4 ms·
Really, the reason desktop Linux isn't popular is: 1) A few things still don't work. Vanishingly few now but still a few. 2) Linux can't be simply as good as
by joe_the_user 8y ago
Really, the reason desktop Linux isn't popular is:
1) A few things still don't work. Vanishingly few now but still a few.
2) Linux can't be simply as good as Windows or MacOs, it would have to be better for people to make the effort. And it's not going to be better. I don't think "better" is possible now (not in a fundamental, decisive way. Lots of little ways sure but, again, I don't think that's what people care so much about). An Os is just a way to launch apps and we've kind of a limit on such goodness. My desktop Linux launches my apps, especially my browser and that's about it. I like being independent of the corporate megamachine but most people would not spend the hard two hours required for this.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y ago> Linux can't be simply as good as Windows or MacOs, it would have to be better for people to make the effort. I really don't think this is the reason. Pretty much anything is better than Windows, but defaults rule supreme and Windows is what you get on your computer until you pay extra for MacOS. Ordinary users aren't likely to change the OS on their computer any more than they are to swap the engine on the car.
- pjmlp 8y agoCocoa and Android Frameworks are the only tooling that compares to Windows developer experience for UI/UX centric devs. For how much effort GNOME and KDE devs have put on their frameworks, they still don't offer the full stack experience across APIs, IDE, GUI tooling and OS APIs.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoOk. Of course there's a sizable group of devs who really don't like the Windows developing experience (part of why Microsoft has been so keen on getting the the subsystem for Linux into place, to lure Linux-centric devs over). But I think that's largely irrelevant to desktop share. It's not as if the majority of Windows users are developers.
- pjmlp 8y agoSomeone needs to write the applications those users have access to. So if the desktop market is bigger, by definition there needs to be a bigger amount of desktop devs to serve the market. Thanks to people that buy Apple to develop for GNU/Linux instead, Microsoft has learned that for many developers it isn't about GNU/Linux rather some kind of POSIX like compatibility. Since Linux seems to have replaced POSIX in the minds of many devs, they apparently decided it was better to support Linux syscalls than bring back the SUA personality. Which is something that even BSD and illumos were kind of forced to do. So given the current trajectory of Apple hardware, they saw an opportunity there to get those devs on Windows.
- opan 8y agoI guess each person's usage would change their view on this, but I actually do think it's better. You've got the rock solid shell that Unix popularized, repositories of software that's just a command away to install, dependencies handled for you across all your packages, and things are generally able to work together better due to software freedom and a community of tinkerers. If you're running firefox and an office suite, maybe you don't care too much about your operating system, but I definitely think there is some importance to it. Maybe something like a shell and the tools you run in it would be counted under "apps" for you, but to me it feels a little different.
- joe_the_user 8y agoI would personally also have the view that Desktop Linux is superior. But the problem is it's superior in a not-exciting way. Not-exciting is exactly what I want. It accomplishes everything needed in a low-key way. But the thing is the average person get no boost of endorphins for installing Linux. They can do what they did before just fine but there's no literal or metaphorical explosion of stars. And means they'll abandon the effort after a while.
- wvenable 8y agoAnd maybe they don't get any sound, or when they plug in a second monitor it doesn't work, and Fortnite doesn't run, and they can't Skype their parents. The Linux desktop is inferior in a lot of non-exciting ways as well.
- opan 8y agoNot being able to run all the proprietary software is a given, although I believe Skype is natively supported for the record. I don't run into hardware issue support, though. Especially with something as basic as sound or a second monitor. The worst I've heard recently is that some wireless cards may not be supported because they need proprietary blobs to work. Most things works out of the box since the support is all built into the kernel.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I like being independent of the corporate megamachine You aren't, and you won't be. Companies did an end run around user freedoms by turning everything into a service. You neither own nor control the software you run in the browser, and neither do you own the data. Replacing an OS won't help you if it's only serving as a bootloader for Google Chrome; if you want independence, you need to prefer locally executable software (which is becoming harder by the day).
- joe_the_user 8y agoMeh, I like being independent in this particular dimension. I use Firefox but that's another aspect. Obviously, Linux is "the revolution" but that doesn't mean it doesn't change on particular aspect of my existence.
- danShumway 8y agoI use browsers a lot. This is silly, and assumes that personal control over software is a binary state. I am much more independent of corporate megamachines than I would be if I ran Windows. - My computer asks me before it updates, and it does not send telemetry data about my files and application usage to another company. - All of my personal notes and organization is managed through org mode, which is much more flexible and portable than OneNote, which I was using on Windows. Emacs is technically available for Windows, but it doesn't work well. - The majority of Open Source software is designed to be compiled on Linux, so if you want the full benefit of using Open Source (ie, being able to edit the software yourself or use a specific development branch), working off of Linux is practically a requirement. - youtube-dl means that when I want to save a video to watch later on Youtube, I simply download it to my local desktop. No more worrying that a corporation decides a month from now to take it down. Because I'm on Linux, it's easy for me to script chron jobs that automatically download from creators I'm looking to follow, which further reduces my need to go to Youtube's homepage and look at its crappy recommendation engine. I have plans to locally host my own server that uses youtube-dl as a backend, and then to set up network rules on my desktop to redirect all Youtube video embeds to it instead. - On the web, I'm leveraging more Open protocols like Matrix to allow me to primarily run free software while still connecting to friends who are on Discord/Slack. Because I'm on Linux, developing and deploying Matrix applications is much easier. - Also on the web, I use browser automation tools and scrapers (which work better on Linux) to allow me to manage applications like Twitter without being forced to look at their crappy recommendations and ads, and without being beholden to their user-hostile API rules. This kind of stuff can save you a tremendous amount of time and energy, because sites like that are designed primarily to waste your time. I've thought about setting up a similar system for Hackernews, but ATM it still passes the value threshold for me. - I use Borg Backup (which works better on Linux) and B2 so I have complete control over my own encrypted backups, and I don't need to share the key with a corporation. - I'm able to recycle old devices by installing lighter, Arch-based distros on them. This helps me avoid the consumerist grind of throwing things away and buying new devices over and over and over again. A significant portion of my home setup runs off of recycled machines. - Speaking of my home setup, if you're looking to reduce your reliance on the web by building competing or personalized services that you host yourself, knowing Linux is basically a requirement, because at some point you will want to do something outside of NodeJS, and then you'll have to interact with the underlying server, which will be running Linux. Running the same OS everywhere will improve your development time, for the same reason why NodeJS became popular. It's just less context switching. Switching wholesale to Linux has greatly improved my life in noticeable ways. I spend less time fighting with my computer to do things. I have more control over when and how I connect to the Internet. I feel more confident about the software that I'm running. And I feel like in some ways, I am more independent of the corporate megamachine. This is not a binary "you're free or you're not." I'm a web developer. I spend most of time looking at either Emacs or a browser. Switching to Linux is still worth it. Could my situation be better? Yeah, and I'm working on it. But people who say this kind of stuff forget just how bad the Windows world actually is right now.