6 ms·
"However, the legality of doing so is on the artist’s side: a concert is technically a private event..." I bet a lot more of these private events integrate mor
by mc32 8y ago
"However, the legality of doing so is on the artist’s side: a concert is technically a private event..."
I bet a lot more of these private events integrate more of this kind of technology for both good reasons (prevent stalkers) and bad reasons (prevent opposition) from attending an event. Let's say Hillary has a talk but she doesn't want hecklers. Or Cheney, same thing. That would be unfortunate use of this tech.
- jcims 8y agoWhat about things like advertising. Ambient marketing based on the known proclivities of those in attendance.
- EADGBE 8y agoBoom. Marketing Start Up. I'd start with all those ad-network TVs in restaurants and waiting areas. Requires low funding.
- bluecalm 8y agoWhat's wrong with someone wanting to ensure a calm event where they can talk about their policies and ideas? If you want a private event where everyone attending is required to seat calmly and quietly throughout you should be able to organize it. Just state what the rules are in front.
- bogomipz 8y agoWhat's the point in even having a live in-person event if you start requiring pre-screening and pre-qualifying an audience for "behavioral readiness"? For fuck's sake why would we want to start sucking the spontaneity and chance engagement out of everything?
- toss1 8y agoMaintaining spontaneity is the criterai? It's not exactly spontaneous when an organized group of hecklers decides to attend an event with the specific purpose to disrupt it and interrupt or prevent the speaker's message from getting across. As long as events actually stay spontaneous, I doubt speakers/performers will be motivated to become early adopters of the tech. When attendees with bad intent or repeated bad behavior become too frequent, then it's actually maintaining spontaneity to filter them out.
- bogomipz 8y ago>"Maintaining spontaneity is the criterai?" No but not allowing for any possibility of it is absurd. >"It's not exactly spontaneous when an organized group of hecklers decides to attend an event with the specific purpose to disrupt it and interrupt or prevent the speaker's message from getting across" Oh no not hecklers! How have we survived up until now? Yes we should definitely optimize for avoiding that at the expense of of normalcy i.e not having to be vetted to attend a public event. How serious of a problem to society is heckling really? I have never heard of "an organized group of hecklers" before. Pre-screening against potential hecklers sounds like ham-fisted to solution to a societal problem so small it doesn't even register. So please take me down this slipper slope. What's the criteria for "heckling"? Is protest heckling? Is verbally voicing disagreement heckling? Is someone deemed a heckler entered into a database and prevented from attending other public events?
- toss1 8y agoIt's pretty easy to draw the line even using your spontaneity criteria. When a group of your sacred hecklers organizes to disrupt an event to the extent to the degree that it destroys the spontaneity of the rest of the audience. Believe it or not, many people attend events to hear the speakers, and interested members of the audience, and not some randos that want to monopolize the attention on for themselves. I suppose you're one of the people that is against ad-blockers, because they prevent those marketers from spontaneously changing everyone's internet experience?
- bogomipz 8y ago>"your sacred hecklers" No. That's your word. You introduced that. You haven't bothered to answer any of the questions have you? No, you resorted to ad-hominem attacks about ad-blockers? Seriously? Grow up. I can't even remember the last time I saw someone get heckled. And I live in city where I go to either a speaking engagement, a comedy show or a concert at least once a week. It happens with absolutely no regularity. The prospect is about as concerning as having a hang nail.
- zamadatix 8y agoWhat's the point of going to a play when the script is already printed? Not all forms of engagement require spontaneous unplanned interaction to be considered interesting or useful by those partaking.
- skdd8 8y agoAre you implying that all politicians/politics are part of a play scripted and decided in advanced?
- zamadatix 8y agoMany of these events are but it's irrelevant to the point one way or the other.
- bogomipz 8y ago>"What's the point of going to a play when the script is already printed? That's a ridiculous analogy. You go to a play to be entertained, because it's a live experience, it'a performance that will always be slightly different and unique from performance to performance depending on any number of variables. In fact a play is great example of why spontaneity is so important. >"Not all forms of engagement require spontaneous unplanned interaction to be considered interesting or useful by those partaking." Really? Name one live event that doesn't presume some level of unplanned interaction? You go to see someone speak - there might be laughter, groans, facial expressions - a feedback loop. You go to see a band - there will be between song banter, audience reaction, requests. It's a kinetic ritual. You go to a book signing and there will be an audience Q AND A with an author. Please share some examples of which live events that are completely devoid of any unplanned human interaction are interesting?
- joering2 8y agoThis is not really new. A friend from Washington was hired to do IT security for few of Trump events. Initial ones they hired people off craiglist because Trump just started rolling out his third attempt on Presidency. He brag how often they got super nice people that seemed to love trump only to run them through facial recognition system on crowds libraries (there are companies specializing in high quality 4k recording of crowds of political events so that later they can be sold to security corps) to find out they were hard core against his agenda and that was their attempt at final sabotage during life event.
- da_chicken 8y agoPeople have been circulating photographs of potential threats to their security guards since photography became ubiquitous. This is just an additional tool. > Let's say Hillary has a talk but she doesn't want hecklers. Or Cheney, same thing. That would be unfortunate use of this tech. Why? Your right to free speech is not a right to prevent others from exercising their right to free speech, and that's exactly what a heckler is doing. Your rights end where others' begin. The purpose of free speech is to not stifle the free exchange of ideas and arguments, and "shut up," is not a particularly novel or valuable contribution to any conversation. and therefore does not deserve the same level of protection as an actual argument or idea.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoCome on, it’s not just a “tool.” It radically changes privacy because of the scale. A human can only scan and accurately identify so many pictures manually with their eyes. I don’t necessarily disagree with the use of technology, but let’s be honest, it’s a dramatic shift.
- da_chicken 8y agoIt's only dramatic change if the purpose of the system is to identify as many people as possible (i.e., data mining the crowd), rather than to scan for a fixed set of known individuals (which is what guards already do). It's like the difference between checking IDs for entry vs scanning and saving IDs for entry.