6 ms·
As a gamer, I'm torn on the rtx line. On one hand, it really is super expensive for an entertainment product that will be outdated in a few years. On the other
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
As a gamer, I'm torn on the rtx line. On one hand, it really is super expensive for an entertainment product that will be outdated in a few years. On the other hand, the exceptionally large die justifies that cost on a technical level, and raytracing in real time games is legitimately cool—much more so, IMO, then just another resolution or fps bump.
I certainly don't intend to upgrade, but I admire nVidia for the gutsy move, and I'm glad they're pushing the industry in this direction.
- benj111 8y ago>raytracing in real time games is legitimately cool I may be (read am) an old git, and ray tracing just makes me think Wolfenstein 3D. I assume this is a different raytracing? Is it the origin of the rays rather than coming from the 'eye', coming from the light source? Isn't that inefficient? Or something else???
- michaelmrose 8y agoRay tracing produces the best results for complex dynamic lighting. This is why it's used for example in movies. It's also normally done on the cpu which is slow rtx is supposed to do something with specialized hardware on chip which is much faster although games would have to build Nvidia specific features which doesn't bode well.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> although games would have to build Nvidia specific features which doesn't bode well. Actually, nVidia's raytracing stuff is—somewhat-uncharacteristically for the company—all done in open APIs.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI'm past the edit window, but tiny self-correction: I probably should have said "hardware agnostic APIs" instead than "open APIs". DirectX isn't "open" per se, although it depends on your definition.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- elFarto 8y agoWolfenstein 3D was ray-casting, not ray-tracing. There is quite a difference between the two techniques.
- benj111 8y agoOk thanks. According to the wikipedia ray casting article, the two were used interchangeably "in early computer graphics literature", just to make me feel even older.
- dahart 8y agoOne of the differences nobody mentioned yet is that Wolfenstein 3D was based on 2D ray casting. It’s much less common to use the term “ray tracing” for two-dimensional rays, and more common to use something more generic like “ray casting” in that case. This is in addition to how the WP article mentions that “ray casting” is currently referring to visibility testing, and “ray tracing” is more often referring to a specific rendering algorithm.
- RantyDave 8y agoThe big difference is ray casting is just along a line, not on every pixel. Hence the thing with not being able to make overhangs.
- speedplane 8y ago> The big difference is ray casting is just along a line, not on every pixel. I think you have it backwards. Ray tracing is O(#of pixels*number of light bounces). More common 3D rendering is based on O(# of objects in the scene). It's conceivable that ray tracing can be more efficient for scenes with many objects.
- Jarb 8y agoI'm simplifying, but Wolfenstein's technique is called Ray Casting, which calculated the player's view by drawing lines from the player's "eye" to objects and walls in the field of view and use that information to calculate distance and perspective. Ray tracing has been around for forever, but was too resource-intensive to use in real-time until recently. It calculates the path a pixel/light source takes, allowing for realistic lighting (including bouncing off of surfaces) and perfect reflections.
- mattdw 8y agoIt's essentially the same process to begin with (I think), but every time the ray hits something you fire off secondary rays probabilistically from the hit point to see what that point is receiving light from, and so on ad infinitum. Usually you're calculating a BSDF[1] for each surface you hit, which tells you where to cast your next set of rays. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bidirectional_scattering_distribution_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bidirectional_scattering_distr...
- AareyBaba 8y agohttps://youtu.be/SrF4k6wJ-do?t=543 https://youtu.be/SrF4k6wJ-do?t=543 This video is one of the best explanations on ray casting/tracing I have come across.
- bmurphy1976 8y agoDon't be torn on the RTX line, be practical. The RTX 3080 or RTX 4080 will be amazing. By that time they'll have fixed the initial performance issues and software will be generally available that actually takes advantage of it. Now's a great time to find a used 1080 or two for cheap. Don't buy the first generation of anything unless you've got money to burn. Get the second or third.
- Animats 8y agoNow's a great time to find a used 1080 or two for cheap. No, you'll get something worn out after running flat out for a year in a Monero mining farm.
- nkurz 8y agoWhat parts are worn out, and how does this affect performance and remaining lifespan? I guess I can see that fan bearings and the like may have physical wear, but I'm surprised that "digital" wear would be a major problem.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoShh, let people believe what they want to believe, it keeps the prices down for the rest of us ;)
- suresk 8y agoI am a little torn, too. I built a new machine recently and went with the 2080 (Stepping up to the 2080ti when they become available). On one hand, there is the appreciation for the technical achievement of something that seemed unlikely for a while (real-time ray tracing), plus as you mention, then increased die size. They look to be pretty good for ML applications, as well. On the other hand, there is the increased price and, frankly, underwhelming results. The only game that uses the RTX feature suffers substantial performance penalties for turning on the RTX feature and most people (including me) just try it out for a few minutes and then turn it off. Is the quality better? Yeah, the reflections are shaper and more consistent when changing views (ie, aiming down a sight), but they aren't game-changing and are definitely not worth the performance penalty. This generation of cards is worth skipping if you aren't building a new computer.
- Konnstann 8y agoBuilt mine with a 2080 as well, was able to get one for $700 which is about the same as a 1080ti which was my original plan. RTX doesn't matter for me but the deep learning enhancements and their effects on frame rates are interesting.
- sneakernets 8y agoCall me Debbie Downer, but I'm still of the opinion that real-time raytracing has yet to prove itself. Most of the examples I've seen achieve effects which have been imitated by faster, more portable techniques for years, and - for the most part - have been still scenes with static lighting, which hasn't been a problem since Quake 2.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI'm kind of with you, partially. Game devs have gotten really, really good at faking reflections. It's not always accurate to real life, but I don't notice. I personally do think the raytracing footage we've seen is a significant step up, however.
- sneakernets 8y ago
- FooHentai 8y ago>It has some ray tracing hardware used by nothing. Hard to fault this. It's reminiscent of when hardware transform & lighting (T&L) was introduced. Nothing used it until the cards existed, but the cards had to come along before anyone would bother coding it into the games.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoUsed by nothing right now. The lineup of upcoming rtx games at nVidia's press conference was pretty substantial, it's just that most of them aren't out yet.
- ethbro 8y agoHT&L is a great analogy. For those who weren't around during the first wave of hardware 3D acceleration (circa 90s), there was a huge amount of "X brand only accelerates this and that game." Nowadays, with DirectX and OpenGL (somewhat) winning the API war, a GPU is a GPU for all games. It seems entirely reasonable raytracing hardware and game support follow the same path. Supported in some hardware, supported in some games. If the market likes it, over time we see fewer and fewer games that don't use it. * Caveat: Things are a little different this time since DirectX 12 supports Ray tracing today, as far as I can tell. And Microsoft doesn't really care who wins between Nvida and AMD (aside from keeping suppliers in competitive bidding for XBox GPUs).
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoThat caveat makes the entire analogy wholly inapplicable. nVidia is using standard graphics technologies that AMD + Intel will eventually be able to implement in their own hardware, down the road. Games that support raytracing on rtx cards today will also support raytracing on future AMD cards.
- ethbro 8y agoAssuming Nvidia didn't lay down a patent minefield behind their implementation.
- lazzlazzlazz 8y ago> will be outdated in a few years I seriously doubt that we can take this for granted: the RTX 2080 will almost certainly remain near the state-of-the-art for several years.