_v_Iceland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EFTA_Surveillance_Authority_v_...
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI read both your links, and I don't think my characterization is an inaccurate recalling of history at all. From the second and third paragraphs of that wikipedia page: ---- When Landsbanki was placed into receivership by the Icelandic Financial Supervisory Authority (FME), 343,306 retail depositors in the UK and Netherlands that held accounts in the "Icesave" branch of Landsbanki lost a total of €6.7bn of savings. Because no immediate repayment was expected by any Icelandic institutions, the Dutch and British national deposit guarantee schemes covered repayment up to the maximum limit for the national deposit guarantees – and the Dutch and British states covered the rest.[1] The Icelandic state refused to take on this liability on behalf of the guarantee fund. Originally this was because the state lost funding access at credit markets due to the Icelandic financial crisis, but later proposed bilateral loan guarantees for repayment were rejected by Icelandic voters. ---- At the end of the day there were a ton of foreign depositors who felt like these were just normal savings accounts with higher rates, but when the financial crisis came they were in a much more difficult position than people who used domestic banks.
- avar 8y agoI took issue with the abrupt ending of "refused to make depositors whole[...]". That sounds like unilateral action, whereas what happened was that there was a dispute about how deposit guarantees should be treated within the EFTA agreement, and all parties involved ultimately didn't insist on what they individually felt like doing, but followed the rulings of the EFTA Court. But yes, it was a big learning experience for everyone involved. But that's exactly the reason it's important to make the distinction. It's not that Iceland was unilaterally callous and pursuing those relatively small amounts was deemed small potatoes. Rather, EFTA rules were clarified in a way that would also apply to e.g. French depositors in Danish banks should a similar Danish default occur in the future. What happened with domestic depositors is that the Icelandic state was free to selectively grant benefits to whomever it pleased once it became clear that its banks weren't subject to the EFTA deposit guarantees for anyone. That's also an important distinction, and is why the action didn't violate the rules of the trade area.