3 ms·
Per your final paragraph a child recent told me that at school they learnt "Marie Curie discovered radiation". Which was probably the child's own error, but th
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Per your final paragraph a child recent told me that at school they learnt "Marie Curie discovered radiation".
Which was probably the child's own error, but the actual story of the Curie's [1] like others of that period (Cecilia Payne-Gaposhkin, say) is one of a community of scientists collaborating across borders of geography, and sex (, and perhaps class too).
To me it's very strange, if you wanted to say "anyone can be a scientist/engineer regardless of sex" then surely you'd de-emphasise sex. Instead it's made the primary focus, often put in the headline.
Usually too these things play towards the cult of personality, "X discovered Y" when the reality is often much more of a collaboration which I find it's usually far more pertinent than whether X had a vulva.
[1] https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/themes/marie-and-pierre-curie-and-the-discovery-of-polonium-and-radium/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/themes/marie-and-pierre-cu...
- gameswithgo 8y ago>To me it's very strange, if you wanted to say "anyone can be a scientist/engineer regardless of sex" then surely you'd de-emphasise sex. It is because historically there has been a tendency for the contributions of women to be actively de-emphasized by most, that some work to re-emphasize. For sure the end-goal should be for us to reach a place where we just don't worry about it at all, but if over the last 50 years nobody had been actively talking and writing about women in science, many young women growing up would likely see very few examples they could relate to and be inspired by.
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago>many young women growing up would likely see very few examples they could relate to and be inspired by. // Is that how inspiration works for you, it's not for me. When I see an amazing achievement I don't think "oh, wait they're not my sex/race/nationality/height/eye-colour they can't inspire me". My greatest inspiration at school as a pubescent male was probably a near-retirement woman, because of her passion and knowledge of her subject, her sex being immaterial to that ... am I especially peculiar in this. Sure, you want a diverse roster of characters to study, but exaggerating achievements because past politics or societal mores don't conform to your preference seems asinine to me. [PS thanks for responding, I really appreciate conversation on this as so many appear to hold contra positions that I can't discern the logic of.]
- claudiawerner 8y ago>if you wanted to say "anyone can be a scientist/engineer regardless of sex" then surely you'd de-emphasise sex. Instead it's made the primary focus, often put in the headline. The reasoning behind this (which I'm not saying is good or bad) is that people see women and girls are underrepresented in science, or lacking role models etc. so perhaps pointing out the achievements of women in science can help dispel the notion (perhaps less common now than in the past) of science being a men's field, or worse, an old boys club.