4 ms·
>Up to now, physics has for the most part not been a design science. But my guess is that’s going to change in the coming decades. There are more and more examp
by whatshisface 8y ago
>Up to now, physics has for the most part not been a design science. But my guess is that’s going to change in the coming decades. There are more and more examples where design seems the right way to think: topological quantum computers; new designer phases of matter; the Alcubierre warp drive and other designer spacetimes; constructor theory and universal constructors; programmable matter and utility fog.
I'm not sure if the author realizes what the difference between physics and engineering really is. In the 1800s, concepts like entropy and pressure (and the foundations of mechanics) were considered to be exciting fields of research, right alongside the construction of the first steam engines. Although the inventors building the first steam engines were exploiting the cutting-edge physics of the day, they were not in doing so acting as physicists. Engineering is not "the study of heat transfer and classical mechanics," engineering is "the application of physics (or whatever other science is helpful) to practical design problems." If a physicist were to construct or design a physical system to meet some requirements, they would be by definition engineering, whether they were a mechanical engineer, an electrical engineer, or a quantum field engineer. Likewise, if an engineer were to decide that the laws of the system they were working with were not fully understood, they might spend some time working out what they were, and in doing so they would be acting as a scientist.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoAn Engineer is a Scientist with thumbs is how it was explained to me.
- defaultprimate 8y agoScientists discover tools. Engineers use those tools to solve problems.
- checkyoursudo 8y agoMy dad was a aeronautical engineer and my father-in-law is an electrical engineer. I would say their work was not really like my wife's (when she was a scientist). The scientists in my life have seemed more like chefs coming up with the recipes and the engineers more like line cooks making the operation of the restaurant actually happen. That's probably a really terrible analogy. I don't mean at all to say that the engineers don't understand the science (I have no idea! and it probably varies from eng to eng), but the actual work I hear or heard them talk about over the course of decades seems very different, whereby "scientist with thumbs" doesn't really seem accurate. Although maybe that is more true now than in the past? For the last 10 years or so, my f-i-l's main complaint is that newly graduated engineers only understand theory and models and have zero practical experience coming out of a degree program. Though, he ... let's just say, he exaggerates a lot, so I don't know how accurate that is. My engineer-for-45-years father seems very little like a scientist.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoDepends where you worked :-) my first job was at a world leading hydrodynamics research place on campus at CIT (Cranfield) Our Boss was Presediuent of the Mech engineers and the boss of CIT The civil's
- amelius 8y agoNot entirely true, because engineers also implicitly validate scientific results, and this activity is explicitly part of the scientific method.
- fouc 8y agoThere's also the "theoretical physicist" vs the "experimental physicist", the experimental physicist is closer to the engineer, and validates the results.
- checkyoursudo 8y agoI mean, literally everybody implicitly validates scientific results all day every day, no?
- sound1 8y agoYes but we either validate what was already proven or something else for which the theory doesn't yet exist. Both are completely unhelpful for scientific progress in my opinion.
- jessriedel 8y ago> Engineering is not "the study of heat transfer and classical mechanics," engineering is "the application of physics (or whatever other science is helpful) to practical design problems." I basically agree, but there's an important human-institutional aspect to this: An alternate useful definition of physicist (engineer) is "a person who work in a physics department/lab (engineering department/shops)". And despite common misconceptions, the sort of thing that binds departments together is not the goal of the work (learning basic laws vs. building useful things) but rather the collection of techniques/tools/ideas that people learn and apply in those places. In other words, even though the goals of "materials physics" have for decades been much closer to engineering and design, there is a reason people continue to call it physics: because, at least for the time being, the sort of training you go through to become a materials physicist is mostly done in a physics department, and the methods by which materials physicist evaluate each other is closer to physics than to engineering.
- quantum_state 8y agoDid the author mean to say that he wanted to design a new set of law of nature? As far as it is known, not yet possible.