4 ms·
> discover inside information >prevent trading based on non public information You completely misunderstand what inside trading means. Inside trading prevent
by nabla9 8y ago
> discover inside information
>prevent trading based on non public information
You completely misunderstand what inside trading means. Inside trading prevents company insiders from trading with the company they work for. Insider trading laws are there to protect shareholders.
It's completely fine to use non public information about world events to trade.
- enraged_camel 8y ago>>It's completely fine to use non public information about world events to trade. I don't believe it is legal for outsiders to make trades based on non-public information they have acquired from company insiders. For example, if I am the CFO of a publicly traded company, I cannot come to you and whisper in your ear that we just got hit with a massive data breach, because doing so would give you the opportunity to dump your stocks based on that non-public information.
- kasey_junk 8y agoThere is a major schism in this between the US and Europe (that I only learned about in a recent HN thread). In the US insider trading laws are geared around protecting shareholders from insiders. Solving for the agency problem. In that case an outsider who finds non-public data and trades on it is likely (though the complexity of this is one of the downsides of the regine) not insider trading. In many European regimes the goal is information parity. In that case outsiders can generate material non-public data, and thus illegally trade on it. As someone who spent a lot of time under the US regime the European model blows my mind, but in objective terms there isn’t anything bizarre about it.
- sokoloff 8y ago> outsiders can generate material non-public data, and thus illegally trade on it. It does seem (more than) a little bizarre to me. If I understand your post correctly, in Europe, I could do traffic counts at malls, conclude (correctly) something about a company's sales from that, trade profitably based on that conclusion, and be prosecuted successfully for it? If that's the case, how should I create my own opinion about the state of a company in order to decide how much to bid (or ask) for the shares of that company? Am I just supposed to blindly make investments since any amount of private research is bound to be deemed illegal? It seems that the entire purpose of research is to generate an informed opinion which differs from the current public opinion. We've found hedge funds placing orders with the presumed intention of deriving order volume information from sequential IDs that we inadvertently leaked in the shipping process (since fixed). My view is "good on them for thinking of it!" Is trading based on that illegal as well?
- kasey_junk 8y agoI am clearly not an expert on this, but I suspect the answer is not “don’t do research” it’s “disclose the result”. As for where the lines are drawn I’d guess there is a whole industry around determining that just like in the States.
- nabla9 8y agoIt varies from country to country. But in any case the inside information is information related to the corporation coming from inside the corporation. Poll results are not that kind of information.
- talltimtom 8y agoPeople have been prosecuted for sitting in on a court case and trading the second the ruling was made because it was deemed that the information was not yet public information. It’s definately not ok to trade based on insider information. Doesn’t matter if you just heard from you cousin who’s the CEO of a company that they are about to tank or reach for the moon. You might not work for the company but you are still guilty of trading on non-public insider information.
- nabla9 8y agoPolls are not insider information. Polls are information about the environment where companies operate, not non-public fact regarding the plans or condition of a publicly traded company.
- bentoner 8y agoNote however that you completely misunderstand that the US definition of insider trading is not the same as that used in other countries. In particular, there is no requirement in the UK that the non-public information originate from a company insider.
- joncrocks 8y agoWhat kind of inside information would not come from inside an organisation? Are we talking about unauthorised access of information or something else?
- ben_w 8y agoI believe the intent is regarding, e.g. “Huh, this spreadsheet says we’ve made a massive loss this quarter, but the investors don’t know that yet, I should sell all my stock before they find out” and vice versa.
- nabla9 8y agoThe key issue is that insider information must be about the internal issues of the publicly traded company (even in UK) How people voted is not insider information.
- jonknee 8y agoBut in this case they literally asked the public to get the info. It wasn't a secret, anyone has the ability to ask the public.